Worked question 16 - Reading and Comprehension (Poetry)
Poems
Poem 1: Low Tide at Bracelet Bay
Original poem written for Revision Library.
1 At Bracelet Bay the water sighs,
2 Retreating slow as sleep,
3 And leaves a mirror on the sand
4 For gulls to stand and keep.
5 My grandad rolls his trousers up
6 The way he did before,
7 And walks me out past pools of glass
8 To where the mussels moor.
9 He points his stick towards the rocks
10 Like an old and patient king,
11 And tells me how the sea forgets
12 Then remembers everything.
13 The crabs retreat beneath the weed,
14 Small soldiers in retreat,
15 While starfish freckle every pool
16 Like stars beneath our feet.
17 The wind has combed the grass to grey,
18 The cliffs stand blunt and bare,
19 And somewhere out beyond the buoys
20 A trawler cuts the air.
21 I used to think the tide came in
22 Because the moon was sad,
23 That every wave that reached the shore
24 Was lonely for the lad
25 Who built his castles out of sand
26 And watched them wash away,
27 Not knowing that the sea, like time,
28 Would take them anyway.
29 Now grandad's gone six years this spring,
30 Yet still I come to stand
31 Where mussels moor and starfish freckle
32 This forgetful, patient sand.
Poem 2: Auntie Pearl's Allotment
Original poem written for Revision Library.
1 Auntie Pearl grows runner beans
2 in rows as straight as Sunday hymns,
3 tying each stem to its cane
4 with strips of old tights, knotted twice.
5 She talks to the tomatoes
6 the way some people talk to dogs,
7 scolding the greenfly, praising the sun,
8 naming every bloom before it opens.
9 When August comes she fills a bucket
10 with beans too long to count,
11 and presses one, still warm, into my hand
12 saying eat it now, before it knows it's picked.
13 I did not understand her then,
14 how a woman with soil under her nails
15 could hold a whole summer
16 in the shape of a single bean.
17 Now I keep an allotment of my own,
18 smaller than hers, and less straight,
19 but every August I press a bean
20 into someone's hand, still warm,
21 and say her sentence exactly as she said it.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 16
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 9-10 | Level 5 Sophisticated, perceptive comparison sustained across the whole answer, with judicious selection of quotation from both poems, precise use of subject terminology and confident critical exploration of language, form and structure. |
| 7-8 | Level 4 Detailed, well-developed comparison with a good range of accurate textual reference from both poems and clear exploration of writers' methods across language, form and structure. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 Clear comparison with relevant reference to both poems, addressing language and at least one of form or structure, though development may be uneven. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 Some comparison with reference to both poems, but limited exploration of form or structure, or comparison largely one-sided. |
| 1-2 | Level 1 Simple or general comparison, with minimal or unclear reference to the texts. |
- Indicative content:
- Concrete objects and places (mussels, starfish, sand; runner beans, tomatoes, the allotment) act as symbols or vessels of memory in both poems, anchoring abstract feelings of love and loss in specific, sensory detail.
- Poem 1 uses personification and simile ('the sea...forgets / Then remembers'; 'Like an old and patient king') to make the coastal setting feel alive and emotionally charged with memory.
- Poem 2 uses personification and playful, homely simile ('as straight as Sunday hymns'; the bean that 'knows it's picked') to make the allotment feel intimate and lovingly remembered.
- The contrast in form (Poem 1's regular ABCB stanzas versus Poem 2's free verse) reflects different relationships to memory: Poem 1's ritualised, cyclical form suits the elegiac tone of a fixed, often-repeated memory, while Poem 2's looser, conversational form suits a warmer, more spontaneous recollection.
- Both poems use a final stanza in which the speaker repeats or continues the older relative's action (returning to the tideline; pressing a warm bean into someone's hand and repeating Auntie Pearl's words), structurally showing memory embodied in repeated action rather than left in the past.
- Sensory, tactile detail is central to both (the cold/damp of rock pools; the warmth of a freshly picked bean), making memory feel physically present rather than merely recalled.
- Differences in tone (elegiac and wistful in Poem 1; warm and humorous in Poem 2) show that the same central idea, that ordinary places and objects hold memory, can be explored in contrasting emotional registers.
Answer: Both poems root memory in small, sensory, concrete details (a rock pool, a warm bean) and use personification to make these ordinary objects and places feel alive; Poem 1's regular rhymed form suits its elegiac, cyclical treatment of memory, while Poem 2's free verse suits its warmer, more conversational recollection, but both end with the speaker physically repeating the older relative's action, showing memory sustained through ritual rather than simply remembered.










