Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
English · Topic guide

Literature: Power and Conflict Poetry Anthology

The Power and Conflict cluster, from GCSE English Literature, is an anthology of fifteen poems grouped around themes such as the power of rulers, the power of nature, the experience of battle, its aftermath, and identity and belonging, studied for a comparison question in which one named poem is printed and a second is chosen from the cluster to compare with it. Marks come from comparing the poets' methods and the ideas behind them, not from listing what each poem is about.

GCSEGCSE EnglishAQAOCRWJECEduqasCCEAEdexcel

Before you start

Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:

Method

  1. Read the named poem and decide in one sentence what its attitude is, then choose a second poem that shares the subject but takes a different attitude or method. Contrast gives you more to say than similarity.
  2. Plan four points of comparison before writing: the central idea, one language method, one structural or formal method, and the ending. Discard any point where you can only speak about one poem.
  3. Write integrated paragraphs. Open with the comparative point, analyse the named poem, then move across with whereas, by contrast or similarly, and finish the paragraph on the comparison rather than on the second poem.
  4. Quote in short bursts and analyse the individual word. One verb unpicked properly beats a three-line quotation summarised.
  5. Always give a paragraph to form and structure: the crumbling sonnet of Ozymandias, the couplets of My Last Duchess that the Duke keeps overrunning, the unresolved cyclical stanzas of Exposure, the free-verse fragmentation of Remains.
  6. Use context to sharpen a point, not to open a paragraph. Owen's own experience matters when you are explaining why Exposure gives the enemy no face; Agard's Guyanese background matters when you are explaining the phonetic spelling.
  7. Finish with a judgement about which poem presents the idea more powerfully and why, based on the methods you have analysed.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeWriting that a free verse poem 'has no structure' because it has no regular rhyme or metre.

    InsteadFree verse still has structure: line length, stanza breaks, where sentences run on, shifts of tense and the order of images. Ask where the poem changes direction or stops, and why the poet placed that moment there.

  • MistakeUsing enjambment and caesura as if they were the same, for example calling a pause in the middle of a line 'enjambment'.

    InsteadEnjambment is a sentence running on past the end of a line. A caesura is a pause inside a line, usually made by punctuation. Name the right one, then explain its effect, such as breathlessness or a sudden halt.

  • MistakePlacing every war poem in the First World War, for example treating The Charge of the Light Brigade as a poem about the trenches.

    InsteadTennyson's poem is about a cavalry charge in the Crimean War, written in 1854. Date each poem's conflict correctly, because a contrast with a trench poem depends on the different period and attitudes to war.

  • MistakeCalling every case of nature acting like a person 'pathetic fallacy', for example a river described as swallowing a village.

    InsteadThat is personification: human actions or qualities given to something non-human. Pathetic fallacy is usually weather or landscape that mirrors a mood, such as rain on a sad day. Name the one the evidence shows, and say what it adds.

Worked examples

Example 1

Plan a comparison of Ozymandias with My Last Duchess, on how the poets present the power of rulers.

  1. Set the comparative thesis: both poems expose a ruler's power as ultimately hollow, but Shelley lets time do the exposing while Browning makes the Duke expose himself as he speaks.
  2. Paragraph one, the speaker. Ozymandias reaches us third hand, through a narrator quoting a traveller describing an inscription, so the tyrant's voice survives only as a quotation inside a quotation. My Last Duchess gives the Duke the entire poem, so his power is enacted in the act of speaking, and we hear him control what the listener sees.
  3. Paragraph two, the language of command. Ozymandias's ye Mighty, and despair is an imperative addressed to rivals who no longer exist, and the irony is that nothing beside remains. The Duke's I gave commands and then all smiles stopped uses the passive and the euphemism to have a woman killed in half a line, and the calm is more frightening than the boast.
  4. Paragraph three, form. Shelley uses a sonnet, the form of love and permanence, and disrupts its rhyme scheme so that the poem itself decays as the statue has. Browning uses rhyming couplets but runs the sense past the rhyme with constant enjambment, so the Duke's control of the form is audible and slightly forced, exactly like his control of the conversation.
  5. Paragraph four, what survives. In Ozymandias the sculptor's art outlasts the king, since the passions are stamped on lifeless things by the hand that mocked them; art defeats power. In My Last Duchess the portrait also outlasts its subject, but here art is possession: the Duke can finally control the smile he could not control in life, and he draws a curtain over it at will.
  6. Reach the judgement: Shelley's tyrant is defeated by time and can no longer act, so the poem is a consolation; Browning's is alive, negotiating a new marriage in the final lines, so the more disturbing presentation of power is Browning's, because his ruler is not yet ruined.

Example 2

Compare how poets present soldiers in the moment of attack in The Charge of the Light Brigade and Bayonet Charge. Write a model answer in steps.

  1. Set the thesis: both poems put the reader inside an attack made under orders, but Tennyson asks the reader to admire obedience while Hughes lets the soldier doubt why he runs, so each form follows what its poet wants the reader to feel about war.
  2. Voice: Tennyson speaks about the brigade as one body, naming it by its number rather than through any individual, so the soldiers are seen as a unit. Hughes follows one unnamed soldier closely in the third person, so the reader shares a private panic.
  3. Sound and shape: Tennyson repeats the same sentence pattern for the guns on each side and in front, so the brigade seems enclosed while it advances. Hughes opens in the middle of the action, with irregular lines and a broken rhythm, so the movement reads as lurching fear.
  4. Attitude to orders: Tennyson admits that the order was a mistake but moves straight on to praise, and says it is not for the soldiers to question why. Hughes shows a soldier who nearly halts in confusion and wonders why he is the one running, then lets abstract ideals fall away under fear. That questions the cause that Tennyson's praise assumes.
  5. Endings: Tennyson closes by turning to the reader and telling them how the men should be remembered, so the poem ends settled. Hughes ends mid-run in terror with nothing resolved, so the reader is left inside the attack.
  6. Context and judgement: Tennyson wrote his poem in 1854, as Poet Laureate and soon after the charge, which took place in the Crimean War. Hughes, born in 1930, wrote long after Tennyson, and his poem is usually read as being about the First World War, which gives it a more doubtful attitude to war.
  7. Final answer: Tennyson presents the attack as a duty to be admired, while Hughes presents it as one man's terror in which ideals fall away. For a question about the experience of the moment of attack, Hughes's close, broken treatment is the more immediate.

Practice questions

Q1Which poems in the cluster would you pair with Storm on the Island, and why?Show answer

Answer: Exposure, since both present nature as an active enemy and both undercut human preparation. Alternatively The Prelude extract, where nature humbles a confident speaker. The pairing works because the comparison can be about the attitude to nature's power, not just its presence.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q2Explain the effect of the phonetic spelling in Checking Out Me History.Show answer

Answer: It writes the speaker's Caribbean voice into the poem rather than translating it into standard English, so the form performs the reclaiming of identity that the content demands. It also forces the reader to hear the voice the education system left out.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q3Why is the sonnet form significant in Ozymandias?Show answer

Answer: The sonnet is associated with love and with permanence, so using it for a ruined monument is ironic. Shelley also breaks the conventional rhyme scheme, so the form is itself decaying, which reinforces the poem's argument about what time does to power.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q4How does Remains present the aftermath of violence differently from The Charge of the Light Brigade?Show answer

Answer: Tennyson uses insistent dactylic rhythm and repetition to make the charge collective, glorious and public, honouring the six hundred. Armitage uses a colloquial single voice, present tense and fragmented free verse to make one killing private and unending, so the dead man is not left behind in the country where he was shot but carried home in the speaker's mind.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q5Give two poems in the cluster about memory and absence rather than combat itself, and name a method in each.Show answer

Answer: Poppies uses domestic and textile imagery, and a mother's voice, so the loss is felt through ordinary objects. Kamikaze uses an embedded narrative told by a daughter, so the pilot's story reaches us second hand, which enacts the family's refusal to speak to him.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q6What is the risk of writing a paragraph on poem A and then a paragraph on poem B?Show answer

Answer: It produces two mini-essays rather than a comparison, and the comparison marks are the ones the question is testing. Paragraphs should be organised by point of comparison, moving between both poems inside each one.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q7How should context be used in a Power and Conflict answer?Show answer

Answer: As part of the analysis of a specific choice. Say that Owen writes from the trenches and therefore refuses the enemy a face because the real antagonist is the weather, rather than opening with a biography of Owen before mentioning the poem.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a English exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • Learn each poem's speaker and situation in one sentence (who is speaking, to whom, and about what moment). It lets you place any printed poem quickly and choose a second poem that contrasts with it.
  • Look for a contrast in voice when you choose your second poem, such as a participant against an observer or 'we' against 'I'. A difference of voice gives you comparison points that run through the whole answer.
  • Keep quotations short and exact. Where you cannot recall a line word for word, refer to the image or the moment instead of guessing the wording.
Q1[30 marks]One poem from the cluster is printed on the exam paper. Compare how poets present the effects of conflict on the people who survive it, in that poem and one other poem from Power and Conflict.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 30 available

Got it right?
Q2[30 marks]Compare how poets present ideas about the power of nature in one named poem from Power and Conflict and one other poem from the cluster.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 30 available

Got it right?

See real English past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

This topic in real past papers

We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the Literature: Power and Conflict Poetry Anthology worksheet pack - 7 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This topic is chapter 11 of GCSE English Literature Essentials, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 3 of GCSE English Literature Topic Workbook 2, a free printable practice book.

Other versions of this worksheet:

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on Literature: Power and Conflict Poetry Anthology, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.