The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
10 original exam-style questions - 5 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument revision guideMore GCSE Religious Studies practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 1 of GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 6 and chapter 15 of GCSE Religious Studies 10-Minute Tests 3.
7.5 The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument
- A: David Hume
- B: Bertrand Russell
- C: Thomas Aquinas
- D: Frederick Copleston
Question 1
- selecting option C, Thomas Aquinas, caoB1
- Answer: C
Question 2
- it observes that everything in the universe is contingent, meaning it could have existed or not existed, and at some point did not exist, oeB1
- it concludes there must be at least one necessary being, whose existence does not depend on anything else, to explain why anything contingent exists at all, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. everything in the universe is contingent (it could have not existed); there must be a necessary being to explain why anything contingent exists.
Question 3
- point 1: a believer might feel that the existence of a necessary, self-existent God gives a satisfying stopping point to the question, rather than the question remaining permanently unanswerable, oeB1
- development: for example, when discussing the origin of the universe with a friend, a believer might present belief in a necessary first cause as a more complete answer than simply saying the universe 'just is', oeB1
- point 2: a believer might see the universe's dependence on a first cause as a reason to treat all existence, including their own life, as a gift rather than something owed to them, oeB1
- development: for example, this could encourage a sense of humility or gratitude that shapes how the believer approaches worship or daily reflection, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. a satisfying stopping point to the question of why anything exists; seeing existence as a gift, encouraging gratitude and humility.
Question 4
- point 1: a believer might come to see their faith as reasoned and examined, rather than something held without ever being tested against serious challenges, oeB1
- development: for example, a believer might feel more confident discussing their beliefs with a sceptical friend, having already considered strong objections rather than avoiding them, oeB1
- point 2: a believer might conclude that philosophical argument alone cannot fully prove God's existence, and so come to rely on other reasons for faith, such as religious experience, alongside reasoned argument, oeB1
- development: for example, this could lead a believer to value personal prayer or community worship as much as intellectual argument in sustaining their faith, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. faith feels reasoned and examined rather than untested; realising argument alone cannot fully prove God leads to valuing experience and community alongside it.
Question 5
- view 1: Aquinas argued that since everything in the universe is contingent and at some time did not exist, if everything were contingent there would have been a time when nothing existed, and since nothing cannot cause something, nothing would exist now, oeB1
- development: because things clearly do exist now, Aquinas concluded there must be at least one necessary being, which does not depend on anything else, and he identified this necessary being with God, oeB1
- view 2: critics such as Hume question whether this reasoning is valid, arguing that even if every individual thing in the universe is contingent, it does not automatically follow that the universe as a whole, or the sequence of contingent things across time, needs a single necessary cause, oeB1
- development: this mirrors Hume's fallacy of composition objection to the First and Second Ways, that what is true of each part is not necessarily true of the whole collection, oeB1
- reference to a philosopher of religion made accurately, oeB1
- Answer: Contrast: Aquinas's argument for a necessary being to explain contingent existence, vs a Hume-style doubt that the whole universe needs a single necessary cause even if its parts are contingent.
Question 6
- the argument from motion (unmoved mover), oeB1
- the argument from causation (uncaused cause), oeB1
- the argument from contingency (necessary being); accept also the argument from degree or the argument from design, oeB1
- Answer: Any three: motion (unmoved mover); causation (uncaused cause); contingency (necessary being); accept also degree or design.
Question 7
- point 1: the argument from motion (First Way) - everything in the universe is in motion or change, and whatever moves is moved by something else, oeB1
- development: Aquinas argued this chain of movers cannot regress infinitely, so there must be a first, unmoved mover, not moved by anything prior, which he identified as God, oeB1
- point 2: the argument from causation (Second Way) - nothing can be the cause of itself, since that would mean it existed before itself, oeB1
- development: Aquinas argued there must be a first, uncaused cause, since an infinite regress of causes is impossible, and this first cause he identified with God, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. the argument from motion (First Way); the argument from causation (Second Way).
Question 8
- view 1: Aquinas and other supporters argue that everything that exists is caused by something else, so the universe itself, as a whole, must have a cause outside itself, which is God, oeB1
- development: without a first cause, there would be an infinite regress, which Aquinas believed was impossible, oeB1
- view 2: Hume argued that although objects within the universe need causes, this does not mean the universe as a whole needs a cause, oeB1
- development: treating the whole collection of caused things as if it were itself a further single thing requiring a cause is a mistake, since what is true of the parts is not necessarily true of the whole (the fallacy of composition), oeB1
- reference to a philosopher of religion made accurately, oeB1
- Answer: Contrast: the universe needs a first cause (Aquinas) vs the fallacy of composition objection (Hume).
