GCSE Business Essentials 2 includes Extension Strategies and the Product Portfolio (Marketing); Interpreting and Analysing Market Research Data (Marketing); Technology, E-Commerce and Digital Marketing (Marketing); Building an Integrated Marketing Mix (Marketing); Why businesses need finance (Finance); Sources of finance (Finance); Break-even analysis (Finance); Cash-flow forecasting (Finance); Financial statements: the income statement and statement of financial position (Finance); Analysing financial statements: ratio analysis (Finance); Capital Expenditure and Revenue Expenditure (Finance); Choosing the Right Source of Finance for a Business Scenario (Finance); Break-Even: The Effect of Changes in Price, Costs and Output (Finance); Cash-Flow Problems: Causes, Consequences and Solutions (Finance); Cash Versus Profit and the Importance of Working Capital (Finance); Calculating Gross Profit Margin and Net Profit Margin (Finance); Organisational structures and span of control (People and human resources); Recruitment and selection (People and human resources); Employment contracts and types of working (People and human resources); Training and development (People and human resources); Motivation: financial and non-financial methods (People and human resources); Employee retention (People and human resources); Job Descriptions and Person Specifications in Recruitment (People and human resources); Training Methods: Induction, On-the-Job and Off-the-Job Training (People and human resources); Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory of Motivation (People and human resources).
Method recap - Choosing the Right Source of Finance for a Business Scenario
- Read the scenario for the amount of finance needed, how urgently it is needed, and what it is for.
- Decide whether the need is short-term, e.g. covering a temporary gap in cash flow, or long-term, e.g. buying a fixed asset or expanding.
- Check the business's legal structure, since this rules some sources in or out, e.g. only a limited company can sell shares.
- Compare the likely cost, e.g. interest rate, and risk, e.g. whether the business has to offer security, or repay regardless of performance, of the realistic options.
Worked example - Choosing the Right Source of Finance for a Business Scenario
Tomasz runs a limited company making furniture. He has a large, one-off order and needs 25,000 pounds to buy materials, which he will fully repay within 3 months once the customer pays him. Recommend a suitable source of finance for Tomasz, and justify your recommendation using details from the scenario.
- Identify the amount and purpose: 25,000 pounds, needed for a short period (3 months) to cover materials for a single order.
- Identify that this is a short-term need, since it will be repaid quickly once the customer pays, ruling out sources meant for long-term investment such as a mortgage or share capital.
- Consider suitable short-term sources: an overdraft fits, since it can be drawn down and repaid flexibly as needed, and only used, and charged interest, for the 3 months it takes.
- State the recommendation: an overdraft, justified because the need is short-term and temporary (3 months), the amount can be repaid quickly once the customer pays, and an overdraft avoids the longer-term commitment and higher total interest of a bank loan taken for a need that will not last.
Question 8 - Choosing the Right Source of Finance for a Business Scenario
6 marks
A cafe owner needs 10,000 pounds and is choosing between two options to raise it within one year: Option A, a bank loan at a simple interest rate of 7% per year; Option B, an overdraft that she expects to need for only 4 months of the year, at a simple interest rate of 15% per year, charged only for the months it is used. (a) Calculate the interest cost of Option A for the full year. (2 marks) (b) Calculate the interest cost of Option B, given it is used for 4 out of 12 months. (2 marks) (c) State which option costs less in interest, and by how much. (2 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [6 marks]| Question 8[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| calculates Option A's annual interest (10,000 x 0.07). | 1 |
| correct answer for part (a) of 700 pounds. | 1 |
| calculates Option B's interest for 4 months as a fraction of the annual rate (10,000 x 0.15 x 4/12). | 1 |
| correct answer for part (b) of 500 pounds. | 1 |
| correctly identifies Option B, the overdraft, as costing less. | 1 |
| correct difference calculated, 700 - 500 = 200 pounds. Final answer: (a) 700 pounds; (b) 500 pounds; (c) Option B, by 200 pounds. | 1 |
Question 9 - Choosing the Right Source of Finance for a Business Scenario
8 marks
A sole trader who owns a small clothes shop wants to raise 40,000 pounds to open a second shop in a nearby town. She is choosing between a long-term bank loan and finding an investor who would become a business partner in exchange for a share of future profits. Evaluate which source of finance is more suitable for her situation.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [8 marks]| Question 9[8 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies basic features of a loan and/or a partner investment, with little or no application to the sole trader's situation. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains an advantage and a drawback of each source with some development, applied to the scenario, for example that a loan must be repaid with interest whether or not the second shop succeeds, while a partner shares the financial risk but also means sharing future profits and giving up some independence as a sole trader. | Level 23-5 marks |
