Worked question 8 - Bonding and Structure
Table 2: boiling points of Group 14 and Group 16 hydrides
| Group 14 hydride | Mr | Boiling point / C |
|---|---|---|
| CH4 | 16 | -162 |
| SiH4 | 32 | -112 |
| GeH4 | 77 | -88 |
| SnH4 | 123 | -52 |
| Group 16 hydride | Mr | Boiling point / C |
|---|---|---|
| H2O | 18 | 100 |
| H2S | 34 | -60 |
| H2Se | 81 | -41 |
| H2Te | 130 | -2 |
Explain, using ideas about intermolecular forces, why the boiling points of the Group 14 hydrides increase steadily down the group, but the boiling point of H2O is anomalously high compared with the trend shown by the other Group 16 hydrides.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 5-6 | Level 3 A full and coherent explanation addressing both patterns: correctly identifies that the Group 14 hydrides are non-polar, symmetrical (tetrahedral) molecules held together only by London (dispersion) forces, and correctly explains that these forces strengthen down the group as the number of electrons (and Mr) increases; and correctly identifies that H2O (unlike H2S, H2Se, H2Te) can form hydrogen bonds, because its H atoms are bonded directly to the small, highly electronegative O atom which has lone pairs available, and explains that hydrogen bonds are much stronger than the London and permanent dipole-dipole forces present in the other Group 16 hydrides, requiring significantly more energy to overcome and giving H2O an anomalously high boiling point. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 The explanation addresses most of the required chemistry for both patterns but is incomplete in at least one respect (for example, does not fully explain why H2O can hydrogen bond and H2S cannot, or omits reference to the number of electrons/Mr in the Group 14 trend), or contains minor inaccuracies; both the Group 14 trend and the Group 16 anomaly are attempted. |
| 1-2 | Level 1 A basic or partial explanation with limited use of correct terminology; may address only one of the two patterns (for example, only explains the Group 14 trend, or only states "hydrogen bonding" without further detail linking it to boiling point). |
| 0 | Level 0 No relevant chemistry, or the answer does not relate to the question. |
- Indicative content:
- The Group 14 hydrides (CH4, SiH4, GeH4, SnH4) are non-polar, symmetrical, tetrahedral molecules with no permanent dipole, so the only intermolecular force present between them is London (dispersion) forces.
- The number of electrons (and Mr) increases down Group 14 from CH4 to SnH4.
- A greater number of electrons gives a larger electron cloud, allowing larger instantaneous and induced dipoles to form, so the strength of the London forces increases down the group.
- Stronger London forces require more energy to overcome, so the boiling point of the Group 14 hydrides increases steadily down the group.
- The Group 16 hydrides H2S, H2Se and H2Te also show an increasing boiling point down the group, for the same reason (increasing number of electrons strengthens London forces); these three are also weakly polar, adding weak permanent dipole-dipole forces.
- H2O is different because its hydrogen atoms are bonded directly to oxygen, which is small and highly electronegative and has two lone pairs, satisfying the conditions needed for hydrogen bonding.
- Hydrogen bonds are much stronger than permanent dipole-dipole forces and London forces.
- Significantly more energy is needed to overcome the additional hydrogen bonding between H2O molecules, giving H2O a much higher boiling point than the trend (based on Mr/London forces alone) would predict.
- H2S, H2Se and H2Te cannot form hydrogen bonds because S, Se and Te are larger and less electronegative than O, so their H-S, H-Se and H-Te bonds are not polar enough to meet the conditions for hydrogen bonding.
Answer: Levels-of-response answer; see indicative content.