Question 9
- (a) a first cause that is not itself caused by anything else, traditionally identified with God, oeB1
- (a) Answer: A first cause not itself caused by anything else, traditionally identified with God.
- (b) the argument from motion (First Way), oeB1
- (b) the argument from causation (Second Way); accept also the argument from contingency (Third Way), oeB1
- (b) Answer: Any two: motion (First Way); causation (Second Way); contingency (Third Way).
- (c) point 1: Aquinas argued that everything that exists has been caused by something else, and this chain of causes cannot go back forever, oeB1
- (c) development: he reasoned that if there was no first cause, there would be no earlier causes to produce the effects we see today, and so nothing would exist now, which is false, since things clearly do exist, oeB1
- (c) point 2: Aquinas argued that if the chain of causes had no beginning, there would be no explanation for why the universe exists at all, rather than nothing, oeB1
- (c) development: positing an uncaused first cause avoids this problem, since a cause that is itself uncaused would not require a further explanation, and Aquinas identified this first cause with God, oeB1
- (c) Answer: E.g. an infinite regress would leave nothing to explain why things exist now; an uncaused first cause avoids needing a further explanation.
- (d) view 1: Hume argued we only have grounds to say individual things within the universe need causes, because we have repeated experience of similar things being caused; we have no such experience of universes, so cannot assume the universe as a whole needs one (the fallacy of composition), oeB1
- (d) development: Bertrand Russell, in his 1948 BBC radio debate with Frederick Copleston, developed a similar point, arguing the universe could simply be a fact that exists without further explanation, and that it is a mistake to assume everything, including the universe as a totality, must have a cause, oeB1
- (d) view 2: other philosophers argue Hume's objection does not remove the force of the question of why anything exists at all rather than nothing, and that a first cause remains the most reasonable explanation for a contingent, causally-ordered universe, oeB1
- (d) development: some point out that modern cosmology, which holds the universe had a beginning (e.g. the Big Bang), fits comfortably with the idea that the universe itself began to exist and so needed a cause, which they argue supports rather than undermines Aquinas's reasoning, oeB1
- (d) reference to a philosopher of religion made accurately, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Contrast: Hume/Russell's 'brute fact' objection vs the view that a first cause remains the best explanation, supported by Big Bang cosmology.
- (e) L4 A well-argued, balanced answer that considers more than one point of view in a developed way, using accurate and detailed references to philosophical teaching to support each point, and reaches a clear, justified conclusion.10-12
- (e) L3 A clear and reasoned answer that considers more than one point of view, supported by relevant references to philosophical teaching, though the justification of the conclusion may be less developed.7-9
- (e) L2 A reasoned answer that considers at least one point of view, with some relevant supporting evidence, but with limited or no consideration of an alternative view.4-6
- (e) L1 One or more relevant points are made, but with little or no supporting evidence and no reasoned conclusion.1-3
- (e) L0 No relevant content.0
- (e) Indicative content:
- Agree: Aquinas's argument from motion holds that everything in motion is moved by something else, and this chain cannot regress infinitely, so there must be a first, unmoved mover, identified with God.
- Agree: Aquinas's argument from causation holds that nothing can cause itself, so the chain of causes must have a first, uncaused cause, which Aquinas identified with God.
- Agree: the argument answers the deep question of why there is something rather than nothing, since God as a necessary, self-existent being provides a stopping point that avoids infinite regress.
- Agree: modern Big Bang cosmology, which suggests the universe had a beginning, is consistent with, though it does not prove, the idea that the universe needed a cause outside itself.
- Disagree: Hume argued we only know from experience that things within the universe need causes; this does not licence the further claim that the universe as a whole needs a cause (the fallacy of composition).
- Disagree: Russell argued in the 1948 Russell-Copleston debate that the universe could be regarded as simply existing, without requiring any further external cause or explanation.
- Disagree: even if the argument succeeds in showing there is a first cause, this does not by itself prove that cause has the further properties (personal, all-loving, all-knowing) believers attribute to God; it might just be an impersonal force.
- Disagree: some point to features of quantum physics, where certain events appear to occur without an identifiable prior cause in the classical sense, as challenging the premise that everything needs a cause.
- A balanced answer might conclude that whether the argument proves God's existence, or only makes belief in a first cause reasonable, depends on whether one accepts that the universe as a whole requires the same kind of causal explanation as things within it.
Question 10
- Hume's argument that we cannot assume the universe as a whole needs a cause just because things within it do (the fallacy of composition), oeB1
- Russell's view that the universe might simply exist as a fact needing no further explanation, oeB1
- the argument, even if successful, does not prove the first cause has the qualities (e.g. personal, loving) that believers attribute to God, oeB1
- Answer: Any three: the fallacy of composition (Hume); the 'brute fact' response (Russell); the argument does not establish a personal, loving God even if a first cause is granted.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.