Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 6 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
20 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 6 revision guideMore 13+ Common Entrance practice
This topic is chapter 6 of 13+ English Topic Workbook 3.
1.6-6 Reading and Comprehension (Non-Fiction) Set 6
Racing Against the Stars: John Harrison and the Sea Clock
Original narrative account written for Revision Library, grounded in the real history of John Harrison's marine chronometers and the eighteenth-century search for a solution to the longitude problem, including the 1707 Isles of Scilly disaster and the 1714 Longitude Act; no historical document or past-paper text reproduced verbatim.
[1] On a stormy night in October 1707, a fleet of Royal Navy ships returning from Gibraltar strayed hopelessly off course in the darkness and ran aground on the rocks of the Isles of Scilly. Four ships were wrecked within minutes of one another, and an estimated two thousand sailors drowned, in what remains one of the worst disasters in British naval history. The tragedy was not caused by an enemy fleet, nor by a sudden and unexpected storm, but by something far more ordinary: nobody aboard could say, with any real confidence, exactly where the ships were.
[2] Sailors of the time could measure latitude, their position north or south, reasonably well by observing the height of the sun or the Pole Star above the horizon. Longitude, their position east or west, was a far trickier puzzle. In theory, it could be worked out by comparing local time, calculated from the sun's position, with the time at a fixed reference point such as London; every hour of difference represented fifteen degrees of longitude. In practice, this required a clock that could keep accurate London time for months at sea, and no clock built in the early eighteenth century could survive a rolling ship, salty air and swings in temperature without losing minutes, sometimes hours, along the way. Shocked by the scale of the Scilly disaster, Parliament passed the Longitude Act in 1714, offering a reward of up to twenty thousand pounds, an almost unimaginable fortune, to anyone who could solve the problem, to be judged by a newly formed panel called the Board of Longitude.
[3] Among those who read of the prize was John Harrison, a carpenter from a small Lincolnshire village who had never received a single day of formal training in clockmaking. As a young man he had built precision clocks almost as a private hobby, carving many of the moving parts from a dense, oily wood called lignum vitae so that they needed no lubricating oil, which tended to thicken or evaporate over time and threw the timekeeping out. Most of the country's leading scientists were convinced that the answer to the longitude problem lay in astronomy, in painstaking measurements of the moon's position against the stars, not in a mechanical box of cogs and springs. Harrison disagreed, and in 1730 he travelled to London, his sea clock designs in hand, determined to prove that a machine could succeed where the astronomers' calculations could not.
[4] What followed was not a single triumphant invention but more than twenty years of relentless refinement. Harrison's first sea clock, known simply as H1, was finished in 1735 and performed promisingly on a trial voyage to Lisbon, yet Harrison himself was dissatisfied with it and immediately began again. H2 followed, then H3, each one heavier, more complicated and, in Harrison's own exacting judgement, still not quite good enough. Nearly a quarter of a century passed between the completion of H1 and H3, years spent testing, dismantling and rebuilding almost every part of the mechanism in a workshop that, by the late 1750s, still smelled faintly of the same lignum vitae shavings that had filled it decades before.
[5] The breakthrough was tiny. Harrison's real leap forward came not from making his sea clock larger and sturdier, as his earlier designs had assumed was necessary, but from making it dramatically smaller. Completed in 1759, H4 was little bigger than a large pocket watch, a complete departure from the bulky machines that had come before. In 1761, Harrison's son William carried it aboard a ship bound for Jamaica to put it to the ultimate test. After eighty-one days at sea, crossing an ocean in every kind of weather, H4 had lost a mere five seconds, an astonishing degree of accuracy that ought to have settled the matter at once. Yet the Board of Longitude, dominated by astronomers who had staked their careers on the rival lunar-distance method, seemed reluctant to believe that a self-taught carpenter's watch had beaten them, and Harrison found himself demanding a second trial, then a third, simply to be taken seriously.
[6] It took the direct intervention of King George III, who reportedly tested a replica of H4 himself and pronounced Harrison badly treated, before Parliament finally voted him a further payment in 1773, some forty-three years after his first journey to London with H1 under his arm. Harrison died just three years later, in 1776, having transformed a carpenter's hobby into an instrument that would guide ships safely across every ocean on earth. Every marine chronometer built in the centuries since owes something to his stubborn insistence that a machine, however small, could out-perform the stars. It is a story less about a single clever invention than about a man who refused, for over forty years, to accept that good enough was actually good enough.
- A) ran aground on the rocks of the Isles of Scilly
- B) an estimated two thousand sailors drowned
- C) was not caused by an enemy fleet, nor by a sudden and unexpected storm
- D) one of the worst disasters in British naval history
- A) more interesting
- B) more difficult
- C) more dangerous
- D) more expensive
Question 1
- (a) wandered/drifted off the correct course (oe)B1
- (b) certainty or assurance about something (oe)B1
- Answer: (a) Wandered or drifted off the correct course. (b) Certainty or assurance about something.
