Complex Clause Analysis - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
22 original exam-style questions - 10 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Complex Clause Analysis revision guideMore GCSE English practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 6 of GCSE English Language Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 6 of GCSE English Language 10-Minute Tests.
Complex Clause Analysis is the skill of identifying main (independent) clauses and subordinate (dependent) clauses within a sentence and explaining how they are joined, using subordinating conjunctions, relative pronouns or non-finite verb forms. It is tested in GCSE English Language SPaG questions and used when analysing how writers build meaning through sentence structure.
- Find the main clause first: the part of the sentence that makes complete sense on its own and could stand as a sentence.
- Locate the subordinate clause(s): the part(s) that add extra information but cannot stand alone, often starting with words like 'because', 'although', 'which' or 'when'.
- Identify the connective or relative pronoun joining the clauses and name its type (subordinating conjunction, relative pronoun, or non-finite verb form such as '-ing').
- Check whether the subordinate clause is embedded inside the main clause (marked off with a pair of commas when it adds extra, non-essential information, but with no commas when it defines the noun it follows) or attached before or after it.
- When analysing effect, comment on what the subordinate clause adds, e.g. reason, contrast, time, or extra description.
- Practise by underlining the main clause once and the subordinate clause(s) twice in exam-style sentences.
Worked example
Analyse the clause structure of: 'Although the storm was fierce, the sailors, who had faced worse before, steered the boat calmly towards the harbour.'
- Find the main clause: 'the sailors steered the boat calmly towards the harbour' - this makes complete sense alone.
- Identify the first subordinate clause: 'Although the storm was fierce' - begins with the subordinating conjunction 'Although', showing contrast.
- Identify the second subordinate clause: 'who had faced worse before' - a relative clause beginning with the relative pronoun 'who', embedded inside the main clause using commas.
- Note the sentence type: this is a complex sentence with two subordinate clauses, one fronted (contrast) and one embedded (relative, extra description).
- Final answer: one main clause ('the sailors steered the boat calmly towards the harbour') with two subordinate clauses: a fronted concessive clause ('Although the storm was fierce') and an embedded relative clause ('who had faced worse before').
4.6 Complex Clause Analysis
The Last Ferry
Written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free). This short narrative extract was composed specifically for this worksheet as a source for clause-level grammar analysis.
01 When the last coach had rattled away from the harbour car park, Priya
02 locked the ticket office and walked down towards the jetty, listening to
03 the gulls that circled above the fish market roof. The ferry, which had
04 carried passengers across the strait for almost forty years, sat low in
05 the water, its engine idling patiently. Marcus, who had been the skipper
06 since Priya was a child, leaned out of the wheelhouse window and called
07 down that the tide would turn within the hour. Having checked the ropes
08 twice, Priya climbed aboard and settled into the small cabin that smelled
09 of diesel and salt. She knew that the crossing would be rough because
10 the forecast, pinned to the noticeboard since breakfast, had warned of
11 a rising wind. The lighthouse, its beam sweeping steadily across the
12 black water, offered the only light beyond the harbour wall. Although
13 the waves grew steeper beyond the headland, Marcus kept the boat steady,
14 correcting the wheel with small, unhurried movements. Priya, gripping the
15 rail and trying not to think about the crossing that had capsized a
16 smaller boat two winters before, watched the harbour lights shrink behind
17 them. 'We have done this a thousand times,' Marcus shouted over the
18 engine, grinning as though the weather were nothing more than a light
19 drizzle. By the time the ferry reached the far jetty, the wind had
20 dropped and the sky, scrubbed clean by the storm, had begun to clear.
21 Priya, who had spent the whole crossing gripping the rail, stepped onto
22 the harbour steps and breathed out slowly, relieved that the night's last
23 crossing was finally over.
- A) Simple sentence
- B) Compound sentence
- C) Complex sentence
- D) Compound-complex sentence
Sentence 1 (lines 3-5): 'The ferry, which had carried passengers across the strait for almost forty years, sat low in the water.'
Sentence 2 (lines 5-6): 'Marcus, who had been the skipper since Priya was a child, leaned out of the wheelhouse window and called down that the tide would turn within the hour.'
A. 'that circled above the fish market roof' (describing the gulls)
B. 'which had carried passengers across the strait for almost forty years' (describing the ferry)
C. 'who had been the skipper since Priya was a child' (describing Marcus)
D. 'that smelled of diesel and salt' (describing the cabin)
E. 'that had capsized a smaller boat two winters before' (describing the crossing)
Which TWO of these relative clauses are non-defining - that is, they add extra information that could be removed without changing which ferry, cabin, gulls, crossing or person is being talked about?
- A
- B
- C
- D
- E
- A) '...called down that the tide would turn within the hour' (the clause 'that the tide would turn within the hour')
- B) '...the gulls that circled above the fish market roof' (the clause 'that circled above the fish market roof')
- C) 'Although the waves grew steeper beyond the headland...' (the clause 'Although the waves grew steeper beyond the headland')
- D) '...Marcus kept the boat steady, correcting the wheel with small, unhurried movements' (the clause 'correcting the wheel with small, unhurried movements')
A. 'Having checked the ropes twice' (line 7)
B. 'scrubbed clean by the storm' (line 20)
C. 'gripping the rail and trying not to think about the crossing that had capsized a smaller boat two winters before' (lines 14-16)
'the harbour master who had worked there for thirty years never trusted a calm sea, he always checked the forecast twice before any boat left, although the sky looked clear this morning something did not feel right.'
(10 marks are available for the content and organisation of your answer, and 6 marks for the technical accuracy of your writing.)
Question 1
- (a) When the last coach had rattled away from the harbour car park (cao)B1
- (a) Answer: When the last coach had rattled away from the harbour car park
- (b) Priya locked the ticket office and walked down towards the jetty (oe, accept up to 'jetty'; the trailing participle phrase 'listening to...' need not be included)B1
- (b) Answer: Priya locked the ticket office and walked down towards the jetty
Question 2
- (a) Although the waves grew steeper beyond the headland (cao)B1
- (a) Answer: Although the waves grew steeper beyond the headland
- (b) Marcus kept the boat steady (cao)B1
- (b) Answer: Marcus kept the boat steady
Question 3
- C) Complex sentenceB1
- Answer: C
Question 4
- an appropriate subordinating conjunction is used to join the two clauses (e.g. once, when, after, as soon as), oeB1
- resulting sentence is grammatically correct and correctly punctuated (comma after a fronted subordinate clause, or no comma if the subordinate clause is placed at the end), caoB1
- Answer: Once the tide had turned, Marcus steered the ferry back towards the harbour.
Question 5
- correct relative pronoun used to replace the repeated noun (that/which)B1
- no commas used, since the clause is defining (it identifies which rope), and the sentence is grammatically correct, caoB1
- Answer: The rope that was holding the smaller boat had frayed badly.
Question 6
- identifies the error as a comma splice: two main clauses are joined only by a commaB1
- gives a correctly punctuated rewrite, e.g. a full stop and capital letter, a semicolon, or a comma plus coordinating conjunction, oe/caoB1
- Answer: The wind was rising fast, so Marcus checked the ropes one more time. (Also accept: 'The wind was rising fast; Marcus checked the ropes one more time.' or 'The wind was rising fast. Marcus checked the ropes one more time.')
Question 7
- identifies that 'Because the tide was turning' is a subordinate clause wrongly punctuated as a complete sentence (a sentence fragment)B1
- gives a correctly punctuated rewrite joining it to the main clause with a comma, caoB1
- Answer: Because the tide was turning, Marcus called the crew back aboard.
Question 8
- (a) which had carried passengers across the strait for almost forty years (cao)B1
- (a) Answer: which had carried passengers across the strait for almost forty years
- (b) which (cao)B1
- (b) Answer: which
- (c) who had been the skipper since Priya was a child (cao)B1
- (c) Answer: who had been the skipper since Priya was a child
- (d) who (cao)B1
- (d) Answer: who
Question 9
- B selected (non-defining relative clause giving extra information about the one ferry, marked off by commas in the source)B1
- C selected (non-defining relative clause giving extra information about Marcus, a named individual, marked off by commas in the source)B1
- Answer: B and C are non-defining. A, D and E are defining relative clauses: they identify which gulls, which cabin and which crossing are meant, so removing them would leave the reference unclear, and none of them is marked off by commas in the source text.
Question 10
- identifies a straightforward effect, e.g. it establishes that the harbour has emptied of everyday visitors and it is now late/quiet (oe)B1
- develops this with reference to language/structure, e.g. the verb 'rattled' suggests noise fading into silence, marking the shift from the ordinary daytime world into Priya's solitary night shift before her name is even mentioned (oe)B1
- Answer: Opening with this fronted clause establishes that the harbour has emptied of ordinary visitors and that it is now late and quiet; the verb 'rattled' suggests noise fading into silence, marking a shift from the everyday world into Priya's solitary night shift before she is introduced.
Question 11
- AB1
- Answer: A
Question 12
- correct relative pronoun 'who' used to replace the repeated noun phraseB1
- correct comma placed before 'who' and after 'years' to mark the non-defining clause as extra information, caoB1
- Answer: The harbour master, who had known Marcus for twenty years, waved from the quay.
Question 13
- correctly formed -ing non-finite clause replacing the first simple sentence (e.g. 'Checking her watch')B1
- correct comma placed after the fronted non-finite clause, with the subject of the main clause matching the implied subject of the participle, caoB1
- Answer: Checking her watch, Priya hurried along the jetty.
Question 14
- identifies that 'which was over forty years old' is non-defining (there is only one ferry, so the clause only adds extra information) and so needs commasB1
- both commas correctly inserted, immediately before 'which' and immediately after 'old', caoB1
- Answer: The ferry, which was over forty years old, rarely broke down.
Question 15
- AO5: Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 1 Simple description of the journey and weather; little sense of a controlled narrative voice or organisation.1-2
- Level 2 Some relevant, engaged description of the sudden weather; an attempt at a consistent narrative voice; ideas are mostly sequenced clearly.3-4
- Level 3 Clear, engaging and convincing description of the journey and weather in a consistent, well-judged narrative voice; well organised with a genuine sense of atmosphere.5-6
- AO6: Technical accuracy (range of clause types) (AO6)
- Level 1 Limited accuracy; the four required clause types are mostly missing or used incorrectly.1
- Level 2 Most of the four required clause types are present and mostly accurate, with occasional errors.2-3
- Level 3 All four required clause types are present, clearly identified and used accurately and effectively, alongside a controlled range of other sentence forms.4
- Indicative content:
- First or third person narrative, past tense, describing a journey interrupted by sudden weather
- A fronted subordinate (adverbial) clause opens or interrupts a sentence, correctly followed by a comma
- A relative clause (defining or non-defining) is used accurately, with commas only where the clause is non-defining
- A non-finite participle clause (present or past) adds detail or action without a second full sentence
- An embedded/parenthetical clause interrupts a main clause, correctly marked off by a pair of commas (or dashes/brackets)
- Sense of atmosphere and the effect of the sudden weather on the writer or character, appropriate to a descriptive register
Question 16
- (a) present participle clause (oe: -ing clause, perfect participle clause)B1
- (a) Answer: present participle clause
- (b) past participle clause (oe: -ed clause)B1
- (b) Answer: past participle clause
- (c) present participle clause (oe: -ing clause)B1
- (c) Answer: present participle clause
Question 17
- identifies that the clause functions as the direct object of 'knew' (it answers 'what did she know?'), occupying a noun's role in the sentenceB1
- identifies that there is no specific noun directly before 'that' for the clause to describe, unlike a relative clause, which always modifies a preceding noun (oe)B1
- Answer: The clause functions as the direct object of 'knew' (it answers 'what did she know?'), taking the place of a noun rather than describing one, and there is no specific noun immediately before 'that' for it to modify, which is what a relative clause would need to do.
Question 18
- relative clause 'who had watched over the harbour for decades' correctly embedded between the subject 'The lighthouse keeper' and the verb 'switched'B1
- correct pair of commas placed immediately before and after the embedded clause, caoB1
- Answer: The lighthouse keeper, who had watched over the harbour for decades, switched on the beam.
Question 19
- (a) Although the waves grew rough, Marcus kept the boat steady (comma after the fronted clause), caoB1
- (a) Answer: Although the waves grew rough, Marcus kept the boat steady.
- (b) identifies a straightforward effect, e.g. fronting the danger builds tension or suspense before the reader learns the outcome (oe)1 mark
- (b) develops this, e.g. delaying the reassurance of Marcus's control until after the threat is stated sharpens the contrast between danger and his calm competence (oe)1 mark
- (b) Answer: Fronting the danger creates tension by making the reader confront the rough waves before learning that Marcus stays in control, sharpening the contrast between threat and his calm competence once the main clause arrives.
Question 20
- Level 0 No accurate corrections made; errors remain uncorrected or new errors are introduced.0
- Level 1 One or two errors corrected (e.g. the opening capital letter or one comma splice), with limited overall accuracy.1-2
- Level 2 Most errors corrected, including at least one sentence-boundary fix and an attempt at the relative-clause commas, with generally secure punctuation.3-4
- Level 3 All errors corrected accurately, demonstrating secure control of clause boundaries, embedded relative clauses and fronted subordinate clauses throughout.5-6
- Indicative content:
- Capital letter added for 'The' at the start of the sentence
- A pair of commas correctly added around the non-defining relative clause 'who had worked there for thirty years'
- The comma splice between 'calm sea' and 'he always checked' corrected with a full stop and capital 'He' (or a semicolon)
- The run-on between 'any boat left' and 'although the sky looked clear' corrected with a full stop and capital 'Although'
- A comma correctly added after the fronted subordinate clause 'Although the sky looked clear this morning', before 'something'
- Overall rewrite is fluent, grammatically accurate Standard English with correct clause boundaries throughout
Question 21
- Level 1 Simple, limited identification of clause types, with little or no use of subject terminology. Comments on effect, if present, are undeveloped.1-2
- Level 2 Some relevant identification of clause types, with some use of subject terminology. Some attempt to comment on effect on the reader, with limited textual support.3-4
- Level 3 Clear explanation of the writer's use of clause types, using relevant terminology accurately. Clear explanation of effect on the reader, supported by well-chosen textual detail.5-6
- Level 4 Detailed and perceptive analysis of the writer's use of clause types, using sophisticated terminology precisely. Explores subtlety and the shift in mood in depth, with sustained textual support.7-8
- Indicative content:
- The fronted adverbial clause 'Although the waves grew steeper beyond the headland' opens with concession and danger, delaying the reassurance that follows and building tension before the main clause arrives.
- The short, simple main clause 'Marcus kept the boat steady' provides a controlled, confident contrast to the longer, more complex clauses surrounding it, mirroring his composure.
- The present participle clause 'correcting the wheel with small, unhurried movements' adds a calm, ongoing action alongside the main clause, reinforcing his quiet competence without a second full sentence.
- The long chain of non-finite and relative clauses describing Priya ('gripping the rail and trying not to think about the crossing that had capsized a smaller boat two winters before') interrupts the main action, structurally embodying her spiralling anxiety through its length and complexity.
- The shift to direct speech and the participle clause 'grinning as though the weather were nothing more than a light drizzle' deflates the built-up tension with humour, the casual comparison ('a light drizzle') undercutting the danger just described.
- Overall, the contrast between short, simple main clauses and long, subordinated or non-finite clause chains maps directly onto the shift from danger to reassurance across this section.
Question 22
- Content and organisation (AO5)
- Level 1 Simple, limited vocabulary. Simple structure, sometimes unclear. Little or no deliberate variation of clause structure for effect.1-3
- Level 2 Some attempt to vary sentence and clause structure for effect, with some success. Some evidence of organisation and control of atmosphere.4-6
- Level 3 Clear, controlled variation of clause structure to build atmosphere and control pace. Generally effective organisation across the response, with increasingly sophisticated vocabulary.7-8
- Level 4 Convincing and inventive variation of clause structure, deliberately shifting between short main clauses and longer, subordinated or non-finite clause chains to shape pace, tension and atmosphere throughout.9-10
- Technical accuracy (range and control of clause types) (AO6)
- Level 1 Occasional accurate use of subordinate, relative or non-finite clauses. Simple sentence structures attempted, with limited variety.1-2
- Level 2 A reasonable range of fronted subordinate, relative and non-finite clauses used, mostly accurately punctuated, with some errors.3-4
- Level 3 A wide, controlled range of fronted subordinate, relative and non-finite clauses used accurately and precisely for effect, with consistently accurate punctuation of clause boundaries.5-6
- Indicative content:
- Opening with a fronted subordinate clause of time or concession to establish setting before the abrupt weather change
- Non-defining relative clauses used to add characterisation or description without starting new sentences
- Non-finite participle clauses (present or past) used to layer simultaneous actions or sensory detail efficiently
- Embedded/parenthetical clauses interrupting main clauses to add tension or additional detail mid-sentence
- Deliberate contrast between short, simple main clauses (for impact, e.g. at the moment the weather turns) and longer, multi-clause sentences (to build unease or anticipation)
- A confident, original narrative voice and setting, avoiding any resemblance to the source text's plot or characters
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.