Animal Experimentation and the Use of Animals - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
8 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Animal Experimentation and the Use of Animals revision guideMore GCSE Religious Studies practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 7 of GCSE Religious Studies Topic Workbook 5 and chapter 7 of GCSE Religious Studies 10-Minute Tests 3.
6.8 Animal Experimentation and the Use of Animals
Question 1
- one valid reason, e.g. concern for animal welfare or suffering (especially in intensive farming), linked to a belief that humans should care for animals, oeB1
- a second, different valid reason, e.g. concern for the environment because livestock farming can harm creation, which humans are meant to look after (stewardship), or a belief that in Genesis 1:29 the first food God gave humans was plants, oeB1
- Answer: Any two different reasons, e.g. concern for animal welfare; concern for the environment and stewardship of creation; Genesis 1:29 (plants given as food).
Question 2
- supporters of animal research want it to continue because it may lead to medical and scientific benefits, oeB1
- opponents are concerned about the suffering caused to animals and about the number of animals used, oeB1
- the 3Rs (replacement, reduction, refinement) allow research to continue but aim to use fewer animals and cause less suffering, so each side gets some of what it wants, oeB1
- Answer: Supporters want research to continue for medical benefit; opponents want less suffering; the 3Rs let research continue while replacing, reducing and refining animal use.
Question 3
- point 1: many Christians believe God cares about each of his creatures, so humans should care about animals too, oeB1
- development: in Matthew 10:29 Jesus teaches that not one sparrow falls to the ground outside the Father's care, or another accurate scripture reference supporting the point, oeB1
- point 2: many Christians believe a good person looks after the welfare of the animals in their care, oeB1
- development: Proverbs 12:10 says that 'the righteous care for the needs of their animals', or another accurate scripture reference supporting the point, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. God cares for every creature (Matthew 10:29, the sparrow); the righteous care for the needs of their animals (Proverbs 12:10).
Question 4
- belief 1: many religious believers accept limited, strictly regulated animal experimentation where it could save or improve human life, believing dominion permits responsible use of animals for genuine human benefit, oeB1
- development: this can be based on Genesis 1:28's teaching that humans were given authority to rule over animals, understood as including responsible, regulated use for medical benefit, oeB1
- belief 2: other religious believers oppose animal experimentation, believing dominion means responsible care rather than permission to cause suffering, so using animals purely for human benefit is wrong, oeB1
- development: the Qur'an's teaching that animals form communities like human beings (Qur'an 6:38) is used by some Muslims to argue animals have a moral status that experimentation on them for human benefit disregards, oeB1
- reference to a source of wisdom and authority made accurately, oeB1
- Answer: Contrast: dominion read as permitting regulated experimentation for human benefit (Genesis 1:28) vs dominion read as care that rules out causing suffering (Qur'an 6:38).
Question 5
- (a) the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986, oeB1
- (a) Answer: The Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986.
- (b) there is disagreement about whether animals have a moral status/rights that should limit how they can be used, oeB1
- (b) there is disagreement about whether the scientific or medical benefits justify the suffering caused to animals, oeB1
- (b) Answer: E.g. disagreement about animal moral status/rights; disagreement about whether benefits justify suffering caused.
- (c) point 1: many Christians believe animals are part of God's creation and were given to humans to look after responsibly, not to exploit, oeB1
- (c) development: Genesis 1:28 teaches that humans were told to 'rule over' animals, which many Christians read as a responsibility of care rather than a licence for cruelty, oeB1
- (c) point 2: many Muslims believe animals are communities with their own status before Allah, deserving of respect and kindness, oeB1
- (c) development: the Qur'an teaches that 'there is not an animal on the earth... but they are communities like you' (Qur'an 6:38), oeB1
- (c) Answer: E.g. dominion as responsible care, not exploitation (Genesis 1:28); animals as communities deserving respect (Qur'an 6:38).
- (d) belief 1: many religious believers accept carefully regulated animal experimentation for genuine medical benefit, based on a stewardship reading of dominion, oeB1
- (d) development: this can be supported by Genesis 1:28's teaching that humans were given authority over animals, understood by some to include responsible, regulated scientific use, oeB1
- (d) belief 2: many non-religious campaigners argue that animals have an interest in avoiding suffering that deserves equal moral consideration, and that using them for human benefit is a form of speciesism, oeB1
- (d) development: the philosopher Peter Singer popularised the argument that giving less moral weight to an animal's suffering purely because it is not human is a form of unjustified discrimination, comparable to discrimination on grounds of race or sex, oeB1
- (d) reference to a source of wisdom and authority or another appropriate source made accurately, oeB1
- (d) Answer: Contrast: stewardship-based support for regulated experimentation (Genesis 1:28) vs anti-speciesism opposition (Peter Singer's argument).
- (e) L4 A well-argued, balanced answer that considers more than one point of view in a developed way, using accurate and detailed references to religious teaching and/or scripture to support each point, and reaches a clear, justified conclusion.10-12
- (e) L3 A clear and reasoned answer that considers more than one point of view, supported by relevant references to religious teaching and/or scripture, though the justification of the conclusion may be less developed.7-9
- (e) L2 A reasoned answer that considers at least one point of view, with some relevant supporting evidence, but with limited or no consideration of an alternative view.4-6
- (e) L1 One or more relevant points are made, but with little or no supporting evidence and no reasoned conclusion.1-3
- (e) L0 No relevant content.0
- (e) Indicative content:
- Agree: Peter Singer's argument that animals can suffer, and that giving less moral weight to their suffering purely because they are not human ('speciesism') is an unjustified form of discrimination, comparable to discrimination on grounds of race or sex.
- Agree: animals cannot consent to experiments or understand and agree to the suffering involved, unlike adult human participants in medical trials, which some argue makes using them fundamentally different from, and less justifiable than, human research.
- Agree: some religious believers who read dominion as responsible stewardship, not domination, argue that Genesis 1:28 gives humans a duty to protect animals from unnecessary suffering, not permission to use them for experiments.
- Agree: hadith describing kindness to animals as rewarded by Allah are used by some Muslims to argue that deliberately causing suffering to animals, even for human benefit, sits uneasily with Islamic teaching.
- Disagree: many religious believers argue that Genesis 1:28's teaching that humans should 'rule over' animals gives a level of authority that permits carefully regulated use of animals, including experimentation, for genuine human benefit.
- Disagree: many important medical treatments and vaccines have been developed with the help of animal research, so some argue a complete ban could cost human (and future animal) lives that could otherwise have been saved.
- Disagree: UK law already requires researchers to apply the 3Rs (replace, reduce, refine) under the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986, which some argue shows animal experimentation can be conducted responsibly and is not inherently wrong.
- Disagree: some non-religious ethicists argue that if an experiment causes limited suffering to a small number of animals but leads to a significant reduction in suffering overall, for both humans and other animals, a considered cost-benefit judgement can justify it.
- A balanced answer might conclude that whether animal experimentation can ever be justified often depends on the type of research, the severity of suffering caused, and whether genuinely effective alternatives have been exhausted, rather than there being one single, absolute answer.
Question 6
- belief that animals can suffer and their suffering matters morally, oeB1
- belief that alternatives, such as computer modelling or cell-culture testing, should be used instead wherever possible, oeB1
- concern that some experiments are unnecessary or do not lead to genuine benefits for humans or animals, oeB1
- Answer: Any three: belief animal suffering matters morally; preference for non-animal alternatives; concern some experiments are unnecessary.
Question 7
- one valid use of animals, e.g. as food (meat, milk or eggs) or as a source of materials (leather, wool), oeB1
- a second, different valid use, e.g. as working or assistance animals (guide dogs, sheepdogs, police horses), oeB1
- a third, different valid use, e.g. for entertainment or sport (racing, zoos, circuses) or as companions (pets), oeB1
- Answer: Any three different uses, e.g. food; working animals such as guide dogs; entertainment or sport; pets.
Question 8
- point 1: many Muslims believe Allah permits humans to eat the meat of certain animals as long as the animal is slaughtered in the way Islam teaches (halal), oeB1
- development: the animal must be slaughtered by a person who says the name of Allah as the cut is made, and the Qur'an teaches that Muslims may eat meat over which Allah's name has been mentioned, oeB1
- point 2: many Muslims believe some animals and some ways of killing are forbidden (haram), so not every use of animals for food is allowed, or that an animal must be slaughtered humanely, with a sharp knife and as little suffering as possible, oeB1
- development: the Qur'an lists carrion (an animal that has died of itself), blood and pork as forbidden foods, or Muslims are taught to spare the animal unnecessary suffering when it is slaughtered, oeB1
- Answer: E.g. halal slaughter with the name of Allah said (Qur'an: eat meat over which Allah's name has been mentioned); forbidden foods such as pork, carrion and blood (Qur'an), or humane slaughter with a sharp knife.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.