Comparing Data Sets
Comparing data sets means using averages (mean, median or mode) and a measure of spread (range or interquartile range) to describe how two or more sets of data are similar or different. A full comparison always makes two statements: one comparing the averages (which set has a higher or lower typical value) and one comparing the spread (which set is more consistent). This topic is tested throughout GCSE Statistics using diagrams like back-to-back stem-and-leaf diagrams and box plots as well as raw data.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Calculate the same average (usually the mean or median) for both data sets, using the same method for each so the comparison is fair.
- Calculate the same measure of spread (usually the range, or the interquartile range if quartiles are available) for both data sets.
- Write a comparison of the averages in context, stating which data set has the higher or lower typical value and what that means in the situation given.
- Write a comparison of the spread in context, stating which data set is more consistent (smaller spread) or more variable (larger spread).
- Always refer back to the context of the question (e.g. 'the boys' times' or 'class A's marks') rather than just giving numbers, since comparison marks are usually awarded for context.
- If given a diagram such as a box plot, read the median and quartiles/range directly off the diagram rather than recalculating from scratch.
Common mistakes
MistakeMaking only one comparison (either the averages or the spread) when a question asks to 'compare' two data sets, instead of covering both.
InsteadAlways write two comparison sentences, one for the average and one for the spread, even if one turns out to be equal: state 'the means are the same' or 'the ranges are equal' explicitly rather than leaving that half of the comparison out.
MistakeWriting a comparison as a bare pair of numbers, such as 'Bakery A: 84, Bakery B: 91', without a sentence connecting the numbers back to the context.
InsteadName the data set and what the number represents: write 'Bakery A sold fewer loaves on average (mean 84) than Bakery B (mean 91)', since comparison marks are usually given for a sentence in context, not a bare pair of numbers.
MistakeAssuming the data set with the higher average is automatically the 'better' one, even in a context where a smaller value is actually preferable, such as faults, errors or journey times.
InsteadCheck what 'better' means in context first: for two factories' daily production faults, Factory M averaging 6 faults and Factory N averaging 9, Factory M is the better performer, since fewer faults is the more desirable outcome here, not more.
Worked examples
Example 1
The times, in minutes, taken by 5 runners in Team A are: 22, 25, 23, 28, 22. The times taken by 5 runners in Team B are: 24, 24, 25, 26, 26. Compare the two teams' times using the mean and the range.
- Team A mean: 22+25+23+28+22 = 120, 120/5 = 24 minutes.
- Team B mean: 24+24+25+26+26 = 125, 125/5 = 25 minutes.
- Team A range: 28 - 22 = 6 minutes. Team B range: 26 - 24 = 2 minutes.
- Compare averages: Team A has a lower mean time (24 minutes) than Team B (25 minutes), so on average Team A were faster.
- Compare spread: Team A has a much larger range (6 minutes) than Team B (2 minutes), so Team B's times were more consistent.
- Final answer: Team A was faster on average (mean 24 vs 25 minutes) but less consistent (range 6 vs 2 minutes).
Example 2
A commuter is choosing between two bus routes to get to work on time. Route X's journey times, in minutes, over 6 days are: 18, 20, 19, 21, 17, 21. Route Y's journey times, in minutes, over the same 6 days are: 15, 28, 14, 30, 16, 13. (a) Calculate the mean and the range for each route. (b) The commuter cannot risk being late and must arrive on time every day. Which route should they choose, and why?
- Route X mean: 18+20+19+21+17+21 = 116, 116/6 = 19.33 minutes (2 dp).
- Route Y mean: 15+28+14+30+16+13 = 116, 116/6 = 19.33 minutes (2 dp) - the same mean as Route X.
- Route X range: 21 - 17 = 4 minutes. Route Y range: 30 - 13 = 17 minutes.
- Since both routes take the same average time, the range is what matters: Route X is far more consistent (range 4) than Route Y (range 17), which sometimes takes as long as 30 minutes.
- Final answer: choose Route X. Both routes average 19.33 minutes, but Route X's much smaller range makes its journey time far more predictable, which matters more here than the average.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]Class A has a mean test score of 62 and Class B has a mean of 58. Which class did better on average?Show answer
Answer: Class A (higher mean score)
Q2[1 mark]Data set X has a range of 12 and data set Y has a range of 5. Which data set is more consistent?Show answer
Answer: Data set Y (smaller range means less spread/more consistent)
Q3[1 mark]Team 1 has median height 165 cm and Team 2 has median height 172 cm. Write one comparison in context.Show answer
Answer: Team 2 players are taller on average (higher median height) than Team 1
Q4[1 mark]Shop A's daily sales have an IQR of 40 pounds and Shop B's have an IQR of 15 pounds. Which shop has more variable daily sales?Show answer
Answer: Shop A (larger IQR means more variable/spread out sales)
Q5[2 marks]The mean rainfall in April was 45 mm with a range of 20 mm; in May it was 45 mm with a range of 8 mm. Compare April and May.Show answer
Answer: The mean rainfall was the same in both months, but April was more variable (larger range) than May
Q6[2 marks]Two classes sit the same test. Class P: mean 70, range 10. Class Q: mean 55, range 30. Write a full comparison.Show answer
Answer: Class P scored higher on average (mean 70 vs 55) and was more consistent (smaller range, 10 vs 30)
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Statistics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- A 'compare' question always wants two statements, one about the averages and one about the spread, even when a diagram or the given figures make one of them look obvious.
- Name the data set and what the number represents in every comparison sentence (for example 'Route X's journey times, mean 19.33 minutes'), rather than leaving two bare numbers next to each other.
- Check what 'better' means in the context before concluding from the higher or lower average alone: for a cost, an error rate or a journey time, the smaller value is usually the more desirable one, not the larger.
Q1[3 marks]Two machines fill bottles with juice. Machine A's fill volumes (ml) have a mean of 500 and a range of 4. Machine B's fill volumes have a mean of 498 and a range of 20. Compare the two machines' fill volumes.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
Q2[4 marks]The marks out of 50 for 9 students in Test 1 were: 30, 32, 35, 28, 40, 33, 31, 36, 29. In Test 2, the same 9 students scored: 25, 45, 20, 48, 22, 44, 30, 46, 25. (a) Calculate the mean mark for each test. (b) Calculate the range for each test. (c) Compare the two tests.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q3[3 marks]A survey compares the number of hours of screen time on a school day for 10 Year 8 students (median 3.5 hours, IQR 1.2 hours) and 10 Year 11 students (median 4.8 hours, IQR 2.5 hours). Compare the screen time of the two year groups.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
See real GCSE Statistics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- Edexcel GCSE Statistics past papers: 14 questions across 12 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- AQA GCSE Statistics past papers: 11 questions across 7 papers, latest tagged June 2023
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Comparing Data Sets worksheet pack - 30 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 6 of GCSE Statistics Foundation Essentials 2 and chapter 8 of GCSE Statistics Higher Essentials 2, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 6 of GCSE Statistics Foundation Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 8 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 5, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: