Worked question 10 - Organisms Exchange Substances with their Environment
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 5-6 | (a) L3 A detailed, well-linked account that compares the SA:V ratios of the two organisms and explains, with specific reference to named adaptations (e.g. a specialised gas exchange surface and a mass transport system in the mammal), why each organism's strategy is sufficient for its own metabolic demand. Scientific terminology used accurately throughout. |
| 3-4 | (a) L2 A generally correct comparison of SA:V ratio and its consequences, but the explanation of adaptations may be less detailed, may focus on only one organism, or the link between SA:V ratio and the need for adaptations may not be fully developed. Terminology mostly appropriate. |
| 1-2 | (a) L1 Basic or isolated statements about size, surface area or diffusion are made, with little comparison between the two organisms and little or no reference to specific adaptations. Limited use of scientific terminology. |
| 0 | (a) L0 No relevant content is provided. |
| B1 | (b) similarity: all three surfaces (gill lamellae, tracheole walls, and villi/microvilli) have a large surface area and a thin (often one cell thick) wall/layer to maximise the rate of diffusion, supporting the student's claim oe |
| B1 | (b) this is because all rely, at least in part, on diffusion, whose rate depends on surface area and diffusion distance in the same way regardless of the organism/substance involved oe |
| B1 | (b) difference: fish gills and villi both maintain a diffusion/concentration gradient using a mass flow of blood (countercurrent blood flow in gills; blood flow beneath the villi), whereas the tracheal system of insects delivers air (and maintains the gradient at the tracheole tips) mainly by diffusion and mass flow of air itself, without any blood/circulatory fluid carrying the respiratory gas oe; alternatively, gas exchange in gills and tracheoles uses diffusion, whereas villi also absorb glucose by sodium-glucose cotransport oe |
| B1 | (b) so while the student's claim holds well for surface area and thinness, the specific method of maintaining a gradient varies (mass transport of a circulatory fluid versus direct mass flow/diffusion of air), showing the claim is only partly complete without this detail oe; alternatively, cotransport allows glucose absorption against its concentration gradient, so a diffusion gradient alone does not explain all absorption by villi oe |
- (a) Indicative content:
- A small organism such as an amoeba has a large surface area to volume ratio, so its outer surface area is large relative to the volume of cytoplasm that needs supplying with oxygen.
- This means diffusion of oxygen directly across its body surface (with short diffusion distances within its small volume) is sufficient to meet its metabolic demand, without needing any specialised exchange surface or transport system.
- A large multicellular organism such as a mammal has a much smaller surface area to volume ratio, so its outer body surface area is far too small, relative to its much greater volume/metabolic demand, for diffusion across the outer surface alone to supply oxygen to all its cells.
- Mammals therefore have a specialised gas exchange surface (alveoli in the lungs) with a very large surface area, a thin (one cell thick) exchange surface, and a good blood supply to maintain a steep diffusion gradient.
- Because many cells are far from this exchange surface (long diffusion distances), mammals also require a mass transport system (a circulatory system with a heart, blood vessels, and haemoglobin to carry oxygen) to carry oxygen quickly from the lungs to respiring tissues throughout the body.
- In contrast, an amoeba has no need for such a mass transport system, since diffusion alone across its already large (relative to volume) body surface can meet its lower total oxygen demand.
- (a) Answer: Full marks require an explicit comparison of SA:V ratio between the two organisms plus a reasoned link to why the mammal specifically needs both a specialised exchange surface and a mass transport system, judged holistically.
- (b) Answer: Similarity: all three have a large surface area and thin diffusion pathway. Difference: gills and villi rely on blood flow to maintain the gradient, whereas insect tracheae rely on the direct mass flow/diffusion of air itself, without a circulatory fluid. Alternatively, gills and tracheoles exchange gases by diffusion, whereas villi also use sodium-glucose cotransport to absorb glucose against its concentration gradient, so diffusion alone does not account for all absorption.





