Market failure and government intervention
Market failure occurs when the free market mechanism, left alone, fails to allocate resources efficiently, meaning total welfare, the sum of consumer and producer surplus, is not maximised, or resources are misallocated relative to what would benefit society as a whole.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Define market failure precisely as a situation where the free market fails to achieve an efficient allocation of resources, i.e. total, community, welfare is not maximised, distinguishing it from a market outcome someone simply dislikes.
- List the main causes of market failure covered at A Level: externalities, negative or positive, in production or consumption, public goods and the free-rider problem, information gaps or asymmetric information, and market power or monopoly.
- Define a negative externality, a cost imposed on a third party not involved in the transaction, e.g. pollution, and a positive externality, a benefit received by a third party, e.g. from vaccination or education, and explain that in both cases the free market will not produce the socially optimal quantity.
- Define a public good using its two technical properties: non-excludable, once provided no one can be stopped from consuming it, e.g. street lighting, and non-rival, one person's consumption does not reduce what is available to anyone else, and explain how this causes the free-rider problem.
- Define asymmetric information, where one party in a transaction has more or better information than the other, e.g. a used car seller knowing more about a car's faults than the buyer, and explain how it can lead to a worse-than-optimal quantity or quality of trade.
- List the range of government interventions available and match each to the market failure it targets: indirect taxes and tradable permits for negative externalities, subsidies and direct provision for positive externalities or public goods, regulation for a variety of failures, and information provision for information gaps.
- Define government failure as a situation where government intervention, intended to correct a market failure, itself leads to a misallocation of resources or a net loss of economic welfare, and use it as the standard evaluation point when assessing any single policy.
Common mistakes
MistakeFor a positive consumption externality, such as vaccination, drawing the social benefit below the demand curve or moving the supply curve instead of adding the external benefit above demand.
InsteadDemand is the marginal private benefit. A benefit that spills onto third parties is added on top of it, so MSB lies above MPB and the socially optimal output, where MSB meets MSC, is higher than the market output. Supply (MPC) does not move.
MistakeCalling a good a public good because the government provides it, for example a state school place or a course of hospital treatment.
InsteadPublic good status depends on the two properties, not on who pays. A school place can be denied to someone and one pupil's place is not available to another, so it is excludable and rival. The government may provide it for other reasons, such as the benefits it spills onto others.
MistakeDescribing noise that a factory has already paid its neighbours to accept as an external cost.
InsteadAn externality is an effect on a third party that is not compensated in the transaction. Payment brings the cost into the firm's own decisions, so it is internalised; only any part left uncompensated is an external cost.
Worked examples
Example 1
A factory's private marginal cost of producing one more unit is 15 pounds. Producing that unit also imposes 6 pounds of pollution costs on nearby residents, who are not compensated. Calculate the social marginal cost of that unit of output, and explain why the free market, using only private cost, would lead to overproduction relative to the socially optimal level.
- Identify the private marginal cost: 15 pounds, the cost to the factory itself of producing the unit.
- Identify the external cost: 6 pounds, the uncompensated cost imposed on nearby residents from pollution.
- Calculate the social marginal cost: social marginal cost = private marginal cost + external cost = 15 + 6 = 21 pounds.
- Explain the market failure: a profit-maximising firm sets output based only on its own private marginal cost (15 pounds) compared with the price/marginal revenue it receives, ignoring the extra 6 pounds of external cost borne by residents.
- Conclude: because the firm does not take the full 21 pounds social marginal cost into account, it will keep producing units for which price exceeds private marginal cost but is below social marginal cost, so it produces more output than the socially optimal level, where price should equal social marginal cost.
Example 2
In the market for a vaccine, marginal private benefit (demand) is P = 60 - 2Q and marginal private cost (supply) is P = 10 + 3Q, where P is in pounds and Q in thousands of doses a week. Each dose also gives an external benefit of 10 pounds to people who are not vaccinated. (a) Find the free-market price and quantity. (b) Find the socially optimal quantity. (c) Calculate the welfare loss in the free market. (d) State the per-dose subsidy that restores the optimum and its total cost.
