Persuasive and Discursive Writing Focus Set 2 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 9 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Persuasive and Discursive Writing Focus Set 2 revision guideMore 11+ English practice
This topic is chapter 2 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 8.
1.29-2 Persuasive and Discursive Writing Focus Set 2
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): at least one argument in favour of keeping the clock changes; at least one argument against them; a discourse marker to signal each shift in viewpoint; your own considered conclusion.
Focus on fairness: give genuine weight to both sides before you reach your own view.
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): a heading and at least one sub-heading (for example 'What Went Well' and 'Recommendation'); at least two specific pieces of evidence about the trip's success or shortcomings (for example a comment on a particular activity, or the level of staff supervision); one clear recommendation for next year, with a reason; how you will keep your register formal and impersonal throughout.
Use a formal, impersonal register; do not use contractions or personal opinion phrases such as 'I think'.
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): a heading and at least one sub-heading (for example 'Findings' and 'Recommendation'); how you will present the survey results clearly and accurately; one recommendation that follows logically from the findings; how you will keep your register formal and impersonal throughout.
Use a formal, impersonal register; do not use contractions or personal opinion phrases such as 'I think'.
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): your main argument and at least two supporting reasons or pieces of evidence; a counter-argument (for example that idling is only for a short time, or that it is a driver's own choice) and how you will answer it; at least one persuasive technique you plan to use; a memorable closing line.
Use appropriate letter conventions (for example an address and date, a suitable greeting and sign-off).
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): your main argument and at least two supporting reasons or pieces of evidence; a counter-argument the councillor might raise (for example cost or noise) and how you will answer it; at least one persuasive technique you plan to use (for example a rhetorical question or the rule of three); a memorable closing line.
Use appropriate letter conventions (for example an address and date, a suitable greeting and sign-off).
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): your main argument and at least two supporting reasons or pieces of evidence; acknowledge a reason pupils might not want to take part, and plan how you will answer this; at least one persuasive technique you plan to use; a memorable opening and closing line.
Use appropriate speech conventions (for example direct address to your audience).
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): at least one argument in favour of the current pay gap; at least one argument against it; a discourse marker to signal each shift in viewpoint (for example 'however', 'on the other hand'); your own considered conclusion.
Focus on fairness: give genuine weight to both sides before you reach your own view.
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): a heading and sub-headings (for example 'Findings' and 'Recommendation'); at least one specific reason given by pupils in favour, and at least one specific reason given by pupils against, presented with genuine balance; a clear final recommendation that follows from the findings, using persuasive language appropriate to a formal recommendation (for example a confident, justified final sentence); how you will keep the findings section impersonal while making the recommendation section more persuasive in tone.
This task asks you to control two registers within one document: balanced and impersonal for the findings, then confident and persuasive for the recommendation.
PLANNING FRAME (not marked, but use it before you write): the conservation perspective, with a specific reason or piece of evidence; the animal welfare perspective, with a specific reason or piece of evidence; the local community/economic perspective, with a specific reason or piece of evidence; discourse markers to move between all three; your own considered, personal conclusion.
This task asks you to control more than a simple two-sided balance: give genuine, specific weight to three different perspectives before reaching your own view.
Question 1
- Content and organisation (balance) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, well-balanced discussion that explores both sides of the argument with genuine even-handedness, using precise vocabulary, a confident range of discourse markers to signpost shifts in viewpoint, and a well-reasoned, independent conclusion that clearly weighs the evidence on each side.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised discussion that considers both sides of the argument with reasonable balance, using appropriate discourse markers to signal each viewpoint and a clear final conclusion.7-9
- Level 2 A discussion that considers more than one viewpoint, but coverage may be uneven or one side underdeveloped; some appropriate vocabulary and connectives used.4-6
- Level 1 A largely one-sided discussion with limited genuine engagement with an opposing viewpoint; simple vocabulary and sentence structures; conclusion may simply restate one side.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a genuine argument in favour of keeping the clock changes, given real weight (for example, brighter winter mornings are safer for the school run, and farmers have long relied on the seasonal pattern)
- a genuine argument against them, given real weight (for example, changing the clocks disrupts sleep patterns, and darker winter afternoons are linked to a rise in road accidents involving pedestrians)
- discourse markers used to signal each shift in viewpoint (for example 'however', 'on the other hand', 'in contrast')
- a considered, independent conclusion that weighs the arguments rather than simply repeating one side
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 2
- Content and organisation (report structure and register) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, clearly structured report that uses headings/sub-headings and a genuinely impersonal, formal register throughout; findings are presented precisely, including specific detail or data, and the recommendation is clearly justified and directly linked to the findings.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised report with headings/sub-headings and reference to specific findings, in a consistently formal register; a clear recommendation is given, connected to the findings.7-9
- Level 2 A report with some structure (for example a heading, or a separate findings section) and some formal register, but this may lapse into a more personal or informal tone in places; a recommendation is given but only loosely connected to the findings.4-6
- Level 1 A largely unstructured account with little use of headings or formal register; findings and/or recommendation may be vague or missing.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- clear use of headings/sub-headings to organise the report (for example 'What Went Well' and 'Recommendation')
- at least two specific, plausible pieces of evidence about the trip (for example, a majority of pupils naming the high-ropes course as their favourite activity, or a comment about insufficient staff supervision during evening free time)
- a formal, impersonal register maintained throughout (no contractions, no first-person opinion phrases)
- one clear, reasoned recommendation for next year that follows logically from the evidence given (for example, increasing the staff-to-pupil ratio during evening free time)
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 3
- Content and organisation (report structure and register) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, clearly structured report that uses headings/sub-headings and a genuinely impersonal, formal register throughout; findings are presented precisely, including specific detail or data, and the recommendation is clearly justified and directly linked to the findings.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised report with headings/sub-headings and reference to specific findings, in a consistently formal register; a clear recommendation is given, connected to the findings.7-9
- Level 2 A report with some structure (for example a heading, or a separate findings section) and some formal register, but this may lapse into a more personal or informal tone in places; a recommendation is given but only loosely connected to the findings.4-6
- Level 1 A largely unstructured account with little use of headings or formal register; findings and/or recommendation may be vague or missing.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- clear use of headings/sub-headings to organise the report (for example 'Findings' and 'Recommendation')
- accurate reference to the given survey data (60% would attend if it started earlier, 20% cited cost, 20% not interested), presented clearly rather than simply copied out
- a formal, impersonal register maintained throughout (no contractions, no first-person opinion phrases)
- one clear recommendation that follows logically from the findings (for example, moving the start time earlier and introducing a small number of reduced-cost places)
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 4
- Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, sustained argument that manages the reader throughout, using precise, ambitious vocabulary, a confident range of persuasive techniques (for example rhetorical question, rule of three, direct address) used for deliberate effect, and a considered, well-answered counter-argument.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised argument with a clear main position, relevant supporting reasons, and at least one deliberate persuasive technique used for effect. Appropriate letter conventions used correctly.7-9
- Level 2 A clear argument with a main position and some supporting reasons, using some appropriate vocabulary, but limited use of persuasive technique or letter conventions.4-6
- Level 1 A simple statement of opinion with limited supporting reasons; little use of persuasive technique or appropriate letter form.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a clear, sustained argument against engine idling outside the school gates with specific, relevant reasons (for example, exhaust fumes worsen air quality exactly where young lungs are most exposed, and idling wastes fuel for no benefit)
- accurate letter conventions (address and date, salutation, sign-off) appropriate to a formal audience
- deliberate persuasive techniques (for example rhetorical questions, rule of three, direct address to the reader) used for effect rather than inserted at random
- a considered acknowledgement and answer to a plausible counter-argument (for example that idling only lasts a few minutes, or that it is a driver's personal choice)
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 5
- Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, sustained argument that manages the reader throughout, using precise, ambitious vocabulary, a confident range of persuasive techniques (for example rhetorical question, rule of three, direct address) used for deliberate effect, and a considered, well-answered counter-argument.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised argument with a clear main position, relevant supporting reasons, and at least one deliberate persuasive technique used for effect. Appropriate letter conventions used correctly.7-9
- Level 2 A clear argument with a main position and some supporting reasons, using some appropriate vocabulary, but limited use of persuasive technique or letter conventions.4-6
- Level 1 A simple statement of opinion with limited supporting reasons; little use of persuasive technique or appropriate letter form.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a clear, sustained argument for the skate park with specific, relevant reasons (for example, the nearest existing skate park is several miles away, or similar facilities elsewhere have reduced anti-social behaviour and increased footfall for nearby shops)
- accurate letter conventions (address and date, salutation, sign-off) appropriate to a formal audience
- deliberate persuasive techniques (for example rhetorical questions, rule of three, direct address to the reader) used for effect rather than inserted at random
- a considered acknowledgement and answer to a plausible counter-argument (for example the cost of building the park, or noise for nearby residents)
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 6
- Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, sustained argument that manages the reader throughout, using precise, ambitious vocabulary, a confident range of persuasive techniques (for example rhetorical question, rule of three, direct address) used for deliberate effect, and a considered, well-answered counter-argument.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised argument with a clear main position, relevant supporting reasons, and at least one deliberate persuasive technique used for effect. Appropriate speech conventions used correctly.7-9
- Level 2 A clear argument with a main position and some supporting reasons, using some appropriate vocabulary, but limited use of persuasive technique or speech conventions.4-6
- Level 1 A simple statement of opinion with limited supporting reasons; little use of persuasive technique or appropriate speech form.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a clear, sustained argument for Silent Reading Friday with specific, relevant reasons (for example, regular reading for pleasure builds vocabulary, or a similar scheme at another school led to a rise in library book loans)
- speech conventions used appropriately (direct address to the audience, an inclusive tone, a memorable opening and closing line)
