Comparative and Proportional Pie Charts
Comparative, or proportional, pie charts are pairs or sets of pie charts used to compare data sets of different total sizes, where the radius of each chart is scaled so its area reflects the size of the total frequency it represents. This means a data set with a much larger total is drawn as a visibly bigger pie chart, in addition to each chart's own sector angles showing its own internal proportions.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Find the total frequency represented by each pie chart, for example the total number of people surveyed in each group.
- To compare the data sets fairly, the area of each pie chart should be proportional to its total frequency, so the ratio of the radii equals the square root of the ratio of the frequencies: r2/r1 = sqrt(total2/total1).
- Choose a radius for one pie chart, then use this ratio to calculate the radius for the other pie chart or charts.
- Within each pie chart, calculate each sector's angle in the usual way: angle = (category frequency / that chart's own total frequency) x 360 degrees.
- Draw or interpret each pie chart with sector angles found as normal, letting the differing radii show the difference in total sample size at a glance.
- When comparing proportions between two charts, compare the sector angles or percentages, not the areas of the sectors, since equal angles in charts of different radii still represent equal proportions of their own totals.
Common mistakes
MistakeScaling a pie chart's radius by the same factor as the ratio of the two totals, for example making a radius 9 times bigger when one total is 9 times the other.
InsteadArea, not radius, must be proportional to frequency, so take the square root of the ratio of totals first: for totals of 8 and 72 the ratio is 9, so the radius scale factor is sqrt(9) = 3, and a radius of 2 cm becomes 6 cm, not 18 cm.
MistakePutting the two totals into the ratio the wrong way round, so the chart with the bigger total ends up scaled by a factor smaller than 1 and drawn with the smaller radius.
InsteadDivide the total of the chart whose radius you want by the total of the chart whose radius you already know: for totals of 10 and 40, with the 10-chart's radius known, the ratio is 40/10 = 4, so the scale factor is sqrt(4) = 2, giving the 40-chart double the known radius.
MistakeWhen two comparative pie charts have different totals, dividing a sector's frequency by the other chart's total instead of its own chart's total when finding that sector's angle.
InsteadAlways divide by the total belonging to the same chart as the sector: for a sector of 24 people in a chart with its own total of 96, the angle is (24/96) x 360 = 90 degrees, not (24/24) x 360 = 360 degrees using the wrong total.
Worked examples
Example 1
A survey of 50 people in Town A and 200 people in Town B asked about preferred mode of transport. A comparative pie chart is to be drawn, with the pie chart for Town A having radius 3 cm. Calculate the radius of the pie chart for Town B.
- Ratio of totals = 200/50 = 4.
- Ratio of radii = sqrt(4) = 2.
- Radius for Town B = 3 x 2 = 6 cm.
- Final answer: 6 cm.
Example 2
Cinema P and Cinema Q record how many customers chose each type of screening. A comparative pie chart is drawn: Cinema P's chart has radius 4 cm and represents a total of 36 customers, and Cinema Q's chart has radius 10 cm. (a) Calculate the total number of customers represented by Cinema Q's pie chart. (b) In Cinema Q's pie chart, 75 customers chose a 3D screening. Calculate the sector angle for this sector.
- Ratio of radii = 10/4 = 2.5.
- Ratio of totals = 2.5^2 = 6.25, since area (not radius) is proportional to frequency.
- Total customers at Cinema Q = 36 x 6.25 = 225.
- Sector angle for 3D screenings = (75/225) x 360 = 120 degrees.
- Final answer: Cinema Q's total is 225 customers, and the 3D screening sector is 120 degrees.
Example 3
Fictional surveys at two leisure centres asked visitors whether they use the swimming pool. Centre A surveyed 108 visitors and its pool sector is 150 degrees. Centre B surveyed 432 visitors and its pool sector is 50 degrees. How many visitors in each survey said they use the pool, and what does the comparison show?
- A sector angle gives the fraction of that chart's own total, so calculate each count using angle/360 x its own total.
- Centre A: 150/360 x 108 = 45 visitors.
- Centre B: 50/360 x 432 = 60 visitors.
- Centre A has the larger sector angle, but its smaller survey total means fewer visitors are represented.
- Final answer: 45 visitors at Centre A and 60 at Centre B; the larger angle represents fewer people here.
Practice questions
Q1[3 marks]Two pie charts represent totals of 40 and 160. If the smaller chart has radius 2 cm, find the radius of the larger chart.Show answer
Answer: 4 cm (ratio 160/40=4, sqrt(4)=2, so 2 x 2)
Q2[3 marks]Two pie charts represent totals of 25 and 100. The smaller has radius 3 cm. Find the radius of the larger.Show answer
Answer: 6 cm (ratio 100/25=4, sqrt(4)=2, so 3 x 2)
Q3[1 mark]A comparative pie chart pair has radii 4 cm and 8 cm. Find the ratio of the totals they represent.Show answer
Answer: 1 : 4 ((8/4)^2 = 4)
Q4[1 mark]In a pie chart for Class A (30 pupils), 12 pupils chose football. Find the sector angle for football.Show answer
Answer: 144 degrees ((12/30) x 360)
Q5[1 mark]In a comparative pie chart, Class A (30 pupils) has a football sector of 144 degrees and Class B (60 pupils) has a football sector of 90 degrees. Which class has the greater proportion of pupils choosing football?Show answer
Answer: Class A (144/360 = 40 percent, compared with 90/360 = 25 percent for Class B)
Q6[3 marks]Two comparative pie charts have totals of 18 and 72. If the pie chart for the total of 18 has radius 2.5 cm, find the radius of the other pie chart.Show answer
Answer: 5 cm (ratio 72/18=4, sqrt(4)=2, so 2.5 x 2)
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Statistics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Show the ratio of totals and its square root as separate steps, so the working towards sqrt(ratio) is clear even before you reach the final radius.
- If a question gives radii and asks for the ratio of totals, square the ratio of radii; this is the reverse of finding a radius and is easy to do the wrong way round under time pressure.
- For a 'greater proportion' question, convert each sector's own angle to a fraction or percentage of 360 degrees, compare those, then name the group in a concluding sentence: the chart's radius plays no part in this comparison.
Q1[3 marks]A survey of 60 customers at Shop A and 240 customers at Shop B recorded their favourite drink. Comparative pie charts are to be drawn, with the pie chart for Shop A given a radius of 4 cm. Calculate the radius that should be used for Shop B's pie chart.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
Q2[4 marks]Two comparative pie charts represent surveys of 45 students in School X and 180 students in School Y. In School X's pie chart, the sector for 'walk to school' has an angle of 80 degrees. (a) Find the ratio of the radii of the two pie charts, giving School X's pie chart a radius of 1 unit. (b) Given that 36 students in School Y walk to school, calculate the sector angle for 'walk to school' in School Y's pie chart, and state whether a greater proportion of students walk to school in School X or School Y.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q3[2 marks]Explain why, when comparing two data sets of very different sizes using pie charts, it is more appropriate to draw comparative pie charts of different radii rather than two pie charts of the same radius.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 2 available
See real GCSE Statistics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- Edexcel GCSE Statistics past papers: 2 questions across 2 papers, latest tagged June 2022
- AQA GCSE Statistics past papers: 1 question across 1 paper, latest tagged November 2020
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Comparative and Proportional Pie Charts worksheet pack - 42 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 14 of GCSE Statistics Higher Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 7 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 14 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: