Legislation and its impact - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
15 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Legislation and its impact revision guideMore GCSE Business practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 8 of GCSE Business Topic Workbook 5 and chapter 15 of GCSE Business 10-Minute Tests 3.
6.5 Legislation and its impact
- A) To guarantee a business will always make a profit
- B) To protect employees' rights, such as a safe workplace and fair, non-discriminatory treatment
- C) To set the price a business must charge for its products
- D) To decide which products a business is allowed to sell
- A) Goods sold to customers must be of satisfactory quality and match how they were described
- B) A business must sell every product at the lowest price in the local area
- C) A business must offer every customer a loyalty card
- D) A business must open at the same times as all of its competitors
Recommend whether Roseford Salon Group should treat legislative compliance mainly as a cost to minimise, or mainly as an investment that protects the business and its customers. Justify your answer using the figures and points made earlier in this pack.
Question 1
- B caoB1
- Answer: B
Question 2
- A caoB1
- Answer: A
Question 3
- one acceptable area, e.g. recruiting and employing staffB1
- a second acceptable area, e.g. health and safety in the workplaceB1
- a third acceptable area, e.g. protecting consumers, protecting the environment, or protecting customer dataB1
- Answer: Any three, e.g. employing staff; health and safety; protecting consumers; protecting the environment; protecting customer data.
Question 4
- one acceptable consequence, e.g. a fine imposed by a regulatorB1
- a second acceptable consequence, e.g. reputational damage/loss of customers, legal costs of defending a claim, or being ordered to stop trading or close a siteB1
- Answer: Any two, e.g. a regulator's fine; reputational damage/loss of customers; legal costs; being forced to stop trading or close a site.
Question 5
- 12 x 450 seenM1
- £5,400 caoA1
- Answer: £5,400.
Question 6
- (a) 60 x 12 seenM1
- (a) £720 caoA1
- (a) Answer: £720.
- (b) 1,200 + 720 seen (ft from part a)M1
- (b) £1,920 caoA1
- (b) Answer: £1,920.
Question 7
- 300 x 2 seenM1
- £600 caoA1
- Answer: £600.
Question 8
- 16,200 / 5,400 seen (ft from question 5)M1
- 3 times caoA1
- Answer: 3 times as great.
Question 9
- identifies the point, e.g. data protection law generally requires customer data to be kept secure and used only for the purpose it was collectedB1
- develops the point, e.g. this is why Roseford has to buy compliant record-keeping software, at a first-year cost of £1,920 (question 6b), rather than storing records however it likesB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. handling data correctly protects customers' privacy and reduces the risk of a data breach and the reputational damage this could causeB1
- Answer: Data protection law generally requires customer data to be kept secure and used only for the purpose it was collected, which is why Roseford must buy compliant software at a first-year cost of £1,920 (question 6b), protecting customer privacy and reducing the risk of a damaging data breach.
Question 10
- 5,400 + 1,920 + 600 seen (ft from questions 5, 6b and 7)M1
- £7,920 caoA1
- Answer: £7,920.
Question 11
- identifies the point, e.g. customers know that products and services must meet a minimum legal standard, and can get a refund or repair if something is faultyB1
- develops the point, e.g. this gives customers confidence to buy from Roseford without having to check every detail themselvesB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this builds trust and can lead to repeat business, even though question 7 shows it also has a cost to RosefordB1
- Answer: Customers know products and services must meet a minimum legal standard and can get a refund or repair if something is faulty, giving them confidence to buy without checking every detail, which builds trust and repeat business, even though this has a cost to Roseford (question 7).
Question 12
- identifies the point, e.g. the potential cost of an injury, £16,200, is three times greater than the £5,400 cost of the emergency lighting that could help prevent it (question 8)B1
- develops the point, e.g. this means the upfront cost is small compared with the financial risk of not complyingB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. spending on compliance now is likely to save Roseford money overall, as well as reducing the risk of harm to a real customer or member of staffB1
- Answer: The potential injury cost of £16,200 is three times greater than the £5,400 cost of the lighting that could help prevent it (question 8), so the upfront cost is small compared with the risk of not complying, meaning compliance is likely to save Roseford money overall as well as reducing the risk of real harm.
Question 13
- identifies the point, e.g. costs such as the £1,920 compliance software (question 6b) are largely fixed, whatever the size of the businessB1
- develops the point, e.g. a large chain can spread this fixed cost over many more customers and salons than a single small business canB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. the cost per customer, or per salon, is higher for a small business, making it relatively more expensive to complyB1
- Answer: Fixed compliance costs such as the £1,920 software (question 6b) are the same whatever the size of the business, but a large chain can spread this over many more customers and salons than a single small business can, so the cost per customer is relatively higher for the small business.
Question 14
- identifies the point, e.g. question 10 shows compliance costs Roseford £7,920 in the first year across just these three areasB1
- develops the point, e.g. this is money Roseford cannot spend on other things, such as marketing, staff training, or opening a new salonB1
- links clearly to an outcome, e.g. this could put Roseford at a disadvantage compared with a larger competitor that can spread the same fixed costs across more salonsB1
- Answer: Question 10 shows compliance costs Roseford £7,920 in the first year, money it cannot spend on marketing, training or expansion, which could put it at a disadvantage compared with a larger competitor that spreads the same fixed costs across more salons.
Question 15
- Level 1 Makes simple, undeveloped comments about legislative compliance, with little or no use of the pack's figures and no clear recommendation.1-3
- Level 2 Gives a developed argument for treating compliance mainly as a cost or mainly as an investment, using some of the pack's figures, but does not fully weigh both sides or reach a clearly justified recommendation.4-6
- Level 3 Weighs the evidence on both sides, using the compliance-cost and risk-comparison figures from this pack, and reaches a justified recommendation supported by that analysis.7-9
- Indicative content:
- For treating compliance as a cost to minimise: question 14 shows the £7,920 first-year cost (question 10) is real money that could otherwise fund marketing, training or expansion, and question 13 shows this burden falls relatively harder on a small business like a single Roseford salon.
- For treating compliance as a cost to minimise: Roseford could look for the cheapest way to meet the legal minimum requirements in each area, rather than spending more than necessary.
- For treating compliance as an investment: question 12 shows the £16,200 potential cost of a single health and safety breach is three times greater than the £5,400 cost of preventing it, so underspending on compliance is a false saving.
- For treating compliance as an investment: question 11 shows compliance also builds customer trust and confidence, which could support repeat business and reputation beyond the direct costs and risks already calculated.
- Judgement: given that the potential cost of non-compliance (£16,200, question 8) is several times larger than the cost of prevention, and that compliance also brings a genuine customer-trust benefit (question 11), a reasonable recommendation is that Roseford should treat legislative compliance mainly as a necessary investment rather than a cost to minimise, while still looking for efficient, not excessive, ways to meet each requirement.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.