Biological and Psychological Explanations for Obesity - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Biological and Psychological Explanations for Obesity revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 5 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 7 and chapter 13 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 4.
13.4 Biological and Psychological Explanations for Obesity
Question 1
- states that social and cultural norms shape typical portion sizes, dietary choices and attitudes to eating occasions oeM1
- explains that norms promoting large portions, energy-dense celebratory foods, or high consumption of convenience foods can increase average calorie intake across a population, raising obesity prevalence oeA1
- Answer: Cultural norms that promote large portion sizes, regular consumption of calorie-dense convenience foods or social eating occasions encourage higher average calorie intake; when many people adopt these norms, population obesity rates can rise.
Question 2
- states a valid strength, e.g. genetic explanations are supported by empirical evidence such as twin/adoption studies and molecular genetics oeM1
- explains why this matters, e.g. provides objective, biologically based predictors which can inform medical interventions and personalised prevention oeA1
- states a valid limitation, e.g. genetic explanations can be overly deterministic and may underplay environmental/behavioural influences oeM1
- explains why this matters, e.g. ignoring modifiable social and psychological causes could hinder behavioural interventions and stigmatise individuals oeA1
- Answer: Strength: genetic explanations are supported by twin/adoption studies and gene-association findings, offering objective predictors that can guide medical or personalised approaches. Limitation: they risk genetic determinism and may underplay environmental and behavioural causes; this could reduce emphasis on effective social and psychological interventions and increase stigma.
Question 3
- mentions that monozygotic (identical) twins show higher concordance for BMI than dizygotic twins, suggesting a genetic influence oeM1
- states that family studies show relatives of obese individuals are at greater risk of obesity oeM1
- notes that adoption studies find adoptees' BMI correlates more strongly with biological parents than with adoptive parents, supporting heritability oeA1
- Answer: Twin studies show higher BMI concordance for monozygotic than dizygotic twins, family studies show higher obesity risk among biological relatives, and adoption studies find adoptees resemble biological rather than adoptive parents in BMI, all supporting a genetic contribution to obesity.
Question 4
- states restraint theory proposes deliberate cognitive control of eating to restrict intake, termed dietary restraint oeM1
- explains that when restraint is broken, for example after a 'forbidden' food is eaten, this can lead to disinhibited overeating or bingeing oeA1
- applies to obesity by noting repeated cycles of restraint and disinhibition can produce net weight gain over time oeA1
- Answer: Restraint theory proposes that cognitive efforts to restrict intake make people vulnerable to disinhibited overeating when cognitive control fails; for people aiming to lose weight, repeated cycles of strict restraint followed by loss of control can produce overall excess calorie intake and weight gain, contributing to obesity.
Question 5
- identifies a neural mechanism, e.g. dysfunction in arcuate nucleus signalling, melanocortin pathway abnormality, or altered neuropeptide Y activity oeM1
- explains how such dysfunction can affect appetite control, e.g. impaired anorexigenic signalling leads to reduced satiety and increased food intake oeA1
- applies to obesity by stating that chronic disruption of hypothalamic signalling can promote persistent overeating and weight gain oeA1
- Answer: For example, dysfunction in hypothalamic pathways such as impaired melanocortin signalling or elevated neuropeptide Y activity can reduce anorexigenic signals and increase orexigenic drive, leading to weaker satiety responses, persistent overeating and gradual weight gain contributing to obesity.
Question 6
- outlines the boundary model idea that eating is regulated between upper and lower boundaries influenced by physiological hunger and satiety and by cognitive factors like restraint oeM1
- applies the model to obesity, e.g. repeated cognitive restraint can lower the threshold for disinhibition so people overshoot the upper boundary and overeat, contributing to weight gain oeA1
- evaluates with a strength, e.g. integrates biological and cognitive factors so is useful for explaining interactions and guiding combined interventions oeM1
- explains why this strength matters, e.g. shows why treatments should target both physiological signals and cognitive restraint patterns to reduce relapse into overeating oeA1
- evaluates with a limitation, e.g. empirical support is mixed and the model is descriptive rather than mechanistic about how boundaries shift in different individuals oeM1
- explains why this limitation matters, e.g. without precise mechanisms it is harder to design targeted biological treatments and to predict who will benefit from cognitive approaches oeA1
- Answer: The boundary model proposes eating is regulated between physiological lower and upper boundaries, with cognitive restraint and external cues determining where those boundaries lie; in obesity, chronic restraint and cue-rich environments can make people repeatedly exceed the upper boundary leading to overeating. Strength: it integrates biological and cognitive explanations and supports combined interventions. Limitation: empirical tests are mixed and the model does not specify exact mechanisms for boundary shifts, limiting precise predictive use.
