Recognising Misleading Graphs (Foundation)
Recognising misleading graphs is the skill of spotting ways that a chart has been drawn to give a false or exaggerated impression of the data, such as a truncated axis, an inconsistent scale, or a misleading choice of chart type. Exam questions usually show a graph and ask you to identify and explain what makes it misleading.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Check whether the vertical axis starts at zero; if it starts higher up, small differences between bars look much bigger than they really are.
- Check that the scale on each axis is consistent, with equal gaps representing equal amounts, since an uneven scale distorts the pattern shown.
- Check that 3D effects, or images of different sizes, have not been used to make one category appear larger than its value shows, which is common in pictograms and 3D bar or pie charts.
- Check that a pie chart's sectors actually add up to 100% of the data and are drawn in proportion to their percentages.
- Check that axis labels, units and a title are given, since a graph without them can be interpreted in a misleading way.
- Compare what the graph looks like it shows against what the actual numbers show, and describe the specific feature causing the false impression.
Common mistakes
MistakeCalling a graph misleading just because two bars look very different in height, without first checking whether the vertical axis starts at zero in equal steps.
InsteadA big difference in bar height is genuine when the axis starts at 0 and the steps are equal. Check the axis first, and call a graph misleading only when you can name the feature that distorts it.
MistakeWriting that the graph was drawn 'to trick people' or 'so the company looks good'.
InsteadYou cannot know why a graph was drawn that way. Describe the feature (for example, a vertical axis that starts above zero) and the impression it gives a reader, not what the person meant.
MistakeReading a bar chart whose axis starts at 30 as if bar heights were the values, so a bar that looks twice as tall is said to show twice the amount.
InsteadRead each bar's value from the scale first. Bars reaching 34 and 38 look 2 to 1 (heights of 4 and 8 above 30), but 38 is only about 12% more than 34.
Worked examples
Example 1
A bar chart compares the sales of two shops, A and B. The vertical axis is labelled 'Sales (pounds)' but starts at 400 instead of 0. Shop A's bar reaches 420 and Shop B's bar reaches 460. Explain why this graph could be misleading.
- Because the axis starts at 400 rather than 0, only the range from 400 upwards is shown on the chart.
- This makes Shop B's bar (460) look three times as tall as Shop A's bar (420), since the visible bar heights above the 400 starting point are 60 and 20, even though the true difference is only 40 pounds.
- A reader glancing at the chart would think Shop B massively outsold Shop A, when the real difference is only about 9.5% more sales.
- So the final answer is: the graph is misleading because the truncated, non-zero vertical axis exaggerates a small real difference between the two shops.
Example 2
A pie chart shows how 60 students chose their favourite sport. The table of results is: football 24, netball 18, swimming 12, other 6. The pie chart has a sector of 180 degrees for football, 90 degrees for netball, 60 degrees for swimming and 30 degrees for other. Check whether the pie chart is drawn correctly and explain what impression it gives.
- The sectors add up to 180 + 90 + 60 + 30 = 360 degrees, so the total is right. That alone does not show that each sector is right.
- Work out the correct angles: 360 / 60 = 6 degrees per student. Football 24 x 6 = 144, netball 18 x 6 = 108, swimming 12 x 6 = 72, other 6 x 6 = 36.
- Compare with the drawn angles: football 180 is 36 degrees too big, netball 90 is 18 too small, swimming 60 is 12 too small and other 30 is 6 too small.
- As shares of the whole, football is drawn as 50% of the chart but is 40% of the students, and netball is drawn as 25% but is 30%.
- Final answer: the sectors add up to 360 degrees but are not in proportion to the data. Football is drawn as half of the chart when it is 40% of the students (10 percentage points too much), so the chart makes football look more popular than it is.
Example 3
In a fictional survey, every member of two clubs answers whether they want a later closing time. The complete table has columns Club, Yes, No, Total: Oak, 42, 28, 70; Elm, 32, 8, 40; Total, 74, 36, 110. A bar chart accurately plots the Yes counts, with a vertical axis starting at zero in equal steps. Its caption says, 'A greater proportion of Oak members want a later closing time than Elm members.' Use the table to check the caption and suggest a fairer graph for comparing proportions.
- Read the group totals as well as the Yes counts: Oak has 70 members and Elm has 40. The two bars compare counts from unequal group sizes.
- Calculate Oak's proportion saying Yes: 42 / 70 = 3/5 = 60%.
- Calculate Elm's proportion saying Yes: 32 / 40 = 4/5 = 80%.
- Oak has more Yes responses, since 42 is greater than 32, but Elm has the greater proportion, since 80% is greater than 60%. A correct count chart does not support the caption's claim about proportions.
- Final answer: the caption is misleading. Oak's Yes proportion is 60% and Elm's is 80%. For this comparison, plot percentage saying Yes for each club on a vertical axis starting at zero with equal steps, and label the group totals. The supplied count chart can still be used to compare numbers of Yes responses.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]A bar chart's vertical axis runs from 0 to 10 in equal steps of 2. Is this axis likely to be misleading?Show answer
Answer: No - it starts at zero with equal, consistent steps, so it fairly represents the data.
Q2[2 marks]A pictogram uses one whole apple symbol to represent 10 apples sold, but one row shows a half apple symbol with no key given for partial symbols. Why could this be misleading?Show answer
Answer: Without a key explaining what the half symbol means, the reader cannot tell exactly how many apples it stands for.
Q3[1 mark]A pie chart is drawn showing 3 sectors that look visually equal in size, but the data is 50%, 30% and 20%. What is wrong?Show answer
Answer: The sectors have not been drawn in proportion to the percentages, so the chart misrepresents how the data is split.
Q4[2 marks]A line graph's horizontal (time) axis has unequal gaps between the years labelled: 2010, 2011, 2015, 2016. Why could this mislead a reader?Show answer
Answer: Equal spacing on the axis should represent equal time gaps; unequal gaps for unequal time intervals distort the trend shown.
Q5[2 marks]A 3D pie chart is used to show market share. Explain why 3D charts can be misleading.Show answer
Answer: The 3D perspective can make sectors at the front appear larger than they actually are relative to sectors at the back, distorting the true proportions.
Q6[2 marks]A newspaper bar chart showing company profit over 5 years has no vertical axis labels or scale, just bars of different heights. Explain the problem with this.Show answer
Answer: Without a labelled scale, the reader cannot tell the actual values, only a vague impression of relative size, so the bars could be drawn to exaggerate a trend.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Statistics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Check in the same order each time: axes and scale, labels and key, symbols and shapes, then whether all the data is shown. This stops one obvious fault hiding a second one.
- When asked how to improve a graph, give one fix for each fault you named, such as an axis that starts at 0 in equal steps, or a title and labelled axes with units.
Q1[2 marks]A bar chart comparing rainfall in two months has a vertical axis that starts at 50mm instead of 0mm. Explain why this could give a misleading impression of the data.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 2 available
Q2[3 marks]A pictogram shows the number of cars sold by a dealership over 3 months, using a picture of a car to represent 5 cars. In March, 2.5 car symbols are shown but there is no key stating what a half-symbol means, and the car symbols get physically larger for later months even though each still represents 5 cars. (a) Identify two separate features of this pictogram that could mislead a reader. (b) State what should be added to fix one of these problems.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
Q3[4 marks]A line graph shows a company's yearly profit. The vertical axis jumps from 0 to 100 in a small first gap, then continues in equal steps of 10 above that, and the line rises steeply near the bottom of the axis. (a) Identify the misleading feature of this axis. (b) Explain the effect this has on how the trend appears. (c) Suggest how the graph should be redrawn to avoid this problem.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
See real GCSE Statistics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- AQA GCSE Statistics past papers: 4 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- Edexcel GCSE Statistics past papers: 2 questions across 2 papers, latest tagged June 2023
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Recognising Misleading Graphs (Foundation) worksheet pack - 32 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 12 of GCSE Statistics Foundation Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 4 of GCSE Statistics Foundation Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 12 of GCSE Statistics Foundation 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: