Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
GCSE Statistics · Topic guide

Crude and Standardised Rates

Crude and standardised rates are two ways of measuring how often an event, such as death or birth, occurs within a population. A crude rate simply divides the number of events by the total population, usually multiplied by 1000, while a standardised rate adjusts for differences in population structure, such as age, so that populations with different structures can be compared fairly.

HigherIndex NumbersEdexcelAQACCEA

Before you start

Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:

Method

  1. For a crude rate, divide the total number of events (for example deaths) in a population by the total population size, then multiply by 1000 (or the base stated in the question, such as per 100,000) to give a rate per head.
  2. Recognise that a crude rate does not account for the population's structure, so crude rates from two populations with very different age profiles (for example an area with many elderly people compared with one with mostly young people) can be misleading to compare directly.
  3. To find a standardised rate, apply the age-specific rate for each age band of the population being studied to the corresponding number of people in a given standard population.
  4. Sum the expected number of events across all age bands to find the total expected events for the standard population.
  5. Divide the total expected events by the total size of the standard population, then multiply by 1000 (or the stated base), to get the standardised rate.
  6. Compare standardised rates, rather than crude rates, between populations, since standardisation removes the effect of differing population structures.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeForgetting to multiply by 1000 (or the base stated in the question) as the final step, leaving the rate as a tiny decimal such as 0.006.

    InsteadAlways multiply by the stated base as the last step: for 252 deaths in a population of 42,000, 252/42,000 = 0.006, and multiplying by 1000 gives the rate as 6 per 1000, not 0.006.

  • MistakeWhen calculating expected deaths for standardisation, applying an age-specific rate to the town's own real population for that age band, instead of the standard population's figure for that band.

    InsteadAlways multiply the age-specific rate by the standard population's figure for that band: a rate of 20 per 1000 applied to a standard population of 3000 in that band gives 20/1000 x 3000 = 60 expected deaths, not 100, from wrongly using a real population of 5000 instead.

  • MistakeMultiplying by 1000 out of habit even when the question asks for a rate per 100,000 or some other stated base.

    InsteadUse whichever base the question states: for 15 deaths in a population of 500,000, a rate per 100,000 is (15/500,000) x 100,000 = 3 per 100,000, not (15/500,000) x 1000 = 0.03, which wrongly applies the default base of 1000.

Worked examples

Example 1

In a town, there were 240 deaths in a population of 60,000 during one year. Calculate the crude death rate per 1000 people.

  1. Crude rate = (number of deaths / population) x 1000.
  2. Crude rate = (240/60000) x 1000.
  3. Crude rate = 4.
  4. Final answer: 4 deaths per 1000 people.

Example 2

For a comparison of death rates, a standard population is split into three age bands: under 40 (standard population 15,000), 40-64 (standard population 5,000), 65 or over (standard population 2,500). For the town of Elmwood, the age-specific death rate is 3 per 1000 for under 40, r per 1000 for 40-64, and 44 per 1000 for 65 or over. Given that Elmwood's standardised death rate is 10 per 1000, find r.

  1. Total standard population = 15,000 + 5,000 + 2,500 = 22,500.
  2. Total expected deaths, from the standardised rate, = (10/1000) x 22,500 = 225.
  3. Expected deaths under 40 = (3/1000) x 15,000 = 45.
  4. Expected deaths 65 or over = (44/1000) x 2,500 = 110.
  5. Expected deaths for 40-64 = 225 - 45 - 110 = 70.
  6. r = (70/5,000) x 1000 = 14.
  7. Final answer: r = 14 deaths per 1000 for the 40-64 age band.

Example 3

Two fictional districts have these age-specific death rates per 1000 people. The common standard population has 9,000 people under 60 and 3,000 people aged 60 or over. District A rates are 6 under 60 and 26 aged 60 or over. District B rates are 7 under 60 and 24 aged 60 or over. Their actual populations are: District A, 6,000 under 60 and 6,000 aged 60 or over; District B, 24,000 under 60 and 6,000 aged 60 or over. Which district has the higher crude rate, and which has the higher standardised rate using the common age distribution? Show the calculations and explain why the comparison reverses.

  1. District A has (6/1000) x 6,000 = 36 expected deaths under 60 and (26/1000) x 6,000 = 156 aged 60 or over. Its crude rate is (192/12,000) x 1000 = 16 per 1000.
  2. District B has (7/1000) x 24,000 = 168 expected deaths under 60 and (24/1000) x 6,000 = 144 aged 60 or over. Its crude rate is (312/30,000) x 1000 = 10.4 per 1000, so District A has the higher crude rate.
  3. Apply both sets of age-specific rates to the common standard population. District A gives (6/1000) x 9,000 = 54 and (26/1000) x 3,000 = 78, totalling 132 expected deaths.
  4. District B gives (7/1000) x 9,000 = 63 and (24/1000) x 3,000 = 72, totalling 135 expected deaths.
  5. The standard population totals 12,000, so the standardised rates are (132/12,000) x 1000 = 11 per 1000 for District A and (135/12,000) x 1000 = 11.25 per 1000 for District B. District A has a larger proportion in the older band, where both districts have higher rates. This raises its crude rate. Standardisation gives both districts the same age weights, removing that difference in age structure.
  6. Final answer: District A has the higher crude rate (16 versus 10.4 per 1000), but District B has the higher standardised rate (11.25 versus 11 per 1000). The ranking reverses when both sets of rates use the common age distribution.

Practice questions

Q1[1 mark]A city had 350 births in a population of 70,000. Calculate the crude birth rate per 1000 people.Show answer

Answer: 5 per 1000 ((350/70000) x 1000)

Got it right?
Q2[1 mark]A region recorded 90 deaths in a population of 45,000. Calculate the crude death rate per 1000 people.Show answer

Answer: 2 per 1000 ((90/45000) x 1000)

Got it right?
Q3[1 mark]A town's crude death rate is 8 per 1000 and its population is 25,000. Calculate the number of deaths.Show answer

Answer: 200 deaths ((8/1000) x 25000)

Got it right?
Q4[2 marks]Explain why comparing the crude death rates of a seaside retirement town and a university town could be misleading.Show answer

Answer: The retirement town has a much older population structure, so it would naturally have a higher crude death rate regardless of how healthy the population is; a standardised rate should be used instead

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q5[2 marks]A standard population has 10,000 people aged 65 or over. The age-specific death rate for this age band in Town A is 30 per 1000. Calculate the expected number of deaths in this age band for the standard population.Show answer

Answer: 300 ((30/1000) x 10000)

Got it right?
Q6[2 marks]Using a standard population of 50,000, the total expected number of deaths, summed across all age bands, for Town B is 400. Calculate the standardised death rate per 1000.Show answer

Answer: 8 per 1000 ((400/50000) x 1000)

Got it right?

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a GCSE Statistics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • Multiply by 1000 (or whatever base the question states, such as per 100,000) as the final step: a rate of 0.006 per person is really '6 per 1000', and leaving it as a decimal loses the final mark even with correct working before it.
  • In a standardisation calculation, apply each age-specific rate to the standard population's figure for that age band, never to the real town's own population there - the point is to apply one shared structure to every town compared.
  • An 'explain why standardised rates are more useful' question needs you to state that they remove the effect of a difference in population structure between the areas compared, not merely that crude rates 'can be misleading'.
Q1[3 marks]A hospital catchment area has a population of 80,000 and recorded 640 deaths in one year. Calculate the crude death rate per 1000 population, showing your working.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 3 available

Got it right?
Q2[4 marks]The table shows a standard population split into two age bands, and the age-specific death rates for Village X: under 65 (standard population 8000, rate 2 per 1000); 65 or over (standard population 2000, rate 40 per 1000). (a) Calculate the expected number of deaths in each age band. (b) Hence calculate the standardised death rate per 1000 for Village X.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 4 available

Got it right?
Q3[2 marks]State one reason why standardised rates are more useful than crude rates when comparing death rates between two towns with very different age structures.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 2 available

Got it right?

See real GCSE Statistics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

This topic in real past papers

We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the Crude and Standardised Rates worksheet pack - 25 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This topic is chapter 26 of GCSE Statistics Higher Essentials 2, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 3 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 8 and chapter 15 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 3, free printable practice books.

Other versions of this worksheet:

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on Crude and Standardised Rates, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.