Question 2
- (a) 1735, caoB1
- (a) Answer: 1735.
- (b) Lisbon, caoB1
- (b) Answer: Lisbon.
Question 3
- (a) 1759, caoB1
- (a) Answer: 1759.
- (b) eighty-one (days), caoB1
- (b) Answer: Eighty-one days.
Question 4
- 1707, caoB1
- Answer: 1707.
Question 5
- (a) four, caoB1
- (a) Answer: Four ships.
- (b) (an estimated) two thousand, cao (accept a numerical value approaching this figure)B1
- (b) Answer: An estimated two thousand.
Question 6
- (a) latitude, caoB1
- (a) Answer: Latitude.
- (b) 1714, caoB1
- (b) Answer: 1714.
Question 7
- (a) a carpenter (from a small Lincolnshire village), caoB1
- (a) Answer: A carpenter.
- (b) lignum vitae, caoB1
- (b) Answer: Lignum vitae.
Question 8
- recognises the short sentence signals a shift in focus, introducing the paragraph's main new idea before it is explained (oe)B1
- developed comment on effect, e.g. its brevity creates emphasis and a playful contrast (a small sentence about a small object), standing out against the longer sentences around it (oe)B1
- Answer: The short sentence signals a shift in focus, introducing the paragraph's key idea, that Harrison's success came from making his clock smaller, before it is explained in detail. Its brevity makes it stand out against the longer sentences around it, and its shortness even playfully echoes the smallness of H4 itself, giving the idea extra emphasis right at the start of the paragraph.
Question 9
- gives a meaning close to: constant, never letting up, unstoppable (oe)B1
- supports this with evidence from the text, e.g. 'more than twenty years' of work, immediately starting again after H1, and going on to build H2 then H3 (oe)B1
- Answer: 'Relentless' means constant, never letting up. This fits the paragraph because it describes Harrison spending 'more than twenty years' improving his design, immediately starting again after H1 despite its promising trial, and going on to build H2 and then H3, showing he never stopped trying to improve his work.
Question 10
- C only, caoB1
- Answer: C) was not caused by an enemy fleet, nor by a sudden and unexpected storm.
Question 11
- recognises the cause was mundane/everyday rather than dramatic or extraordinary (oe)B1
- developed comment, e.g. this makes the disaster feel more shocking or avoidable, since it resulted from a simple lack of knowledge rather than a dramatic force like an enemy or storm (oe)B1
- Answer: The phrase suggests the cause was mundane and everyday rather than something dramatic or extraordinary. This makes the disaster feel more shocking and preventable, since it resulted from a simple lack of knowledge, not knowing the ships' position, rather than a dramatic force such as an enemy attack or a storm.
Question 12
- B only, caoB1
- Answer: B) more difficult.
Question 13
- recognises the phrase reflects the dismissive/underwhelming way most scientists viewed a mechanical solution (oe)B1
- developed comment on effect, e.g. it contrasts a simple-sounding machine with the grand astronomical calculations most experts trusted, emphasising how unlikely Harrison's plan seemed and how much prejudice he faced (oe)B1
- Answer: The phrase makes a mechanical clock sound simple and unimpressive, just cogs and springs, reflecting how dismissively most scientists viewed the idea compared with grand astronomical calculations. This contrast helps the reader understand how unlikely Harrison's solution seemed to the experts of his day, and how much scepticism he had to overcome.
Question 14
- recognises Harrison was a perfectionist, unsatisfied even with a design that performed well (oe), e.g. 'dissatisfied with it and immediately began again'B1
- recognises the sheer scale and persistence of the effort involved, e.g. 'more than twenty years' / 'nearly a quarter of a century' spent testing and rebuilding (oe)B1
- recognises the meticulous, almost obsessive attention to detail, e.g. the workshop still smelling of the same wood shavings decades later (oe)B1
- Answer: Paragraph [4] gives the impression that Harrison was a perfectionist who was never satisfied, immediately restarting even after H1 performed promisingly. It also shows the sheer scale of his persistence, spending nearly a quarter of a century testing and rebuilding his designs, with the detail of the workshop still smelling of the same wood shavings decades later suggesting an almost obsessive attention to detail.
Question 15
- identifies that the Board was dominated by astronomers who supported the rival lunar-distance method (oe)B1
- recognises these astronomers had 'staked their careers' on that rival method, giving them a personal or professional reason to resist Harrison's success (oe)B1
- recognises a reluctance to accept that a self-taught craftsman, rather than a trained scientist, had solved the problem (oe)B1
- Answer: The Board of Longitude was dominated by astronomers who had staked their own careers on the rival lunar-distance method, giving them a personal reason to resist accepting that a mechanical clock had succeeded instead. The passage also suggests they were reluctant to believe that a self-taught carpenter, rather than a trained scientist, could have solved a problem that had defeated the experts.
Question 16
- identifies an apt quotation, e.g. 'a machine, however small, could out-perform the stars' or 'good enough was actually good enough' (any apt example of descriptive/figurative language)B1
- explains its effect, e.g. the contrast between a tiny machine and the stars captures the scale of what Harrison achieved, making his success feel more remarkable (oe)B1
- Answer: The phrase 'a machine, however small, could out-perform the stars' is an effective example of figurative language. It sets a tiny mechanical object directly against something as vast as the stars, and this contrast captures just how remarkable Harrison's achievement was, a small, humble invention beating a method based on the whole night sky.
Question 17
- recognises the phrase echoes Harrison's perfectionism shown earlier in the passage (oe)B1
- developed comment, e.g. it sums up his decades of restarting and refining (H1 to H4) in a single memorable line, giving the passage a satisfying, reflective close (oe)B1
- Answer: The line is fitting because it echoes Harrison's perfectionism shown earlier in the passage, particularly his repeated dissatisfaction with H1, H2 and H3 despite each one working reasonably well. By summing up decades of restarting and refining in one memorable, almost paradoxical line, it gives the passage a satisfying and reflective close.
Question 18
- recognises longitude could be worked out by comparing local time (from the sun) with the time at a fixed reference point such as London (oe)B1
- recognises each hour of time difference represented fifteen degrees of longitude (oe)B1
- developed own-words comment linking these points to the need for accuracy, e.g. this method only worked if the clock kept London time correctly for the whole voyage, and existing clocks lost too much time at sea to be reliable (oe); allow 1 mark only for a lifted quotation without rephrasingB1
- Answer: Longitude could be calculated by comparing the local time worked out from the sun with the time at a fixed point such as London, since every hour of difference stood for fifteen degrees of longitude. This method only worked, though, if a clock could keep London time accurately for the whole voyage, and no clock of the time could survive the conditions at sea without losing too much time to be trusted.
Question 19
- Level 1 Identifies a detail or technique with little or no explanation of how it contributes to a sense of determination; may retell events rather than analyse the writing.1-2
- Level 2 Explains, with some development, how one or two paragraphs contribute to a sense of Harrison's determination, supported by relevant reference to the text.3-4
- Level 3 Gives a clear, well-developed explanation of how at least three paragraphs work together to build a cumulative sense of determination, with precise textual reference and secure understanding of the text's overall structure.5-6
- Indicative content:
- paragraph [1] establishes the high stakes from the outset, showing the deadly consequences of the problem Harrison would go on to spend his life solving
- paragraph [3] introduces Harrison as an outsider with no formal training, facing scientists convinced the answer lay in astronomy, establishing the scale of the challenge
- paragraph [4] shows sustained persistence over 'more than twenty years', with Harrison restarting immediately after H1 despite promising results
- paragraph [5] shows determination surviving even after apparent success, as Harrison has to demand 'a second trial, then a third, simply to be taken seriously' despite H4's accuracy
- paragraph [6] closes with the concrete detail that recognition took 'forty-three years' from his first journey to London, reinforcing the scale of his persistence, before generalising this into his lasting legacy
- the structure moves cumulatively from the problem's deadly stakes, through repeated setbacks and self-imposed restarts, to resistance even after success, so that each paragraph deepens the reader's sense of just how determined Harrison had to be
Question 20
- Level 1 Simple agreement or disagreement with little or no reference to the text; general, unsupported comment.1-2
- Level 2 Some relevant comment on either Harrison's cleverness or his patience, with limited textual reference; a one-sided or partial view.3-4
- Level 3 Clear, supported comparison of Harrison's cleverness and his patience, with relevant quotation or close reference to both paragraph [3] and paragraphs [4]/[5], reaching a reasoned judgement.5-6
- Level 4 A sophisticated, balanced response that weighs Harrison's inventiveness and his patience precisely against each other, integrates well-chosen textual reference throughout, and reaches a considered, well-justified personal judgement, potentially recognising how the two qualities reinforce one another.7-8
- Indicative content:
- candidates agreeing with the statement might focus on paragraph [4]'s 'more than twenty years of relentless refinement' and paragraph [5]'s demand for 'a second trial, then a third', arguing that this decades-long persistence, even after success, is what ultimately mattered most
- candidates disagreeing might argue that paragraph [3] shows the true achievement lies in Harrison's originality and ingenuity, such as carving clock parts from lignum vitae to avoid needing oil, or the leap in paragraph [5] of realising H4 needed to be smaller rather than sturdier, arguing cleverness came first and made the patience worthwhile
- candidates might note the concrete detail in paragraph [6] that recognition took forty-three years as evidence that patience, not any single clever idea, was the deciding factor in his eventual success
- a balanced answer might argue the two cannot really be separated: Harrison's cleverness produced each successive design (H1 to H4), while his patience was what allowed him to keep refining and defending that cleverness across decades of setbacks and scepticism
- credit any well-supported view, whether the candidate ultimately privileges the cleverness, the patience, or judges them as equally important, provided the judgement is backed by close, accurate reference to the text
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.