Capture Recapture
Capture-recapture is a method for estimating the size of a population, such as an animal population, that would be impractical to count directly. A first sample is caught, marked and released; a second sample is caught later, and the proportion of marked individuals found within it is used to estimate the population size using N = (n1 x n2) / m, where m is the number marked in the second sample.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Capture a first sample of size n1 from the population, mark every individual, then release them so they can mix back in with the rest of the population.
- After giving the marked individuals time to mix randomly, capture a second sample of size n2.
- Count m, the number of marked individuals found within the second sample.
- Use the formula estimated population N = (n1 x n2) / m.
- Round the estimate to a sensible degree of accuracy, usually the nearest whole number, unless told otherwise.
- State the assumptions the method relies on: the population is closed (no significant births, deaths, immigration or emigration between the two samples), marking does not affect survival or behaviour, and marked individuals mix randomly with the rest of the population.
Common mistakes
MistakeMuddling which number belongs in the denominator, for example calculating N = (n1 x n2)/n2 or (n1 x m)/n2 instead of N = (n1 x n2)/m.
InsteadWrite out n1, n2 and m separately before substituting: for n1 = 20, n2 = 30, m = 6, the correct N = (20 x 30)/6 = 100; the wrong versions above give only 20 or 4, both smaller than the samples themselves, which is a useful check since a population must be at least as big as either sample.
MistakeLeaving the final population estimate as an exact decimal, for example 244.285714 fish, instead of rounding to a sensible whole number of individuals.
InsteadRound only the final answer to a whole number, since a population cannot contain part of an animal: for n1 = 45, n2 = 38, m = 7, N = (45 x 38)/7 = 244.28..., which rounds to 244 fish.
MistakeWhen a question states the second sample's size and how many of them were marked in the same sentence, using the second sample's total size as m instead of the smaller marked count within it.
InsteadCheck m is never bigger than n1: for '70 fish are caught, of which 14 are marked', n2 = 70 and m = 14, not m = 70, since only 14 of those 70 fish can be marked.
Worked examples
Example 1
In a lake, 50 fish are caught, marked and released. A week later, 80 fish are caught and 16 of them are found to be marked. Estimate the total number of fish in the lake.
- n1 = 50 (first sample, all marked), n2 = 80 (second sample), m = 16 (marked fish found in the second sample).
- N = (n1 x n2) / m = (50 x 80) / 16.
- N = 4000 / 16 = 250.
- Final answer: an estimated 250 fish in the lake.
Example 2
A conservation team estimates the number of hedgehogs in a nature reserve. They catch, tag and release 60 hedgehogs. Three weeks later, they catch a second sample of 75 hedgehogs, of which 24% are found to be tagged. (a) Estimate the total hedgehog population in the reserve. (b) The reserve is considered overcrowded if the estimated population is more than 800. Comment on whether this reserve is overcrowded.
- n1 = 60 (first sample, all tagged), n2 = 75 (second sample).
- m = 24% of 75 = 0.24 x 75 = 18 tagged hedgehogs found in the second sample.
- N = (n1 x n2)/m = (60 x 75)/18 = 4500/18.
- N = 250 hedgehogs.
- Final answer: the estimated population is 250 hedgehogs, which is below the reserve's threshold of 800, so on this estimate the reserve is not overcrowded.
Practice questions
Q1[2 marks]40 birds are caught, ringed and released. Later, 60 birds are caught and 12 are found to be ringed. Estimate the population.Show answer
Answer: 200 ((40 x 60)/12)
Q2[2 marks]25 deer are tagged and released. In a second sample of 50 deer, 5 are found to be tagged. Estimate the deer population.Show answer
Answer: 250 ((25 x 50)/5)
Q3[2 marks]100 fish are marked and released. A second catch of 40 fish contains 8 marked fish. Estimate the fish population.Show answer
Answer: 500 ((100 x 40)/8)
Q4[2 marks]A population estimate using capture-recapture gives N = 300, with n1 = 60 and n2 = 50. How many marked individuals, m, were found in the second sample?Show answer
Answer: 10 (m = (60 x 50)/300)
Q5[2 marks]Explain why the capture-recapture method requires the marked animals to have time to mix randomly with the rest of the population before the second sample is caught.Show answer
Answer: So that the proportion of marked animals in the second sample fairly represents the proportion of marked animals in the whole population, giving an unbiased estimate
Q6[2 marks]A conservationist worries that marking makes animals easier for predators to catch, reducing their survival before the second sample. Explain how this would affect the population estimate.Show answer
Answer: Fewer marked animals would survive to appear in the second sample, so m would be too small, making N = (n1 x n2)/m an overestimate of the true population
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Statistics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Identify n1 (first sample, all marked), n2 (second sample size) and m (marked individuals found within the second sample) explicitly before substituting, so the correct values are shown in the correct places.
- For an 'evaluate' or 'comment on the reliability' question, name at least one assumption (the population is closed, marking does not affect survival or behaviour, or marked individuals mix randomly) rather than only restating the estimate.
- Round only your final population estimate, and round to a whole number of individuals unless the question tells you otherwise, since intermediate rounding can shift the final answer.
Q1[3 marks]A biologist catches, tags and releases 45 rabbits in a field. Two weeks later, she catches 60 rabbits and finds that 9 of them are tagged. (a) Use the capture-recapture method to estimate the total population of rabbits in the field. (b) State one assumption needed for this estimate to be reliable.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
Q2[4 marks]A capture-recapture estimate of a population of otters is carried out. 30 otters are caught, tagged and released. Some weeks later, 45 otters are caught, of which 10 are tagged. (a) Calculate the estimated population of otters. (b) A full survey later finds the true population to be 100 otters. Calculate the percentage error in the capture-recapture estimate.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q3[2 marks]Give two conditions that must hold for a capture-recapture estimate of population size to be valid.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 2 available
See real GCSE Statistics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- AQA GCSE Statistics past papers: 3 questions across 3 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- Edexcel GCSE Statistics past papers: 3 questions across 3 papers, latest tagged June 2022
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Capture Recapture worksheet pack - 26 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 2 of GCSE Statistics Higher Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 2 of GCSE Statistics Higher Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 2 of GCSE Statistics Higher 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: