GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 6 includes The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument (from page 3); The Argument from Miracles (from page 8); Religious Experience (from page 13); The Problem of Evil and Suffering (from page 18); Revelation (from page 23); Religious Upbringing and Its Influence on Belief in God (from page 28); The Influence of Science on Belief in the Existence of God (from page 33); Solutions to the Problem of Evil and Suffering (from page 38); Visions as a Source of Knowledge of God (from page 43); The Nature and Importance of Dreams as a Source of Knowledge of God (from page 50); Atheism, Agnosticism and the Nature of Non-Belief (from page 55); The Causes of War (from page 60); Just War Theory and Holy War (from page 65); Pacifism and Peacemaking (from page 70).
Worked question 11 - The Influence of Science on Belief in the Existence of God
Open the included worksheet
Explain two contrasting religious beliefs about the relationship between science and religion when discussing origins. Refer to a sacred text or another source of religious belief in your answer.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 11
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | belief 1: some religious believers see science and religion as compatible, for example believing God was the first cause behind the Big Bang or that evolution is the method God used to create life, oe |
| B1 | development: this view may refer to Genesis 1:1, 'In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth', as compatible with a God who starts the process without contradicting scientific detail, oe |
| B1 | belief 2: other believers see science and religion as in tension, arguing that scientific accounts remove the need for God to explain origins, oe |
| B1 | development: this view may refer to readings that take Genesis as a literal, historical account and therefore see scientific explanations as conflicting with scripture, oe |
| B1 | a correct, accurate reference to a sacred text or other source of religious belief is made, oe |
- Answer: Contrast: compatibility view, e.g. God as first cause or evolution as God's method, linked to Genesis 1:1; tension view, e.g. literal Genesis readers see science as conflicting with scripture.
Question 12 - The Influence of Science on Belief in the Existence of God
Open the included worksheet
Explain two reasons why some religious believers accept evolution as compatible with belief in God, in the context of religious responses to scientific theories.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 12
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: accepting evolution allows believers to combine scientific evidence with faith by seeing evolution as the means God used to create life, oe |
| B1 | development: this preserves theological claims about God as creator while acknowledging scientific mechanisms, oe |
| B1 | point 2: many theologians argue that scripture is not intended as a scientific textbook, so accepting evolution just requires interpreting Genesis metaphorically, oe |
| B1 | development: this approach emphasises the theological meaning of creation texts rather than literal chronological detail, oe |
- Answer: E.g. evolution as God's method, preserving belief in God while accepting science; non-literal reading of Genesis emphasises theological meaning, not scientific detail.
Question 10 - The Influence of Science on Belief in the Existence of God
Open the included worksheet
Explain two limitations of science when it comes to answering questions about purpose and ultimate meaning, in discussions about whether science can disprove God.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: science is methodologically restricted to empirical, testable claims and so cannot directly test metaphysical claims about purpose or ultimate meaning, oe |
| B1 | development: because questions about meaning and purpose are philosophical or theological, they lie outside empirical verification, oe |
| B1 | point 2: scientific models often rely on assumptions and interpretive frameworks, so they do not constitute absolute proof against non-empirical claims, oe |
| B1 | development: this means that arguments claiming science disproves God may depend on philosophical interpretations of scientific findings rather than on science alone, oe |
- Answer: E.g. science cannot test metaphysical questions about purpose; scientific conclusions rely on interpretive frameworks and so do not amount to absolute disproof of non-empirical claims.
Question 12 - The Nature and Importance of Dreams as a Source of Knowledge of God
Open the included worksheet
Explain two sceptical challenges from psychology and neuroscience that undermine the use of dreams as evidence for God as discussed in Theme C.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 12
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: psychologists argue dreams arise from unconscious wishes, fears or memories, not from external divine sources, oe |
| B1 | development: Freud, Jung and others describe mental processes that can create meaningful-seeming dreams without invoking a deity, oe |
| B1 | point 2: neuroscientists point to random neural firing in REM sleep producing vivid images, so dreams are brain-based and unreliable as evidence, oe |
| B1 | development: such research explains many dream features without recourse to the supernatural, reducing the need to accept dreams as proof of God, oe |
- Answer: E.g. dreams as products of unconscious wishes or memories (psychology); dreams as results of random neural activity in REM sleep (neuroscience), each with brief development.
Question 8 - The Nature and Importance of Dreams as a Source of Knowledge of God
Open the included worksheet
Explain two ways dreams are used as evidence for the existence of God, referring to Theme C ideas about divine communication through dreams.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: a dream that gives accurate, verifiable information or prophecy may be taken as evidence of a supernatural source, oe |
| B1 | development: for example a dream that correctly predicts an event or reveals unknown facts can convince the dreamer a divine agent provided the knowledge, oe |
| B1 | point 2: dreams that prompt moral change or deep conversion are used as internal evidence that a divine presence influenced the person, oe |
| B1 | development: the lasting change in attitude or behaviour is taken as supporting evidence that the dream had a spiritual origin rather than being a random mental event, oe |
- Answer: E.g. verifiable prophetic dreams seen as evidence of supernatural source; dreams causing moral change seen as internal evidence of divine influence.
Question 6 - The Problem of Evil and Suffering
Open the included worksheet
Explain two ways belief in a theodicy might affect how a believer responds to suffering today.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 6
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: a believer holding an Irenaean-style view might see personal or others' suffering as an opportunity for growth in character and compassion, encouraging them to respond patiently and supportively rather than losing faith, oe |
| B1 | development: e.g. a believer might volunteer to support others going through hardship, seeing this as part of their own spiritual development, oe |
| B1 | point 2: a believer holding an Augustinian-style view might place greater emphasis on human responsibility for moral evil, encouraging repentance, justice and improving human behaviour, since evil is understood as originating from misused free will rather than from God, oe |
| B1 | development: e.g. a believer might support campaigns against injustice or crime, seeing these as ways of resisting the effects of humanity's misuse of free will, oe |
- Answer: E.g. Irenaean-style response through supportive, growth-focused action; Augustinian-style response through emphasis on human moral responsibility.
Question 3 - The Problem of Evil and Suffering
Open the included worksheet
Explain the problem of evil, as traditionally formulated. Refer to a philosopher of religion in your answer.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | point 1: the problem of evil argues the existence of evil and suffering is logically inconsistent with belief in a God who is all-powerful, all-loving and all-knowing, oe |
| B1 | development: this challenge, traditionally attributed to Epicurus (its earliest surviving statement is recorded by the later Christian writer Lactantius), is often set out as a dilemma: if God is willing to prevent evil but not able, God is not all-powerful; if God is able to prevent evil but not willing, God is not all-loving, oe |
| B1 | point 2: because evil clearly does exist, in both moral and natural forms, this is used to argue an all-powerful, all-loving God, as classical theism describes, cannot exist, oe |
| B1 | development: some philosophers present this as a strict logical contradiction (the logical problem of evil), while others present it as strong evidence against God's existence without claiming an outright contradiction (the evidential problem of evil), oe |
- Answer: The problem of evil: evil's existence seems logically inconsistent with an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God (traditionally attributed to Epicurus, via Lactantius).