Capture Recapture (GCSE Statistics) - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
63 original exam-style questions - 26 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Capture Recapture (GCSE Statistics) revision guideMore GCSE Statistics practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 2 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 2 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.6 Capture Recapture
N = (n1 x n2) / m
where N is the estimated population size, n1 is the number caught and marked in the first catch, n2 is the number caught in the second catch, and m is the number in the second catch that are already marked.
- A) The population is closed between visits (no births, deaths, immigration or emigration)
- B) Every individual is equally likely to be captured
- C) Marks remain visible and are not lost between visits
- D) The two samples, n1 and n2, must always be equal in size
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of fish in a lake.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of beetles in a field.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of badgers in a woodland.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of frogs in a pond.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of frogs in a pond.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Estimate the total number of deer in a park.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
| Site | n1 (marked in first catch) | n2 (caught in second catch) | m (marked recaptured) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Site A | 80 | 60 | 12 |
| Site B | 45 | 50 | 15 |
| Site C | 96 | 40 | 8 |
(a) Estimate the total number of frogs in a pond.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Estimate the total number of deer in a park.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of frogs in a pond.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of beetles in a field.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
(a) Estimate the total number of frogs in a pond.
(b) State one assumption you have made.
(a) Work out the proportion who cycle in each survey as a percentage, to 1 decimal place if needed.
(b) Which survey is likely to give the more reliable estimate, and why?
| Day | n1 (marked in first catch) | n2 (caught in second catch) | m (marked recaptured) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | 40 | 30 | 8 |
| Day 2 | 45 | 35 | 9 |
| Day 3 | 50 | 25 | 10 |
Before the project: n1 = 40, n2 = 30, m = 10
After the project: n1 = 54, n2 = 36, m = 9
Team X: catches and marks 20 butterflies in the first catch, and catches 15 in the second catch, both on the same day.
Team Y: catches and marks 80 butterflies in the first catch, and catches 60 in the second catch, one week later.
Question 1
- (a) n1 = the number caught and marked in the first catch, and m = the number in the second catch that are already marked (both needed), oeB1
- (a) Answer: n1 = number marked in the first catch; m = number of marked individuals found in the second catch
- (b) (50 x 40) / 8, oeM1
- (b) 250 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 250
- (c) any valid condition, e.g. no newts enter, leave, are born or die between the two visits (the population is closed), oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. no newts enter, leave, are born or die between the two visits
Question 2
- (a) (60 x 45) / 12, oeM1
- (a) 225 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 225
- (b) valid reason, e.g. the method relies on catching and marking only a sample of the fish, rather than counting every fish in the lake, so it can only give an approximate figure, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. it is based on catching a sample of fish, not counting every fish in the lake
Question 3
- (a) 14 caoB1
- (a) Answer: 14
- (b) (70 x 56) / 14, oeM1
- (b) 280 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 280
- (c) the rabbits that were marked in the first catch and were also caught again in the second catch (the recaptured marked rabbits), oeB1
- (c) Answer: the rabbits marked in the first catch that were caught again (recaptured) in the second catch
Question 4
- (i) True caoB1
- (i) Answer: True
- (ii) True caoB1
- (ii) Answer: True
- (iii) True caoB1
- (iii) Answer: True
- (iv) False caoB1
- (iv) Answer: False
Question 5
- D caoB1
- Answer: D) The two samples, n1 and n2, must always be equal in size
Question 6
- any valid method, e.g. use larger sample sizes for n1 and/or n2, oeB1