- Free market: set MPB = MPC, so 60 - 2Q = 10 + 3Q, which gives 50 = 5Q. Q = 10 thousand doses and P = 10 + 3 x 10 = 40 pounds.
- Add the external benefit to demand: MSB = 60 - 2Q + 10 = 70 - 2Q. Supply already includes every cost, so MSC = MPC = 10 + 3Q.
- The optimum is where MSB = MSC: 70 - 2Q = 10 + 3Q, so Q = 12 thousand doses, where MSB = MSC = 46 pounds. The free market under-provides by 2 thousand doses.
- Welfare loss: at Q = 10, MSB is 50 and MSC is 40, a gap of 10 pounds that shrinks to zero at Q = 12. The loss is a triangle: 1/2 x 10 x 2 = 10 thousand pounds a week.
- A subsidy of 10 pounds a dose, equal to the external benefit, lets suppliers receive the buyer's price plus 10. Buyers pay P where 60 - 2Q = 3Q, so Q = 12 and P = 36 pounds; suppliers receive 46 pounds, which matches their cost at 12.
- Total cost of the subsidy = 10 x 12 = 120 thousand pounds a week. Most of this is a transfer from taxpayers to buyers and sellers; the net gain to society is the 10 thousand pound triangle, less any cost of raising the tax.
- Answer: the market produces 10 thousand doses at 40 pounds; the optimum is 12 thousand; the welfare loss is 10 thousand pounds a week; a 10 pound subsidy restores the optimum at a cost of 120 thousand pounds a week.
Practice questions
Q1[2 marks]Define market failure.Show answer
Answer: A situation where the free market fails to allocate resources efficiently, so total, community, economic welfare is not maximised.
Q2[2 marks]Define a negative externality.Show answer
Answer: A cost of an economic transaction that falls on a third party not directly involved in that transaction, e.g. air pollution affecting nearby residents.
Q3[2 marks]State the two technical properties of a pure public good.Show answer
Answer: Non-excludable, no one can be prevented from consuming it once it is provided, and non-rival, one person's consumption does not reduce what is available for others.
Q4[2 marks]What is the 'free-rider problem'?Show answer
Answer: The problem that, because a public good is non-excludable, people can benefit from it without paying, giving private firms no incentive to supply it and potentially causing under-provision without government action.
Q5[3 marks]Define asymmetric information, with an example.Show answer
Answer: A situation where one party to a transaction has more or better information than the other, e.g. a used car seller knowing more about hidden faults in the car than a buyer does.
Q6[2 marks]Name one government policy used to correct a negative externality and one used to correct a positive externality.Show answer
Answer: For example, an indirect tax or tradable pollution permits to correct a negative externality, and a subsidy or direct government provision to correct a positive externality.
Q7[1 mark]Give one reason a government intervention intended to correct market failure can leave society worse off.Show answer
Answer: Information gaps mean the intervention can be set at the wrong level, for example a tax larger than the external cost, which over-corrects and creates a new welfare loss. Administrative costs and unintended consequences such as black markets can outweigh the gain.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Economics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- For a welfare loss with straight-line curves, use the triangle between the social and private curves: half x the gap at the market output x the difference between market and optimal output. Give the units, such as thousand pounds a week.
- Keep efficiency and equity arguments in separate sentences. This guide defines market failure by efficiency (total welfare not maximised), so label a point about fair shares of income as an equity point rather than as a further market failure.
Q1[6 marks]Using a diagram, explain how a negative production externality leads to a welfare loss in a free market.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[20 marks]Evaluate the effectiveness of government intervention in correcting market failure caused by negative externalities.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 20 available
See real A Level Economics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- AQA A Level Economics past papers: 7 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- Eduqas A Level Economics past papers: 4 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged Summer 2024
- WJEC A Level Economics past papers: 1 question across 1 paper, latest tagged Summer 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Market failure and government intervention worksheet pack - 6 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 2 of A Level Economics Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 2 of A Level Economics Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 2 of A Level Economics 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: