Gas Attacks and Their Medical Treatment: Chlorine, Phosgene and Mustard Gas - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
14 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Gas Attacks and Their Medical Treatment: Chlorine, Phosgene and Mustard Gas revision guideMore GCSE History practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 11 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 25 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.9 Gas Attacks and Their Medical Treatment: Chlorine, Phosgene and Mustard Gas
"At dawn they released a strange smell and a man next to me went blind, his eyes streaming. The officers gave out small leather cups with a mouthpiece and straps, and the men who could still move helped carry the worst cases to the aid post. Some were sent back in wagons for more treatment."
How could you follow up Source B to find out more about the medical care given to gas casualties after a bombardment in 1917? In your answer give: the detail you would follow up from the source, the question you would ask, the type of source you would use, and how that source would help answer the question.
"The gas came over in a greenish cloud that rolled down the enemy trenches and into ours. Men arrived coughing and with foam at their mouths. We used whatever cloths we could get at first, but many needed to be sent back to hospital for serious breathing trouble. We had no special wards yet, and the smell lingered in tents for days."
Source B: From the diary of a British infantryman who witnessed a later gas bombardment near the Somme, March 1917.
"At dawn they released a strange smell and a man next to me went blind, his eyes streaming. The officers gave out small leather cups with a mouthpiece and straps, and the men who could still move helped carry the worst cases to the aid post. Some were sent back in wagons for more treatment."
How useful are Sources A and B for an enquiry into the immediate medical response to gas attacks on the Western Front?
Question 1
- 1915B1
- Answer: 1915
Question 2
- urine-soaked cloth pads or dampened cloths over the mouth and noseB1
- Answer: Urine-soaked cloth pads or dampened cloths held over the mouth and nose.
Question 3
- a casualty clearing station (CCS)B1
- Answer: A casualty clearing station (CCS).
Question 4
- feature 1 identified, e.g. separate gas wards were set up at casualty clearing stations and base hospitalsB1
- supporting detail for feature 1, e.g. these wards concentrated on eye treatment, bandaging and oxygen while keeping gas cases apart from surgical woundsB1
- feature 2 identified, e.g. there was a chain of evacuation from front-line aid posts to CCSs and then to base hospitalsB1
- supporting detail for feature 2, e.g. gas casualties with delayed symptoms might be sent back to base hospitals for observation and longer-term careB1
- Answer: Separate gas wards were set up at CCSs and base hospitals to treat eyes, bandage and give oxygen, keeping gas cases separate from surgical cases; and gas casualties were moved along the chain of evacuation from aid posts to CCSs and then to base hospitals for observation and longer-term care.
Question 5
- phosgeneB1
- Answer: Phosgene
Question 6
- the PH helmetB1
- Answer: The PH helmet
Question 7
- phosgene produced delayed symptoms, so soldiers could appear fine at firstB1
- Answer: Because phosgene caused delayed symptoms, so soldiers could seem unharmed at first.
Question 8
- 1917B1
- Answer: 1917
Question 9
- blistering of the skinB1
- temporary or permanent blindnessB1
- Answer: Blistering of the skin, and temporary or permanent blindness.
Question 10
- the Small Box Respirator (SBR) or small box respiratorB1
- supporting detail, e.g. it used a mouthpiece and filter and was issued from 1916B1
- Answer: The Small Box Respirator (SBR), which used a mouthpiece and filter and was issued from 1916.
Question 11
- oxygen therapyB1
- eye irrigation and bandagingB1
- Answer: Oxygen therapy, and eye irrigation and bandaging.
Question 12
- medical staff could treat symptoms such as breathing difficulty and eye damageB1
- they could not reverse the underlying chemical damage or provide an antidote for gases like mustardB1
- Answer: They could treat symptoms such as breathing problems and eye injuries, but could not reverse the underlying chemical damage or provide an antidote for agents like mustard gas.
Question 13
- a clear detail from Source B to follow up, e.g. the 'small leather cups with a mouthpiece and straps' issued to menB1
- a focused question linked to that detail, e.g. 'What was the official respirator issued to infantry in March 1917 and how effective was it?'B1
- a type of source to consult, e.g. an official War Office equipment report, an ordnance issue record or an RAMC equipment manual from 1916-17B1
- how that source would help, e.g. it would confirm what respirators were issued, describe how they were meant to be used and give evidence of their distribution and reported effectiveness or problemsB1
Question 14
- Level 1 Makes general comments about the sources with little reference to content, provenance or contextual knowledge.1-2
- Level 2 Makes some valid comments about the usefulness of the sources, using their content and provenance and beginning to link to own knowledge about medical responses.3-5
- Level 3 Provides a balanced, well-supported judgement of the usefulness of both sources, analysing content, provenance and using own contextual knowledge about medical responses to gas (for example the use of improvised cloths, the later issue of respirators, evacuation to CCSs and base hospitals, and the development of separate gas wards).6-8
- Indicative content:
- Content: Source A describes coughing, foam and the use of improvised cloths and the lack of special wards in May 1915, which supports knowledge that early responses were improvised at Second Ypres and that specialised gas care developed later.
- Content: Source B mentions eye injuries, the issue of a respirator with a mouthpiece and straps, and evacuation in wagons in 1917, which fits with the introduction of the small box respirator and the established evacuation chain by 1917.
- Provenance: Source A is a RAMC officer's letter, written soon after the first gas attack at Second Ypres, so it is likely to be a reliable eyewitness account of early medical shortages and improvisation, though it may emphasise immediacy and distress to its recipient.
- Provenance: Source B is a soldier's diary from 1917, giving a front-line perspective on equipment being issued and on the kinds of injuries seen, but it may lack medical detail and could reflect the diarist's shock.
- Usefulness: Together the two sources show change over time from improvised measures to issued respirators and organised evacuation, which is valuable for an enquiry into medical response; however both are limited in that they give fragmentary, personal perspectives and do not provide comprehensive medical statistics or hospital records.
- Own knowledge: An examiner should credit use of contextual knowledge such as the PH helmet and SBR being issued, the establishment of separate gas wards at CCSs and base hospitals, the use of oxygen and eye irrigation, and the later recognition that some gases produced delayed symptoms requiring observation.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.