Reading and Comprehension (Prose) Set 3 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
21 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Reading and Comprehension (Prose) Set 3 revision guideMore 13+ Common Entrance practice
This topic is chapter 3 of 13+ English Topic Workbook 1.
1.1-3 Reading and Comprehension (Prose) Set 3
The Attic Violin
An original short story written for Revision Library.
[1] Freya had expected the attic at Foxglove Cottage to hold nothing more interesting than moth-eaten blankets and a few chipped teacups, but the low room under the eaves turned out to be a museum of somebody else's whole life. A rocking horse with a cracked ear stood guard beside stacks of yellowing postcards, and a rail of faded floral dresses hung along one wall like a row of ghosts waiting patiently for a party that had ended decades ago. Dust hung in the single shaft of light from the skylight, drifting as slowly as ash settling after a fire, and the whole space smelled of beeswax polish, mothballs and something older still, something Freya could not quite name. Great-Aunt Hettie had asked for the attic to be cleared before the move to Larkspur Court, and it was, she had said firmly from the doorway below, 'high time somebody dealt with sixty years of clutter.'
[2] It was while shifting a tea chest away from the cold water tank that Freya's fingers brushed something hard and rectangular, wedged into the narrow gap behind the pipework. She had to kneel flat on the rough floorboards and reach with her whole arm before she could work the object free: a black case, its corners furred with damp, its leather handle stiffened almost to the point of snapping. The catches had rusted shut, and it took several minutes of careful wiggling with a flathead screwdriver borrowed from the kitchen drawer before the lid finally sighed open on hinges that had not moved in half a lifetime.
[3] Inside, nestled in a bed of moth-eaten velvet the colour of a bruise, lay a violin. One string curled loose and broken across the fingerboard like a fallen strand of hair, and a fine grey bloom of old resin dust coated the wood beneath the bridge. Wedged into the compartment meant for spare strings, Freya found a bundle of envelopes tied with a ribbon gone the brittle brown of dead leaves. She carried the whole find downstairs balanced carefully in both arms, as though she were carrying something that might wake.
[4] Great-Aunt Hettie went very still when she saw what lay in Freya's hands. For a long moment she said nothing at all, and the only sound in the small sitting room was the tick of the mantel clock, suddenly much louder than before. 'I wondered if that old thing had rotted through by now,' she said eventually, though her voice had lost its usual brisk certainty. 'Put the kettle on, Freya, and I will tell you why a violin has spent sixty years hiding behind a water tank instead of being played.'
[5] The story came out slowly, in pieces, punctuated by sips of tea gone cold. At seventeen, Hettie had won a place to study violin at a college in London, offered after a single audition by a teacher named Miss Nwosu, who had written to say she had 'not heard talent of that clarity in a decade.' That same spring, Hettie's mother fell seriously ill, and with her father needed at the family bakery from four o'clock every morning, someone had to run the house and mind her three younger brothers. Hettie never sat the entrance audition a second time. Miss Nwosu's last letter, which Freya read aloud at the table, still held a place open 'for whenever circumstances allow,' in handwriting that grew fainter and more hesitant with each line, as though even the ink itself sensed it was writing to no one.
[6] 'I told myself I would go back to it once the boys were older,' Hettie said, turning the violin gently in her lap as if it might still be startled awake. 'Then there was always a next thing, and then another, until it was simply easier to leave the case behind the tank than to look at it.' Freya said nothing, but that evening she drove into Skipton and returned with a fresh set of strings, and by the time Hettie's bungalow was finally ready the following month, the restrung violin travelled with her in the passenger footwell, not packed away in a box of things to be dealt with later. It was not perfect, Hettie admitted, propping it on the new mantelpiece where anyone entering the room would see it first; her fingers, after sixty stiff years, would probably never again find quite what they once had. But for the first time since she was seventeen, the violin was somewhere she could see it every single day, rather than somewhere she had chosen, quietly and for six decades, not to look.
- A) gently
- B) firmly
- C) anxiously
- D) reluctantly
- A) brand new and untouched
- B) damp, rusted and stiff with age
- C) burnt and blackened
- D) recently repaired
- A) confused and irritated
- B) bored and dismissive
- C) shocked into stillness and quiet
- D) delighted and excited
Question 1
- One relevant detail, e.g. stacks of yellowing postcards (oe)B1
- A second relevant detail, e.g. the rail of faded floral dresses described like a party that had ended decades ago (oe)B1
- A third relevant detail, e.g. Great-Aunt Hettie's own reference to 'sixty years of clutter' (oe)B1
- Answer: Any three of: stacks of yellowing postcards; a rail of faded floral dresses described as like ghosts waiting for a party that ended decades ago; a rocking horse with a cracked ear; Great-Aunt Hettie's own reference to 'sixty years of clutter'.
Question 2
- B only, caoB1
- Answer: B) firmly.
Question 3
- Larkspur Court, caoB1
- Answer: Larkspur Court.
Question 4
- B only, caoB1
- Answer: B) damp, rusted and stiff with age.
Question 5
- C only, caoB1
- Answer: C) shocked into stillness and quiet.
Question 6
- Hettie's mother became seriously ill (oe)B1
- Someone had to run the house and look after her three younger brothers while her father worked long hours at the family bakery (oe)B1
- Answer: Hettie's mother fell seriously ill, and with her father needed at the family bakery from four o'clock every morning, someone had to run the house and look after her three younger brothers.
Question 7
- Identifies an image of something pale, still or eerie/lifeless (oe)B1
- Developed comment linking this to the idea that the attic feels frozen in time, or holds on to a past that has long since ended (oe)B1
- Answer: The simile compares the dresses to ghosts waiting for a party that ended long ago, creating an eerie, pale image that suggests the attic has been left frozen in time, still holding on to a past that has since moved on.
Question 8
- Identifies a slow, gentle or delicate quality to the movement of the dust (oe)B1
- Comment on effect, e.g. suggests the stillness/quietness of the attic, or hints at something significant having happened there long ago (oe)B1
- Answer: The simile compares the drifting dust to ash settling after a fire, an image that is slow and delicate, suggesting the attic is completely still and undisturbed, and hinting that something significant happened here long ago, leaving traces that have settled quietly over time.
Question 9
- Identifies the idea of a carefully preserved collection, or objects on display representing a life story (oe)B1
- Comment on effect, e.g. suggests the attic holds significant personal history, or that Freya is an outsider viewing someone else's memories (oe)B1
- Answer: By calling the attic a museum, the writer suggests it is full of carefully preserved objects that together tell the story of somebody's whole life, and the phrase 'somebody else's' emphasises that Freya is an outsider looking in on memories that are not her own.
Question 10
- She had to kneel down and reach with her whole arm to pull the case free from the gap behind the pipework (oe)B1
- She had to spend several minutes carefully working at the rusted catches with a flathead screwdriver before the lid would open (oe)B1
- Answer: First, Freya had to kneel on the floorboards and reach with her whole arm to free the case from behind the pipework; then she had to spend several minutes carefully working the rusted catches open with a flathead screwdriver.
Question 11
- Identifies an image that is delicate, human or personal (oe)B1
- Comment on effect, e.g. makes the violin seem fragile or almost human, or suggests gentle neglect (oe)B1
- Answer: Comparing the broken string to a fallen strand of hair creates a delicate, almost human image, making the violin seem fragile and personal rather than simply an old object, and hinting at the gentle neglect it has suffered over the years.
Question 12
- Identifies a dark, purplish, or damaged/painful colour or association (oe)B1
- Comment on effect, e.g. hints at hurt, pain or a difficult, tender memory connected to the violin (oe)B1
- Answer: Describing the velvet as the colour of a bruise gives it a dark, purplish and slightly painful association, subtly hinting that the violin is connected to a difficult or tender memory rather than simply being an old, forgotten object.
Question 13
- Identifies that Freya is being extremely careful or gentle (oe)B1
- Links this to a sense that the violin, and the story attached to it, feels alive or significant, foreshadowing later revelations (oe)B1
- Answer: The simile suggests Freya is handling the violin with extreme care and gentleness, as though it were a sleeping creature, which gives the object a sense of being alive and significant, foreshadowing the important story that is about to be revealed.
Question 14
- Identifies a sense of tension, silence or a charged/uncomfortable atmosphere (oe)B1
- Comment on effect, e.g. the clock's ordinary sound becoming noticeable emphasises how completely still and tense the room has become (oe)B1
- Answer: Noticing the ordinarily unremarkable ticking of the clock suggests the room has fallen into a tense, heavy silence, and the fact that this small sound now seems 'much louder than before' emphasises just how still and charged the atmosphere has become.
Question 15
- Recognises she has clearly thought about the violin before, e.g. 'I wondered if that old thing had rotted through by now' (oe)B1
- Identifies a loss of composure, shown by her voice losing 'its usual brisk certainty' (oe)B1
- Comment linking this to complicated or unresolved feelings, e.g. that the violin carries a story she has avoided discussing (oe)B1
- Answer: Hettie's comment that she 'wondered if that old thing had rotted through by now' shows she has thought about the violin over the years despite never retrieving it, and the way her voice loses 'its usual brisk certainty' suggests she is more affected than she usually allows herself to appear, hinting that the violin is connected to complicated feelings she has avoided confronting.
Question 16
- Identifies the ink is personified as though it has awareness or feeling (oe)B1
- Links this to the letter fading in confidence/hesitation as it becomes clear no reply will come (oe)B1
- Comment on overall effect, e.g. conveys growing hopelessness or sadness, deepening the reader's sympathy for Miss Nwosu (oe)B1
- Answer: By personifying the ink as though it 'sensed it was writing to no one', the writer suggests that even the physical letter itself seems to grow uncertain and hopeless as it becomes clear no reply, and no return to music, will ever come; this deepens the reader's sympathy for Miss Nwosu's fading hope and reinforces the sadness of Hettie's lost opportunity.
Question 17
- She had to give up her place in London to care for her family after her mother's illness and never sat the audition again (oe)B1
- She told herself she would return to it once her brothers were older, but there was always something else that needed doing (oe)B1
- Over time it became easier to leave the violin hidden away than to confront what giving it up meant to her (oe)B1
- Answer: Hettie gave up her place to study violin in London to help care for her family after her mother became seriously ill, and never sat the audition again. She always told herself she would return to playing once her younger brothers were older, but there was always something else demanding her attention, until eventually it felt easier to leave the violin hidden away than to face what she had given up.
Question 18
- Level 1 Identifies language or details with little or no explanation of their effect; may rely on narrative retelling with minimal reference to the text.1-2
- Level 2 Explains, with some development, how specific words or details (for example the loud clock, Hettie's lost 'brisk certainty', or the fading handwriting) build sadness or regret, supported by relevant quotation.3-4
- Level 3 Gives a clear, well-developed explanation of how the writer's precise choices of language and detail work together to build sadness and regret, integrating apt quotations fluently and showing secure understanding of the effect on the reader.5-6
- Indicative content:
- the sudden stillness and silence when Hettie sees the violin, marked by the clock 'suddenly much louder than before', signals a shift in mood
- Hettie's voice losing 'its usual brisk certainty' shows a normally composed character becoming vulnerable
- the description of Miss Nwosu's praise ('not heard talent of that clarity in a decade') establishes what was lost, heightening the sense of waste
- the matter-of-fact listing of family duties ('someone had to run the house and mind her three younger brothers') contrasts starkly with the earlier promise of a music career, emphasising sacrifice
- the personification of the ink 'sensing it was writing to no one' conveys fading hope and unanswered devotion
- the short, blunt statement 'Hettie never sat the entrance audition a second time' delivers the loss plainly, without sentimentality, which intensifies its emotional impact
Question 19
- Level 1 Identifies a single structural feature (for example the opening description or the ending) with little explanation.1
- Level 2 Explains, with some development, one or two ways the passage is structured to build towards the reader's understanding, with reference to the text.2-3
- Level 3 Gives a clear, well-supported explanation referring to at least two points across the passage (for example, the shift from the mystery of the hidden case to Hettie's backstory, the delay before her reasons are fully explained, and the reflective final paragraph), showing secure understanding of how structure shapes the reader's experience.4-5
- Indicative content:
- opens with the mystery of an unidentified object hidden behind the water tank, creating curiosity before any explanation is given
- narrative focus narrows from the whole attic, to the case, to the violin itself, guiding the reader towards the central object
- Hettie's backstory is withheld until paragraph [5], after the discovery and her emotional reaction, building anticipation for why the violin matters so much
- the final paragraph shifts from past to present, resolving the story by showing Hettie choosing to display rather than hide the violin
- the closing image of the violin visible 'every single day' echoes and reverses the earlier image of it hidden away, giving the ending a sense of closure
Question 20
- Freya finds an old violin and letters hidden behind the water tank in the attic (oe)B1
- The letters reveal Hettie once won a place to study violin in London (oe)B1
- She gave this up to care for her family when her mother became ill (oe)B1
- Freya has the violin restrung (oe)B1
- Hettie decides to display the violin in her new home rather than hide it away again (oe)B1
- Answer: Freya finds an old violin and letters hidden behind the attic water tank. The letters reveal Hettie won a place to study violin in London but gave it up to care for her family when her mother fell ill. Freya has the violin restrung, and Hettie chooses to display it in her new home rather than hide it away.
Question 21
- Level 1 Simple or surface-level response with little reference to the passage; limited personal engagement with the question.1-2
- Level 2 Some relevant explanation with limited textual reference; makes a straightforward personal comment on why the ending is, or is not, effective.3-4
- Level 3 Clear, developed response with relevant textual reference and some apt quotation; explains effectively how particular techniques (for example the image of the violin travelling in the passenger footwell, or the reversal of hiding into displaying) contribute to an effective ending.5-6
- Level 4 Perceptive, well-evaluated response with sustained and precise reference to the passage as a whole; explores subtlety in the writer's choices (for example the restraint in never suggesting Hettie's playing will fully recover, or the symbolic act of display rather than storage) and their effect on the reader.7-8
- Indicative content:
- the detail that the violin 'travelled with her in the passenger footwell, not packed away in a box' symbolically elevates it above Hettie's other possessions
- the ending is deliberately restrained: the writer avoids suggesting a full musical comeback, noting her fingers 'would probably never again find quite what they once had', which feels honest rather than sentimental
- the final image of the violin somewhere Hettie 'could see it every single day' directly reverses the earlier image of it hidden 'behind the tank', giving the ending a satisfying sense of closure
- the calm, reflective tone of the closing paragraph contrasts with the emotional tension of paragraph [4], suggesting a quiet resolution rather than a dramatic one
- Freya's near silence at the end ('Freya said nothing, but...') lets her actions, rather than dialogue, show her response, which some readers may find a subtle and effective choice
- candidates may reasonably disagree about how satisfying the restrained ending is; credit any well-supported, thoughtful personal response, whether positive or qualified
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.