| a balanced answer compares both sources with developed reasoning on cost, risk, control and the sole trader's likely priorities, and reaches a supported judgement on which is more suitable, or under what conditions each would be better. | Level 36-8 marks |
| Specific content that earns credit: a bank loan lets the sole trader keep full ownership and all future profits from the second shop, but must be repaid with interest regardless of how the new shop performs, adding financial risk if it is slow to succeed; taking on a partner spreads the financial risk of the expansion and may bring in useful skills or contacts, but means permanently sharing ownership, profits and decision-making, which changes her legal position from sole trader towards a partnership; a strong answer judges based on her attitude to risk and how much she values remaining a sole trader, e.g. recommending the loan if she is confident of success and wants to keep full control, or the partner if she wants to share the risk of a new location. | |
Method recap - Break-Even: The Effect of Changes in Price, Costs and Output
- Note the original selling price, variable cost per unit and fixed costs, and calculate, or note, the original break-even output.
- Identify exactly what has changed, the selling price, the variable cost per unit, or the fixed costs, and recalculate the contribution per unit if the price or variable cost has changed.
- Recalculate break-even output using the formula with the new figures: break-even output = fixed costs / new contribution per unit.
- Compare the new break-even output with the original, and state whether it has risen or fallen.
Question 9 - Break-Even: The Effect of Changes in Price, Costs and Output
6 marks
Explain two ways in which a rise in a business's fixed costs could affect its break-even output and its overall profitability.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [6 marks]| Question 9[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| basic, undeveloped points made about fixed costs and break-even, with little or no explanation. | Level 11-2 marks |
| explains one effect with some development, for example that a rise in fixed costs raises the break-even output, since more units are needed to cover the fixed costs, using the formula break-even output = fixed costs / contribution per unit. | Level 23-4 marks |
| explains two linked effects with developed reasoning, for example the direct effect on break-even output and the wider effect on profitability at existing sales levels, reaching a supported overall point. | Level 35-6 marks |
| Specific content that earns credit: since break-even output = fixed costs / contribution per unit, a rise in fixed costs directly increases the break-even output, meaning more units must be sold before the business covers its costs; if actual sales stay the same while fixed costs rise, the margin of safety, actual output minus break-even output, shrinks, reducing profit at the existing sales level and leaving less room for sales to fall before the business makes a loss; a business facing higher fixed costs may need to raise its price, cut variable costs, or increase sales volume to protect its profitability. | |
Question 8 - Break-Even: The Effect of Changes in Price, Costs and Output
8 marks
A business currently has fixed costs of 15,000 pounds, a selling price of 50 pounds per unit and a variable cost of 30 pounds per unit. A new supplier offers cheaper materials, which would cut the variable cost per unit to 25 pounds, but the supplier requires a new storage contract that would raise fixed costs to 17,000 pounds. (a) Calculate the current break-even output. (2 marks) (b) Calculate the new contribution per unit if the business switches supplier. (2 marks) (c) Calculate the new break-even output after switching supplier, using the new fixed costs. (2 marks) (d) State whether the business should switch supplier on break-even grounds alone, using your figures to support your answer. (2 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [8 marks]| Question 8[8 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| calculates the current contribution per unit (50 - 30 = 20) and divides fixed costs by it (15,000 / 20). | 1 |
| correct answer for part (a) of 750 units. | 1 |
| calculates the new contribution per unit (50 - 25). | 1 |
| correct answer for part (b) of 25 pounds. | 1 |
| divides the new fixed costs by the new contribution per unit (17,000 / 25). | 1 |
| correct answer for part (c) of 680 units. | 1 |
| correctly states that the business should switch supplier, since the break-even output falls. | 1 |
| developed justification using figures, for example that break-even output falls from 750 units to 680 units, a fall of 70 units, so the business needs to sell fewer units to cover its costs even though fixed costs have risen, because the saving on variable cost outweighs the extra fixed cost. | 1 |