Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 6 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 6 and chapter 25 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 3.
9.6 Duck's Phase Model of Relationship Breakdown
Question 1
- identifies a difference, e.g. collectivist versus individualist cultural norms or strong family involvement oeM1
- describes how this might change progression, e.g. social phase may occur earlier or be more decisive because third-party opinions carry more weight oeA1
- explains the consequence, e.g. partners may delay leaving due to familial pressure or conversely be forced into a public breakup sooner oeA1
- may note individual differences such as attachment style or personality that affect speed or order of phases oeA1
- Answer: In collectivist communities the social phase may occur earlier and be more decisive because family and community opinion is highly influential; this can lead partners either to delay a breakup because of pressure to stay, or to have the relationship ended publicly sooner, showing cultural differences can alter the timing and impact of Duck's phases.
Question 2
- gives the correct sequence for the first three stages: intra-psychic, dyadic, social oeB1
- gives the correct sequence for the last two stages: grave-dressing, resurrection oeB1
- Answer: Intra-psychic, dyadic, social, grave-dressing, resurrection.
Question 3
- states that partners begin to discuss dissatisfaction openly and conflicts increase oeB1
- explains that negotiation, attempts to repair, blame or confrontation occur between partners oeB1
- Answer: Dyadic phase: Kwame and his partner begin to discuss grievances openly, leading to more arguments, negotiation or blame, and attempts to repair the relationship.
Question 4
- states that partners involve third parties such as friends or family and make the relationship troubles public oeM1
- states that external opinions, support or pressure influence decisions about the relationship oeA1
- refers to reputational or social consequences arising from discussing the breakup publicly oeA1
- Answer: Social phase: Priya tells friends about problems, the issues become public, and external opinions, support or pressure help shape what happens next with social consequences for reputations.
Question 5
- states that partners construct a narrative to explain the breakup and present themselves in a favourable light oeM1
- mentions that the narrative is often self-protective, blaming the other or minimising one's own role oeA1
- mentions that the story serves social functions, managing reputation and allowing emotional closure oeA1
- may note that reinterpretation of events helps the individual move on emotionally oeA1
- Answer: Grave-dressing: Callum constructs a post-breakup story that makes the breakup socially acceptable, often protecting his self-image by blaming the other or reinterpreting events, which helps manage reputation and aids emotional closure.
Question 6
- states a limitation: the model is largely descriptive and based on retrospective accounts oeM1
- explains that retrospective reports can be biased by memory or self-justification, reducing the model's predictive power oeA1
- explains that because it describes stages after the event it may not reliably predict which relationships will end or when oeA1
- Answer: Limitation: the model is descriptive and often based on retrospective accounts, which can be biased by memory or self-justification and therefore limit the model's ability to predict which relationships will break up and when.
Question 7
- identifies a practical application, e.g. timing of interventions at the dyadic phase to improve communication or designing repair strategies oeM1
- explains why that phase is an appropriate point for intervention, e.g. partners are discussing issues and can be helped to negotiate more constructively oeA1
- explains how the model guides the intervention, e.g. counsellors focus on conflict resolution skills, improving communication and preventing escalation into the social phase oeA1
- may mention that awareness of stages helps practitioners tailor support and timing, improving chances of repair oeA1
- Answer: Application: counsellors can target the dyadic phase to teach communication and conflict-resolution skills because partners are openly discussing problems; the model guides when and how to intervene to prevent escalation into public breakdown.
Question 8
- outlines one strength of the model, for example its usefulness in identifying stages and guiding interventions oeM1
- explains why this is a strength, linking to practical counselling or timing of support oeA1
- outlines one limitation, for example its descriptive and retrospective nature or failure to account for cultural/individual differences oeM1
- explains why this is a limitation, e.g. retrospective bias, lack of predictive power, or limited generalisability oeA1
- provides an evaluative comment linking the strength and limitation, for example that usefulness for intervention is constrained by limited predictive validity oeA1
- may support evaluation with brief reference to Rollie and Duck's resurrection phase as an improvement or to empirical evidence that shows variability in how breakups proceed oeA1
- Answer: Strength: the model identifies recognisable stages which helps practitioners target interventions at appropriate points, for example helping couples with communication during the dyadic phase. Limitation: it is largely descriptive and based on retrospective accounts so it may not predict breakups well and may not generalise across cultures or individual differences. Overall, while useful for structuring interventions, its limited predictive validity and variability in real-world progress reduce its explanatory power.
Question 9
- Level 4 Knowledge of Duck's model and the resurrection phase is accurate and detailed, showing clear understanding. Discussion is thorough and balanced, including both strengths and limitations, and evaluates evidence and implications. Application to intervention timing is integrated and persuasive. The essay is coherent, well organised and uses appropriate specialist terminology.13-16
- Level 3 Knowledge of the model is clear with some detail. Discussion includes several relevant evaluation points and some application to interventions. Evaluation is effective but may lack depth in places. Answer is organised and uses specialist terms appropriately.9-12
- Level 2 Knowledge of the model is present but may be partial or contain minor inaccuracies. Limited evaluation is present, with one or two relevant points such as descriptive nature or cultural differences. Application to interventions is attempted but not fully developed. The answer may lack organisation in parts.5-8
- Level 1 Basic or sparse knowledge of Duck's model, which may be muddled or fragmentary. Evaluation is minimal or superficial, with weak or no application to interventions. Limited use of terminology and poor organisation.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Outline the four original stages: intra-psychic (private dissatisfaction and weighing up), dyadic (open discussion, confrontation, attempts at repair), social (involving third parties, public discussion, social pressure), grave-dressing (creating post-breakup narratives to protect self and reputation).
- AO1: Describe Rollie and Duck's resurrection phase: revising self-narrative, learning from the relationship, preparing for new relationships and re-engaging with life.
- AO2: Application to interventions: the model suggests counselling or communication training is most useful in the dyadic phase when partners are discussing problems; public involvement in the social phase may reduce options for repair, so early private interventions could be prioritised.
- AO3: Evaluation - descriptive and retrospective nature: many studies that inform the model rely on retrospective accounts which can be biased by memory and self-justification, reducing predictive validity and raising questions about stage order and timing.
- AO3: Cultural and individual differences: progression through phases may differ across collectivist and individualist cultures, and between people with different attachment styles or personalities, so the model may not be universally applicable.
- AO3: Empirical support and contradiction: some qualitative interview studies support stage-like processes and the usefulness of staged accounts for counselling, but quantitative longitudinal studies show considerable variability in order and timing of events and some relationships end rapidly without clear staging.
- AO3: Usefulness for practice: the staged account provides a clear framework for practitioners to time interventions and to help clients reframe narratives in grave-dressing and resurrection phases, but its limitations mean interventions should be flexible and culturally sensitive.
- AO3: Overall judgement: the model is valuable as a heuristic and for guiding practice but limited as a strong explanatory theory because it is largely descriptive, relies on retrospective data and underplays variability between individuals and cultures.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.