Sunni and Shia Islam: The Historical Origins of the Split - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 5 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Sunni and Shia Islam: The Historical Origins of the Split revision guideMore GCSE Religious Studies practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 1 of GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 1 of GCSE Religious Studies 10-Minute Tests 2.
3.15 Sunni and Shia Islam: The Historical Origins of the Split
- A: Those who reject the authority of the Quran
- B: Those descended from the tribe of Quraysh
- C: Those who follow only the teachings of Ali
- D: Those who follow the Sunnah, the example and teachings of the Prophet Muhammad
Question 1
- selecting option D, those who follow the Sunnah, the example and teachings of the Prophet Muhammad, caoB1
- Answer: D
Question 2
- reason 1: he was a close companion and father-in-law of Muhammad, giving him prestige and trust, oeB1
- reason 2: some community leaders valued immediate continuity and political stability, so they chose an experienced leader quickly, oeB1
- Answer: Close companion and father-in-law of Muhammad; chosen to provide quick continuity and political stability.
Question 3
- Level 4 A balanced and well-developed evaluation that analyses arguments for and against the claim, refers to religious and historical evidence, considers alternative causes, and reaches a supported and justified conclusion.10-12
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that gives arguments on both sides with some supporting evidence, and a conclusion that is supported though not fully developed.7-9
- Level 2 An argument that addresses both sides but with limited support or development, and a conclusion that is attempted but not fully justified.4-6
- Level 1 A basic or one-sided response with little development and no real judgement or conclusion.1-3
- Level 0 No relevant material.0
- Indicative content:
- Arguments supporting the claim: the immediate succession dispute determined competing claims to leadership, setting the pattern for Sunni acceptance of elected or consultative caliphs and Shia insistence on leadership from the Prophet's family.
- The dispute created rival communities that developed different religious institutions and authority structures, making it a clear origin point for the divide.
- Arguments against the claim: later events such as the Battle of Karbala and the martyrdom of Husayn had a profound emotional and theological impact that deepened and ritualised the split.
- Social, political and regional factors, including power struggles, tribal alliances and the development of different legal and theological schools, also contributed to long-term separation.
- Religious arguments might note that interpretations of scripture and hadith, and the role of Imamate theology, evolved after the initial dispute, so the split was a process rather than a single cause.
- A balanced conclusion might argue that the succession dispute was a necessary and foundational cause but not the only or always the most important factor, since later events and institutional development also played major roles.
Question 4
- Uthman's assassination led to a period of conflict among Muslims over who should lead next, weakening trust that the community could agree on leadership peacefully, oeB1
- Ali became caliph in this period of conflict, but his authority was contested by other prominent Muslims, so his caliphate did not end the succession dispute, oeB1
- the conflict hardened developing views about legitimate leadership, contributing to the more distinct religious and political identities that developed into Sunni and Shia Islam, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. the assassination led to further conflict over leadership; Ali's caliphate remained contested; the conflict hardened the developing Sunni-Shia identities.
Question 5
- point 1: Shia Muslims traditionally believe the Imam must be a descendant of Ali and Fatima, appointed by divine guidance rather than chosen by the community, oeB1
- development: this means, for Shia Muslims, religious authority continues through a specific spiritual lineage rather than through election or consensus, oeB1
- point 2: Sunni Muslims do not require a leader to belong to the Prophet's family, and historically saw leadership as something the wider Muslim community could confer on a suitably qualified person, oeB1
- development: this reflects a Sunni emphasis on the community's collective judgement, whereas the Shia view places religious authority within a single, divinely guided line, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. Shia: Imam must descend from Ali and Fatima, divinely appointed; Sunni: no family requirement, leadership conferred by the community's judgement.
Question 6
- view 1: Sunni Muslims have traditionally understood 'those in authority' to include the wider community's chosen leaders, supporting the legitimacy of the elected caliphs, oeB1
- development: this reading supports the view that the community's own choice of a qualified leader carries real religious authority, oeB1
- view 2: Shia Muslims have traditionally understood 'those in authority' to refer specifically to divinely appointed leaders from the Prophet's own family, supporting the legitimacy of Ali and his descendants as Imams instead, oeB1
- development: this reading supports the view that true religious authority could only ever belong to the Prophet's appointed successors, not to any leader the community happened to choose, oeB1
- reference to a source of wisdom and authority made accurately, e.g. Surah 4:59, which instructs believers to obey Allah, the Messenger and those in authority among them, oeB1
- Answer: Contrast: 'those in authority' read as the community's chosen leaders (supporting the caliphs) versus read as the Prophet's divinely appointed family line (supporting the Imams).
Question 7
- Level 3 A detailed, well-organised answer that explains several reasons why Karbala and Husayn are important to Shia Muslims, supported by accurate reference to historical events and practice, with clear links made between the reasons given.5-6
- Level 2 An answer that explains some reasons for the importance, with some supporting detail, though links between points may be limited.3-4
- Level 1 One or two isolated relevant points are made about the significance, with little supporting detail or explanation.1-2
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Husayn's martyrdom is a central example of sacrifice and standing against tyranny, forming a model of moral courage for Shia Muslims.
- The event is commemorated annually during Ashura, which strengthens communal identity and reminds communities of suffering and resistance.
- Karbala shapes ideas about suffering, justice and leadership, reinforcing the view that true authority includes moral and spiritual qualities.
- Stories and rituals about Karbala encourage charity, remembrance and loyalty to the Ahl al-Bayt, the family of the Prophet, in many Shia communities.
- The symbolism of Karbala has political and social influence, sometimes inspiring movements that oppose perceived oppression.
- For many Shia individuals it provides a lived, emotional connection to history, theology and community practice.
Question 8
- way 1: commemorations such as Ashura mourning rituals in Shia communities, oeB1
- way 2: differing religious leadership structures, like caliphs and imams, oeB1
- way 3: historical writings and hadith collections emphasising different events or sayings, oeB1
- Answer: Ashura mourning rituals; different leadership structures (caliphs versus imams); different emphases in historical writings and hadith collections.
Question 9
- point 1: Ali was Muhammad's cousin and son-in-law, giving a close family connection seen as a basis for leadership, oeB1
- development: this family tie was interpreted by supporters as a sign of special authority and suitability, oeB1
- point 2: some believed Muhammad had designated Ali as his successor on certain occasions, so leadership should pass through his family, oeB1
- development: this belief underpins the view that leadership should be based on appointment and spiritual authority rather than election, oeB1
- Answer: Ali was Muhammad's cousin and son-in-law, suggesting close familial claim; some believed Muhammad had designated him, implying leadership should remain in Muhammad's family.
Question 10
- similarity 1: both agree that Muhammad died in 632 CE and that the community faced the problem of succession, oeB1
- development: this shared historical fact is the common starting point for later differences, oeB1
- similarity 2: both traditions revere the Prophet and his close companions and family, though they emphasise different individuals, oeB1
- development: Sunnis often highlight the companions who led the community, while Shia honour the Prophet's family and Imams, oeB1
- Answer: Both agree Muhammad died in 632 CE and the community faced a succession problem; both revere the Prophet and his close companions and family, though emphasis differs.
Question 11
- way 1: Sunnis emphasise community consensus and the role of elected caliphs, reflecting the early selection of Abu Bakr, oeB1
- development: this led Sunnis to accept caliphs chosen by consultation or appointment as legitimate religious-political leaders, oeB1
- way 2: Shia belief developed that leadership should be from the Prophet's family and include spiritual guidance from Imams, reflecting support for Ali, oeB1
- development: this resulted in Shia doctrines that combine religious and spiritual authority in the Imamate, distinct from Sunni models, oeB1
- reference to the succession crisis as the historical influence on both positions, oeB1
- Answer: Sunnis emphasise community consensus and accepted elected caliphs, reflecting Abu Bakr's selection; Shia emphasise leadership from Muhammad's family and spiritual Imams, reflecting support for Ali.
Question 12
- reason 1: historical memory shapes communal identity, so communities emphasise events that reinforce their sense of legitimate leadership, oeB1
- development: this can maintain cohesion and provide moral examples tied to leadership models, oeB1
- reason 2: contemporary political or social contexts influence which aspects of the past are highlighted, oeB1
- development: in some places, leaders may use history to legitimise current authority or to resist perceived oppression, oeB1
- Answer: Communal historical memory supports identity and models of legitimate leadership; contemporary political contexts shape which parts of the past are emphasised to justify or challenge authority.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.