Worked question 3 - Umrah and Exemption from the Obligation of Hajj
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | belief 1: some Muslims believe Umrah is not an adequate substitute because Hajj includes unique rites and a specific time in Dhul Hijjah commanded in hadith and tradition, oe |
| B1 | development: explain that Hajj includes standing at Arafat and rites with particular spiritual status which Umrah does not replicate, oe |
| B1 | belief 2: other Muslims believe Umrah has great value and can provide significant spiritual benefit when Hajj is impossible, oe |
| B1 | development: explain that Umrah is praised in hadith and is a meritorious act of worship that brings forgiveness and closeness to Allah, oe |
| B1 | for the required reference: a clear reference to a Qur'anic verse or hadith is given accurately by book/source name, for example a hadith about the merits of visiting the Kaaba or general Qur'anic teaching on pilgrimage and supplication, oe |
- Answer: Contrast: some say Umrah cannot replace Hajj because Hajj includes unique, time-bound rites such as standing at Arafat; others say Umrah is highly meritorious and brings spiritual benefit when Hajj is not possible, with a hadith or Qur'anic reference offered to support the second view.





