Atomic Structure and the Development of the Model
The model of the atom has changed as new experimental evidence appeared: atoms were once thought to be indivisible spheres until the discovery of the electron led to the plum pudding model, a ball of positive charge with negative electrons embedded in it. The alpha particle scattering experiment then showed that an atom is mostly empty space with its mass and positive charge concentrated in a tiny nucleus, Bohr showed electrons orbit at specific energy levels, and Chadwick later provided evidence for the neutron.
Method
- Learn the sequence in order with the evidence attached to each step, because a question about the model is really a question about evidence: indivisible sphere, then plum pudding after the electron was discovered, then the nuclear model after alpha scattering, then Bohr's energy levels, then protons, then the neutron.
- Describe the alpha scattering observations before the conclusions: most alpha particles passed straight through the gold foil, some were deflected through small angles, and a very small number were deflected through more than 90 degrees.
- Draw each conclusion from its own observation: passing straight through means the atom is mostly empty space; large deflections mean there is a concentrated positive charge that repels the positive alpha particles; the rarity of those deflections means that region is tiny; and the fact that some come straight back means it is far more massive than an alpha particle.
- Explain why the plum pudding model failed rather than simply saying it was wrong: it predicted that alpha particles would pass through with only slight deflections everywhere, because charge and mass were spread thinly and evenly throughout the atom, so it could not account for the large-angle deflections.
- State Bohr's contribution accurately: electrons orbit the nucleus at fixed distances in energy levels, and his theoretical calculations agreed with experimental observations, which is why the model was accepted.
- Use the scale figures when a question asks about size: an atom has a radius of about 1 x 10^-10 m and the nucleus is less than 1/10 000 of that, yet the nucleus contains nearly all the mass, which is why the density of nuclear matter is so extraordinarily high.
Common mistakes
MistakePlacing the nuclear model before the plum pudding model in the timeline.
InsteadLearn the order: the indivisible sphere, then the plum pudding model once the electron was discovered, then the nuclear model after the alpha particle scattering experiment.
MistakeSaying electrons were fired at the gold foil in the scattering experiment.
InsteadRutherford's team fired alpha particles, not electrons, at a very thin sheet of gold foil.
Worked examples
Example 1
An atom has a radius of 1 x 10^-10 m and its nucleus has a radius of 1 x 10^-14 m. Calculate how many times larger the atomic radius is than the nuclear radius, and comment on what this means for the structure of the atom.
- Write the ratio: atomic radius / nuclear radius = (1 x 10^-10) / (1 x 10^-14).
- Subtract the powers of ten: -10 - (-14) = 4.
- So the ratio is 1 x 10^4, that is 10 000 times.
- Interpret: the atom's radius is about ten thousand times the nucleus's radius, so the nucleus occupies a minute fraction of the atom's volume.
- Connect to the evidence: this is exactly why almost all alpha particles passed straight through the gold foil in the scattering experiment.
- Add the mass point: despite that tiny volume, the nucleus contains nearly all the atom's mass, so an alpha particle that does strike it can be deflected straight back.
Example 2
A carbon atom has an approximate radius of 7 x 10^-11 m. Its nucleus has an approximate radius of 3 x 10^-15 m. Assuming both are spheres (volume proportional to radius cubed), calculate the ratio of the atom's volume to its nucleus's volume, to 2 significant figures, and explain what this shows about the structure of the atom.
- Find the ratio of the radii: (7 x 10^-11) / (3 x 10^-15).
- Calculate this ratio: (7/3) x 10^4, which is about 2.33 x 10^4 (roughly 23000 times).
- Since volume is proportional to radius cubed, the volume ratio is this radius ratio cubed: keep the unrounded fraction and cube it, ((7/3) x 10^4)^3 = (343/27) x 10^12.
- Calculate: 343 / 27 = 12.7, so the volume ratio is about 12.7 x 10^12 = 1.3 x 10^13 (2 s.f.).
- Final answer: the atom's volume is about 1.3 x 10^13 times the nucleus's volume, so the nucleus takes up a tiny fraction of the atom and the atom is mostly empty space; since almost all of the atom's mass is in the nucleus, that mass is packed into a very small volume.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]Describe the plum pudding model.Show answer
Answer: A ball of positive charge with negatively charged electrons embedded within it.
Q2[1 mark]What observation showed that the atom is mostly empty space?Show answer
Answer: Most alpha particles passed straight through the thin gold foil without deflection.
Q3[1 mark]What observation showed the nucleus is positively charged and very small?Show answer
Answer: A small number of alpha particles, which are positively charged, were deflected through large angles or came straight back, which requires a concentrated positive charge in a very small volume.
Q4[1 mark]What did Bohr add to the nuclear model?Show answer
Answer: That electrons orbit the nucleus at specific fixed distances, in energy levels, supported by calculations that agreed with experimental observations.
Q5[2 marks]Who provided the evidence for the existence of the neutron, and roughly when relative to the nuclear model?Show answer
Answer: Chadwick, about twenty years after the nuclear model was accepted.
Q6[1 mark]State the approximate radius of a nucleus compared with the radius of an atom.Show answer
Answer: Less than 1/10 000 of the atomic radius, roughly 1 x 10^-14 m against 1 x 10^-10 m.
Q7[3 marks]Why is the atomic model a good example of how scientific models change?Show answer
Answer: Each model was accepted while it explained the available evidence, and was replaced when new experimental evidence appeared that it could not explain.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Science exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Attach the correct evidence to each step of the atomic model's history, since a question about the model is really a question about evidence.
- Draw a conclusion from its own observation separately, rather than jumping straight from the experiment to the final model.
- Use the alpha scattering results to explain why the plum pudding model failed, not just that it was wrong.
Q1[6 marks]Describe the alpha particle scattering experiment and explain how its results led to the nuclear model of the atom.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[4 marks]Explain why the plum pudding model was replaced, and what this shows about how scientific models develop.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
See real GCSE Science past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- OCR GCSE Physics past papers: 30 questions across 21 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- OCR GCSE Combined Science past papers: 28 questions across 22 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- AQA GCSE Physics past papers: 7 questions across 5 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- AQA GCSE Combined Science past papers: 2 questions across 2 papers, latest tagged June 2019
- Edexcel GCSE Combined Science past papers: 2 questions across 2 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- Edexcel GCSE Physics past papers: 2 questions across 2 papers, latest tagged June 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Atomic Structure and the Development of the Model worksheet pack - 9 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 26 of GCSE Physics Essentials, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 4 of GCSE Physics Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 11 of GCSE Physics 10-Minute Tests, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: