Worked question 4 - The First Cause (Cosmological) Argument
Answer and mark scheme
Question 4
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | view 1: Aquinas argued that since everything in the universe is contingent and at some time did not exist, if everything were contingent there would have been a time when nothing existed, and since nothing cannot cause something, nothing would exist now, oe |
| B1 | development: because things clearly do exist now, Aquinas concluded there must be at least one necessary being, which does not depend on anything else, and he identified this necessary being with God, oe |
| B1 | view 2: critics such as Hume question whether this reasoning is valid, arguing that even if every individual thing in the universe is contingent, it does not automatically follow that the universe as a whole, or the sequence of contingent things across time, needs a single necessary cause, oe |
| B1 | development: this mirrors Hume's fallacy of composition objection to the First and Second Ways, that what is true of each part is not necessarily true of the whole collection, oe |
| B1 | reference to a philosopher of religion made accurately, oe |
- Answer: Contrast: Aquinas's argument for a necessary being to explain contingent existence, vs a Hume-style doubt that the whole universe needs a single necessary cause even if its parts are contingent.