Question 7
- Level 4 Knowledge of biological, psychological and social explanations is accurate and detailed. Discussion and evaluation are thorough and well balanced, considering evidence supporting and challenging each explanation. There is clear synthesis about the relative contributions with a reasoned and defended judgement. Application and use of terminology are precise and the answer is coherent.13-16
- Level 3 Knowledge is generally accurate with some detail. There is a balanced discussion with evaluation, though some points may be less developed. The relative contribution is considered and a conclusion is reached but may be less strongly defended. Application is present and terminology is used appropriately.9-12
- Level 2 Knowledge is limited or partial. Discussion and evaluation are present but superficial. Consideration of relative contribution is attempted but weak. Answers may be descriptive rather than analytical and application may be limited.5-8
- Level 1 Very limited knowledge, little or no relevant evaluation. Discussion lacks coherence and there is no meaningful judgement on relative contribution. Answer may be brief or list-like.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Biological explanations include genetic influences such as FTO gene variants and high heritability estimates from twin/adoption studies; neural/hormonal mechanisms include leptin resistance, ghrelin effects and hypothalamic pathway dysfunction affecting hunger and satiety.
- AO1: Psychological explanations include restraint theory and the boundary model which link cognitive control and disinhibition to overeating, and behavioural accounts such as operant conditioning and habit formation via reinforcement of palatable food consumption.
- AO1: Social explanations include cultural norms, portion size, food availability, socioeconomic status and marketing that shape eating behaviours and exposure to energy-dense foods.
- AO3: Evaluation of biological: strengths include objective, replicable genetic and physiological findings that can inform medical treatments; limitations include risk of genetic determinism and that genes interact with environment so genetic accounts alone cannot predict obesity outcomes.
- AO3: Evaluation of psychological: strengths include explanatory power for dieting cycles and binge episodes and clear intervention targets (CBT, habit change); limitations include some models being descriptive and individual differences in response to restraint or cues.
- AO3: Evaluation of social: strengths include good explanatory power for population-level trends and clear policy implications (portion control, regulation); limitations include variability between cultures and difficulty establishing causal direction.
- AO3: Integration and interaction: evidence often shows gene-environment interaction, for example genetic predisposition is expressed more strongly in obesogenic environments; psychological factors such as restraint may interact with biological hunger signals, producing cycles of weight gain.
- AO3: Consideration of relative contribution: a balanced view argues biological factors set vulnerability while social and psychological factors determine expression and course; a purely biological or purely social account is insufficient.
- AO3: A reasoned judgement could argue that the most useful approach is integrative, recognising biological predispositions but prioritising environmental and psychological interventions for public health impact, while still using biological insights for personalised treatment where appropriate.
Question 8
- identifies leptin as a hormone produced by adipose tissue that signals satiety to the hypothalamus oeM1
- identifies ghrelin as a gut-derived hormone that stimulates appetite and signals hunger to the hypothalamus oeM1
- explains that leptin resistance or impaired leptin signalling can reduce satiety signalling, promoting overeating and weight gain oeA1
- explains that elevated ghrelin or exaggerated ghrelin responses can increase hunger and food intake, contributing to obesity oeA1
- Answer: Leptin, produced by fat cells, normally signals satiety to the hypothalamus; if leptin signalling is impaired or resistance develops, satiety is reduced and overeating may follow. Ghrelin, produced by the stomach, stimulates hunger and increases food intake; high ghrelin activity can promote increased eating and weight gain.
Question 9
- identifies a biological factor from the case, e.g. family history of obesity or reduced sensitivity to satiety signalling (leptin resistance or hypothalamic dysfunction) oeM1
- explains how the biological factor could lead to weight gain, e.g. genetic predisposition via FTO or impaired satiety signalling reduces feeling of fullness, causing increased calorie intake oeA1
- identifies a psychological or social factor from the case, e.g. dieting and restraint leading to disinhibited overeating, or cravings for high-fat snacks influenced by reinforcement and availability oeM1
- explains how this factor contributes to weight gain, e.g. cycles of strict restraint and subsequent bingeing increase net calorie intake; cravings and reinforced eating of palatable foods maintain overeating oeA1
- links the two factors interactively, showing how biological vulnerability and psychological/social processes combine oeM1
- explains the interaction, e.g. genetic or neural reduction in satiety makes dieting harder, increasing susceptibility to disinhibition and reinforced snack consumption, so both factors together accelerate weight gain oeA1
- Answer: Biological: reduced sensitivity to satiety signalling and a family history of obesity suggest a genetic or hypothalamic vulnerability, meaning Kwame feels less full and so eats more. Psychological/social: repeated strict dieting and resultant restraint followed by disinhibited overeating, together with cravings for high-fat snacks that are readily available and rewarding, increase calorie intake. Interaction: the biological tendency to weak satiety makes dieting more likely to fail and increases the impact of cravings and reinforcement, so the combination explains sustained weight gain.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.