Motivation: financial and non-financial methods - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
13 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Motivation: financial and non-financial methods revision guideMore GCSE Business practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 3 of GCSE Business Topic Workbook 4.
4.5 Motivation: financial and non-financial methods
- A) Job rotation
- B) A fringe benefit
- C) Piece-rate pay
- D) Job enrichment
Recommend whether Hazelmere Bakery should extend piece-rate pay to more of its production staff. Justify your answer using the figures and points made earlier in this pack.
Question 1
- D caoB1
- Answer: D
Question 2
- the bottom three levels named in order: physiological, safety, social/belonging (or love/belonging)B1
- the top two levels named in order: esteem, self-actualisationB1
- Answer: Physiological, safety, social/belonging, esteem, self-actualisation.
Question 3
- identifies a non-financial method, e.g. giving an experienced baker greater responsibility, such as training new staff or planning the day's productionB1
- links it to a Herzberg motivator, e.g. this matches Herzberg's 'responsibility' motivator, which he argued genuinely increases job satisfaction, unlike a hygiene factor such as payB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this can increase engagement and reduce staff turnover without any extra pay costB1
- Answer: Giving an experienced baker greater responsibility, such as training new staff, matches Herzberg's 'responsibility' motivator, which he argued genuinely increases job satisfaction unlike a hygiene factor such as pay, and can increase engagement and reduce staff turnover at no extra pay cost.
Question 4
- job rotation moves a worker between different tasks or roles at a similar level, mainly to reduce boredom (oe)B1
- job enrichment gives a worker more challenging or complex tasks and greater responsibility (oe)B1
- Answer: Job rotation moves a worker between different tasks at a similar level mainly to reduce boredom, whereas job enrichment gives a worker more challenging tasks and greater responsibility.
Question 5
- identifies that hygiene factors, e.g. pay, working conditions, company policy, can cause dissatisfaction if they are poor, but do not themselves create motivationB1
- identifies that motivators, e.g. achievement, recognition, responsibility, the work itself, are what Herzberg argued actually motivate staff and create job satisfactionB1
- draws a clear contrast between the two, e.g. improving hygiene factors alone removes dissatisfaction but will not, on its own, motivate staff to work harderB1
- Answer: Hygiene factors, such as pay and working conditions, can cause dissatisfaction if poor but do not themselves motivate, whereas motivators, such as achievement, recognition and responsibility, are what Herzberg argued actually create job satisfaction; improving hygiene factors alone removes dissatisfaction but will not motivate staff to work harder.
Question 6
- (a) £402.50 caoB1
- (a) Answer: £402.50.
- (b) 850 x 0.50 seenM1
- (b) £425 caoA1
- (b) Answer: £425.
- (c) £22.50 cao (ft from parts a and b)B1
- (c) Answer: £22.50.
Question 7
- (a) 700 x 0.50 seenM1
- (a) £350 caoA1
- (a) Answer: £350.
- (b) £52.50 cao (ft from part a and question 6a)B1
- (b) Answer: £52.50.
Question 8
- identifies the advantage, e.g. piece rate pays workers directly for output, matching Taylor's belief that money motivates harder workB1
- develops the point, e.g. faster workers, like the one in question 6, are rewarded with higher pay for producing moreB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this can increase total output/productivity for Hazelmere without raising the basic time rate for everyoneB1
- Answer: Piece rate pays workers directly for output, matching Taylor's belief that money motivates harder work; faster workers like the one in question 6 earn more for producing more, which can raise Hazelmere's total output without raising the basic time rate for everyone.
Question 9
- identifies the point, e.g. Maslow and Herzberg both argue that needs beyond pay, such as belonging, esteem or responsibility, also affect motivationB1
- develops the point, e.g. a staff member whose basic pay needs are already met (Maslow's lower levels) may be motivated more by recognition or responsibility (Herzberg's motivators) than by extra moneyB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. an approach based only on financial reward, as Taylor proposed, may fail to motivate this member of staff, even if it works well for others, such as the fast worker in question 6B1
- Answer: Maslow and Herzberg both argue that needs beyond pay, such as belonging, esteem or responsibility, also affect motivation, so a staff member whose basic pay needs are already met may be motivated more by recognition or responsibility than by extra money, meaning a purely financial approach, as Taylor proposed, may not motivate everyone equally.
Question 10
- identifies Taylor's view, e.g. Taylor believed workers are motivated mainly, or only, by money/financial rewardB1
- develops the point, e.g. Taylor's scientific management broke jobs into simple, repetitive tasks and paid workers piece rate for the amount they producedB1
- outlines a criticism, e.g. later theorists such as Herzberg and Maslow argued this ignores workers' social and psychological needs, and Taylor's view is now considered too narrow, not a proven factB1
- Answer: Taylor believed workers are motivated mainly by money, so his scientific management broke jobs into simple, repetitive tasks and paid workers piece rate for output; later theorists such as Herzberg and Maslow criticised this as ignoring workers' social and psychological needs, and it is now seen as too narrow rather than a proven fact.
Question 11
- identifies the risk, e.g. this worker's pay depends entirely on how many loaves they produceB1
- develops the point, e.g. a slower or less experienced worker, or one who is unwell or has an off day, earns significantly less, shown by the £52.50 shortfall in question 7bB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this makes piece-rate income unpredictable and could demotivate or financially disadvantage workers who are not among the fastestB1
- Answer: This worker's pay depends entirely on output, so a slower or less experienced worker earns significantly less, shown by the £52.50 shortfall in question 7b, making piece-rate income unpredictable and potentially demotivating for workers who are not among the fastest.
Question 12
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped comments about extending piece-rate pay, with little or no use of the pack's figures or theories, and no clear recommendation.1-3
- Level 2 Gives a developed argument for or against extending piece-rate pay, using some of the pack's figures or theories, but does not fully weigh both sides or reach a clearly justified recommendation.4-6
- Level 3 Weighs the evidence for and against extending piece-rate pay, using the pay-comparison figures and Taylor/Herzberg/Maslow's theories from this pack, and reaches a justified recommendation supported by that analysis.7-9
- Indicative content:
- For extending piece rate: it rewards Hazelmere's fastest worker with £22.50 a week more than the time rate (question 6c), supporting Taylor's view that financial reward motivates workers to produce more, which could raise the bakery's overall output.
- For extending piece rate: it directly links pay to output, which is simple for Hazelmere to administer and clearly rewards effort, unlike a flat time rate that pays the same regardless of how many loaves are baked.
- Against extending piece rate: question 7b shows a slower worker earns £52.50 less than under the time rate, and questions 5 and 9 argue, via Herzberg and Maslow, that pay is not the only, or even the main, motivator for every member of staff.
- Against extending piece rate: unpredictable or reduced income for slower workers (question 11) could increase staff turnover among exactly the staff Hazelmere can least afford to lose, and non-financial methods (question 3) could motivate some staff more effectively at no extra cost.
- Judgement: given that piece rate clearly benefits faster workers but risks demotivating and financially penalising slower ones, and that Herzberg and Maslow's contested but influential theories suggest non-financial factors also matter, a reasonable recommendation is that Hazelmere Bakery should offer piece rate only as an optional alternative to the time rate, alongside non-financial motivators such as recognition and responsibility (question 3), rather than extending it to all production staff.
Question 13
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped points about the change, with limited use of Herzberg's theory and little or no application to Hazelmere Bakery.1-3
- Level 2 Provides a developed and applied analysis of the likely impact on motivation, using Herzberg's theory and referring to Hazelmere Bakery's staff.4-6
- Indicative content:
- Herzberg classed pay-related benefits such as a staff discount as a hygiene factor (question 5), which can prevent dissatisfaction but does not itself motivate staff to work harder.
- Job enrichment matches Herzberg's 'responsibility' motivator (question 5), which he argued genuinely increases job satisfaction, so this change could motivate experienced bakers more effectively than the discount did.
- Removing the discount could reduce satisfaction among lower-paid staff who value its direct financial value, especially if Maslow's lower-level physiological needs (question 2) are not fully met by their basic pay.
- Not every member of staff wants greater responsibility; some may find planning production stressful or prefer the certainty of a discount they can rely on, so the change could demotivate a minority even as it motivates others.
- A balanced conclusion might note that job enrichment is likely to be a stronger long-term motivator for experienced staff under Herzberg's theory, but Hazelmere Bakery should judge how much its staff value the discount's direct financial worth before removing it for everyone, consistent with this pack's wider point (question 9) that no single method motivates every member of staff.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.