- deliberate persuasive techniques (for example rule of three, repetition, a rhetorical question) used for effect
- a considered acknowledgement of a reason pupils might hesitate (for example, losing time to chat with friends) with a reasoned answer (for example, keeping the session short and offering graphic novels or audiobooks so everyone can take part)
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 7
- Content and organisation (balance) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated, well-balanced discussion that explores both sides of the argument with genuine even-handedness, using precise vocabulary, a confident range of discourse markers to signpost shifts in viewpoint, and a well-reasoned, independent conclusion that clearly weighs the evidence on each side.10-12
- Level 3 A well-organised discussion that considers both sides of the argument with reasonable balance, using appropriate discourse markers to signal each viewpoint and a clear final conclusion.7-9
- Level 2 A discussion that considers more than one viewpoint, but coverage may be uneven or one side underdeveloped; some appropriate vocabulary and connectives used.4-6
- Level 1 A largely one-sided discussion with limited genuine engagement with an opposing viewpoint; simple vocabulary and sentence structures; conclusion may simply restate one side.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures; punctuation used precisely for effect.5-6
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-4
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a genuine argument in favour of the current pay gap, given real weight (for example, top footballers generate huge revenue for their clubs through ticket sales, sponsorship and broadcasting, and have very short careers)
- a genuine argument against it, given real weight (for example, nurses and teachers perform essential public services that keep society running, yet are paid a small fraction of a top footballer's wage)
- discourse markers used to signal each shift in viewpoint (for example 'however', 'on the other hand', 'in contrast')
- a considered, independent conclusion that weighs the arguments rather than simply repeating one side
- award up to 12 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 6 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 8
- Content and organisation (balanced report with persuasive recommendation) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated report combining genuinely balanced, impersonal findings, with accurate reference to both percentages and reasons, with a confidently and persuasively worded recommendation that follows logically from the findings, controlling the shift in register with real skill.12-14
- Level 3 A well-organised report with reasonably balanced findings referencing the given data and a clear, persuasively worded recommendation connected to the findings.8-11
- Level 2 A report that presents findings with some reference to the data, but balance may be uneven, or the recommendation may only be loosely persuasive or loosely connected to the findings.4-7
- Level 1 A largely unstructured account with little balance in the findings and a vague or missing recommendation.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures, and across any shift in register the task requires; punctuation used precisely for effect.6-7
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-5
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- accurate reference to both given percentages/figures (70% in favour, 30% against) and at least one specific reason from each side, presented with genuine balance (for example, in favour: black trainers hide scuffs and last longer between washes; against: a change could mean an unwelcome extra cost for families who already own white trainers)
- headings/sub-headings used to separate findings from recommendation
- an impersonal, formal register maintained in the findings section (no contractions, no first-person opinion)
- a confidently and persuasively worded recommendation in the final section, using techniques such as a justified final sentence or a rhetorical question, while remaining appropriate to a formal report
- a clear, controlled shift in tone between the balanced findings and the persuasive recommendation, rather than the same register used throughout
- award up to 14 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 7 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Question 9
- Content and organisation (balance across three perspectives) (AO5)
- Level 4 A sophisticated discussion that gives genuine, specific weight to at least three distinct perspectives, using precise vocabulary, a confident range of discourse markers to manage the shifts between them, and a well-reasoned, independent personal conclusion that clearly weighs all three.12-14
- Level 3 A well-organised discussion that considers at least three perspectives with reasonable balance, using appropriate discourse markers, and a clear personal conclusion.8-11
- Level 2 A discussion that considers more than one perspective, but may only fully develop two of the three, or coverage may be uneven; some appropriate vocabulary and connectives.4-7
- Level 1 A largely one-sided or two-sided discussion with little genuine engagement with a third perspective; simple vocabulary; conclusion may simply restate one side.1-3
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Technical accuracy (AO6)
- Level 3 Consistently accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar throughout, including on ambitious vocabulary and more complex sentence structures, and across any shift in register the task requires; punctuation used precisely for effect.6-7
- Level 2 Mostly accurate spelling, punctuation and grammar; occasional errors on more ambitious vocabulary or complex sentences, but meaning is never lost.3-5
- Level 1 Frequent errors in spelling, punctuation and/or grammar; simple sentence structures used almost throughout.1-2
- Level 0 Nothing worthy of credit.0
- Indicative content:
- a genuine conservation perspective, given real weight (for example, some zoos run breeding programmes for endangered species that support reintroduction into the wild)
- a genuine animal welfare perspective, given real weight (for example, concerns that even well-designed enclosures cannot fully replace the space and freedom of a natural habitat)
- a genuine local community/economic perspective, given real weight (for example, a zoo can provide jobs and support other local businesses through tourism)
- discourse markers used to manage shifts between all three perspectives (for example 'from a different point of view', 'meanwhile', 'a further perspective is that')
- a considered, independent personal conclusion in the final paragraph that weighs all three perspectives rather than simply repeating one
- award up to 14 marks for content and organisation (AO5) and up to 7 marks for technical accuracy (AO6), using the grids above; do not itemise individual points as marks, use best-fit judgement across each grid
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.