- any different valid method, e.g. reduce the time between the two catches so fewer births, deaths, or movements can occur; repeat the survey and average several estimates; use a marking method that does not affect behaviour or survival, oeB1
- Answer: e.g. use larger sample sizes; reduce the time between the two catches; repeat the survey and average the estimates (any two)
Question 7
- (i) Improve caoB1
- (i) Answer: Improve
- (ii) Worsen caoB1
- (ii) Answer: Worsen
- (iii) No effect caoB1
- (iii) Answer: No effect
- (iv) Worsen caoB1
- (iv) Answer: Worsen
Question 8
- 6/40M1
- 3/20 x 1000M1
- 150 caoA1
- Answer: 150
Question 9
- 10/100M1
- 1/10 x 3000M1
- 300 caoA1
- Answer: 300
Question 10
- 11/20 x 100 or 112/200 x 100M1
- 55% and 56% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (200 compared with 20)B1
- Answer: (a) 55% and 56%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 11
- 60 x 40 / 5M1
- 480 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 480; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 12
- 300 x 60M1
- 18000 kg caoA1
- Answer: 18000 kg
Question 13
- 33/50 x 100 or 167/250 x 100M1
- 66% and 66.8% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (250 compared with 50)B1
- Answer: (a) 66% and 66.8%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 14
- 60 x 20 / 8M1
- 150 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 150; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 15
- 16/80M1
- 1/5 x 4000M1
- 800 caoA1
- Answer: 800
Question 16
- 3/25 x 100 or 32/250 x 100M1
- 12% and 12.8% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (250 compared with 25)B1
- Answer: (a) 12% and 12.8%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 17
- 100 x 40 / 8M1
- 500 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 500; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 18
- 56/200M1
- 7/25 x 1200M1
- 336 caoA1
- Answer: 336
Question 19
- 35/50 x 100 or 72/100 x 100M1
- 70% and 72% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (100 compared with 50)B1
- Answer: (a) 70% and 72%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 20
- 37/80M1
- 37/80 x 2000M1
- 925 caoA1
- Answer: 925
Question 21
- 200 x 87M1
- 17400 kg caoA1
- Answer: 17400 kg
Question 22
- 30 x 40 / 4M1
- 300 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 300; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 23
- 300 x 85M1
- 25500 kg caoA1
- Answer: 25500 kg
Question 24
- 6/25 x 100 or 62/250 x 100M1
- 24% and 24.8% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (250 compared with 25)B1
- Answer: (a) 24% and 24.8%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 25
- 20 x 30 / 5M1
- 120 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 120; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 26
- 23/50M1
- 23/50 x 1200M1
- 552 caoA1
- Answer: 552
Question 27
- 13/40M1
- 13/40 x 5000M1
- 1625 caoA1
- Answer: 1625
Question 28
- 30 x 30 / 6M1
- 150 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 150; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 29
- 40/200M1
- 1/5 x 5000M1
- 1000 caoA1
- Answer: 1000
Question 30
- 25/50 x 100 or 104/200 x 100M1
- 50% and 52% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (200 compared with 50)B1
- Answer: (a) 50% and 52%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 31
- 11/100M1
- 11/100 x 5000M1
- 550 caoA1
- Answer: 550
Question 32
- (a) correct method shown for at least one site, e.g. (80 x 60)/12, oeM1
- (a) 400, 150 and 480 all correctA1
- (a) Answer: Site A = 400, Site B = 150, Site C = 480
- (b) Site C cao, ft from part (a)B1
- (b) Answer: Site C
- (c) valid reason, e.g. the surveys may have been carried out under different conditions at each site (different weather, time of year, effort, or time between catches), so the estimates may not be equally reliable or directly comparable, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. the three surveys may not have used the same conditions or level of effort, so the estimates may not be directly comparable
Question 33
- 400 x 45M1
- 18000 kg caoA1
- Answer: 18000 kg
Question 34
- 60 x 60 / 8M1
- 450 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 450; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 35
- 23/80M1
- 23/80 x 5000M1
- 1438 caoA1
- Answer: 1438
Question 36
- 300 x 66M1
- 19800 kg caoA1
- Answer: 19800 kg
Question 37
- 60 x 30 / 5M1
- 360 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 360; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 38
- 2/20 x 100 or 14/100 x 100M1
- 10% and 14% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (100 compared with 20)B1
- Answer: (a) 10% and 14%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 39
- 2/20 x 100 or 22/250 x 100M1
- 10% and 8.8% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (250 compared with 20)B1
- Answer: (a) 10% and 8.8%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 40
- 30 x 60 / 15M1
- 120 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 120; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 41
- (a) (37 x 52)/9, oe (= 213.7...)M1
- (a) 214 cao (awrt)A1
- (a) Answer: 214
- (b) valid explanation, e.g. you cannot have a fraction of an otter, so the population estimate must be a whole number of animals, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. you cannot have a fraction of an otter; the population must be a whole number
Question 42
- 13/20 x 100 or 67/100 x 100M1
- 65% and 67% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (100 compared with 20)B1
- Answer: (a) 65% and 67%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 43
- 3/50 x 100 or 19/250 x 100M1
- 6% and 7.6% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (250 compared with 50)B1
- Answer: (a) 6% and 7.6%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 44
- 17/200M1
- 17/200 x 2500M1
- 213 caoA1
- Answer: 213
Question 45
- 97/200M1
- 97/200 x 5000M1
- 2425 caoA1
- Answer: 2425
Question 46
- 100 x 60 / 5M1
- 1200 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 1200; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 47
- 3/20 x 100 or 19/100 x 100M1
- 15% and 19% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (100 compared with 20)B1
- Answer: (a) 15% and 19%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 48
- (a) n2 = (N x m) / n1, oeB1
- (a) Answer: n2 = (N x m) / n1
- (b) (180 x 5)/30, oeM1
- (b) 30 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 30
Question 49
- 7/80M1
- 7/80 x 1000M1
- 88 caoA1
- Answer: 88
Question 50
- 50 x 40 / 20M1
- 100 caoA1
- e.g. the population has not changed between catches (no births, deaths, or migration), or marked ones mix back evenlyB1
- Answer: (a) 100; (b) the population is unchanged between the two catches
Question 51
- 15/50 x 100 or 32/100 x 100M1
- 30% and 32% caoA1
- Survey BB1
- it has a larger sample (100 compared with 50)B1
- Answer: (a) 30% and 32%; (b) Survey B, larger sample
Question 52
- (100 x 50)/250, oeM1
- 20 caoA1
- Answer: 20
Question 53
- (a) valid explanation, e.g. some frogs that are actually marked will not be recognised as marked because their mark has faded, so they get wrongly counted as unmarked, oeB1
- (a) Answer: e.g. faded marks mean some truly marked frogs are wrongly recorded as unmarked
- (b) overestimate identifiedB1
- (b) correct reasoning, e.g. since m is in the denominator of N = (n1 x n2)/m, a smaller recorded value of m makes N come out larger than it should be, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Overestimate
Question 54
- (a) valid reason, e.g. animals move around and may hide, or the population or area involved may be too large to check every individual with certainty, oeB1
- (a) Answer: e.g. animals move and hide, and populations can be too large to count every individual directly
- (b) valid similarity, e.g. both use information from a smaller sample to make an estimate about a whole population, because examining every member of the population directly is impractical, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. both use a smaller sample to estimate something about the whole population, because a full count is impractical
Question 55
- (a) correct method shown for at least one day, e.g. (40 x 30)/8, oeM1
- (a) 150, 175 and 125 all correctA1
- (a) Answer: Day 1 = 150, Day 2 = 175, Day 3 = 125
- (b) (150 + 175 + 125) / 3, oe (or ft from part a)M1
- (b) 150 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 150
- (c) valid explanation, e.g. a single survey's estimate can be strongly affected by chance in exactly which individuals happen to be caught; averaging several surveys reduces the effect of this random variation on the overall estimate, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. averaging reduces the effect of chance variation between individual surveys
Question 56
- (a) (64 x 50)/10, oeM1
- (a) 320 confirmed caoA1
- (a) Answer: 320
- (b) 320 / 40, oeM1
- (b) 8 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 8 hares per hectare
- (c) 25 x 6 (= 150), oeM1
- (c) 170 cao (320 - 150)A1
- (c) Answer: 170
Question 57
- (a) any suitable question linking otters and this stretch of river, e.g. 'How many otters live along this 10 km stretch of river?', oeB1
- (a) Answer: e.g. How many otters live along this 10 km stretch of river?
- (b) valid difficulty, e.g. otters are shy, nocturnal, or hard to trap, oeB1
- (b) valid solution linked to the difficulty, e.g. use humane traps set overnight near known otter paths or holts, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. otters are hard to trap because they are nocturnal; use humane traps set overnight near known otter holts
- (c) (18 x 24)/6, oeM1
- (c) 72 caoA1
- (c) Answer: 72
- (d) valid comment, e.g. the samples of 18 and 24 are quite small, so a small error in catching or counting could change the estimate a lot, giving fairly low confidence, oeB1
- (d) valid improvement, e.g. repeat the survey with larger samples, or on several different days, and compare or average the results, oeB1
- (d) Answer: e.g. confidence is fairly low because the samples are small; repeating the survey with larger samples would improve reliability
Question 58
- (a) m tends to be higher than it should be, because marked animals are recaptured more easily than unmarked onesB1
- (a) since m is in the denominator of N = (n1 x n2)/m, a higher recorded m makes N smaller than it should be, so the population is underestimatedB1
- (a) Answer: m is too high, so N is an underestimate
- (b) overestimate caoB1
- (b) correct reason, e.g. trap-shy marked animals are recaptured less often than expected, so the recorded m is lower than it should be, which makes N larger than it should be, oeB1
- (b) Answer: Overestimate
Question 59
- (a) (60 x 50)/8, oeM1
- (a) 375 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 375
- (b) (60 x 50)/7, oe (= 428.5...)M1
- (b) 429 cao (awrt)A1
- (b) Answer: 429
- (c) valid comment, e.g. when m is small, a change of just one animal makes a large difference to the estimate (54 more adders here), so the method becomes less reliable and more sensitive to small counting errors when few marked animals are recaptured, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. when m is small, one miscounted animal changes the estimate a lot (here by 54), so the method is less reliable with small m
Question 60
- (a) correct method shown for at least one, e.g. (40 x 30)/10, oeM1
- (a) 120 cao (before)A1
- (a) 216 cao (after)A1
- (a) Answer: Before: 120; After: 216
- (b) valid comment on direction, e.g. the estimates do suggest an increase, from 120 to 216, oeB1
- (b) valid caveat, e.g. both figures are only estimates based on samples, each with their own possible error, so the true populations could be closer together than the estimates suggest, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. the estimates suggest growth (120 to 216), but as both are only estimates with their own possible error, the true increase may not be this large, and the conclusion is not completely certain
Question 61
- (a) (42 x 28)/14, oeM1
- (a) 84 confirmed caoA1
- (a) Answer: 84
- (b) (91 - 84) / 91, oeM1
- (b) their answer x 100M1
- (b) 7.7% awrt caoA1
- (b) Answer: 7.7%
- (c) valid reason, e.g. some tortoises may have been trap-shy and harder to catch a second time, or some genuinely unmarked tortoises may have been mistakenly recorded as marked, increasing m, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. some tortoises may have been trap-shy, or m may have been slightly overcounted
Question 62
- (a) (45 x 52)/9, oeM1
- (a) 260 caoA1
- (a) Answer: 260
- (b) 13/52, oeM1
- (b) their 13/52 x their 260 (ft)M1
- (b) 65 caoA1
- (b) Answer: 65
- (c) valid assumption, e.g. the proportion of badgers with mange in the second catch (13 out of 52) is assumed to be representative of the proportion in the whole population, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. the 13 out of 52 with mange is assumed to represent the true proportion across the whole population
Question 63
- (a) valid reason, e.g. Team Y uses much larger sample sizes (n1 and n2), which generally makes the estimate less sensitive to small counting errors, oeB1
- (a) Answer: e.g. Team Y's larger samples make the estimate less sensitive to small counting errors
- (b) valid reason, e.g. over a longer time gap there is more chance of births, deaths, or migration in or out of the meadow, or marks being lost, which breaks the assumptions the formula relies on, oeB1
- (b) Answer: e.g. a longer gap gives more chance of births, deaths, migration, or lost marks, breaking the formula's assumptions
- (c) valid design, e.g. use large sample sizes (like Team Y) but with a short time gap between catches (like Team X), so the population stays closed but the estimate is not too sensitive to small errors, oeB1
- (c) Answer: e.g. use large samples with a short time gap between catches
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.