Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
Politics
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?
A Level Politics · Topic guide

Prime Minister and Executive

The Prime Minister leads the executive and exercises a range of prerogative powers inherited from the historic power of the monarch, including appointing and dismissing ministers, making senior public appointments, negotiating treaties and recommending the dissolution of Parliament.

A LevelUK GovernmentEdexcelAQAWJECCCEA

Before you start

Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:

Method

  1. Learn the Prime Minister's main prerogative powers, patronage, treaty negotiation, recommending dissolution, deploying the armed forces, honours, with one precise fact about each.
  2. Learn collective responsibility and individual ministerial responsibility as two distinct conventions, each with a real historical example.
  3. Learn the arguments for and against the 'presidentialisation' thesis as a specific list, not a vague impression, since this is one of the most common essay questions on the executive.
  4. For an evaluation question, plan three two-sided paragraphs, each weighing evidence the office has become more presidential against a genuine structural counterpoint.
  5. Give each paragraph a clear judgement before moving on; a paragraph that only lists ways the PM looks powerful, with no counterpoint about formal dependence on Cabinet and Commons, is capped in the middle band.
  6. Build a thesis-led introduction and a conclusion that weighs the three judgements to reach an overall, supported answer.
  7. Keep at least one historical example of a Prime Minister leaving office mid-term through party mechanisms ready as evidence against the presidential thesis, since this is a strong, checkable counterpoint.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeDescribing the Prime Minister's prerogative powers as powers held under an Act of Parliament.

    InsteadPrerogative powers are the historic powers of the monarch, used in practice by ministers and the Prime Minister, and they rest on common law, not statute. Parliament can regulate or replace any of them by Act, so state the current legal footing of each power you name.

  • MistakeCalling a minister's resignation over a failure in their own department an example of collective responsibility.

    InsteadCollective responsibility concerns Cabinet's shared position on decisions. A minister who answers for their own department's failure or their own conduct is applying individual ministerial responsibility, so classify a resignation by what caused it, not by the fact that a minister left.

  • MistakeSaying the Prime Minister is the head of state.

    InsteadThe monarch is head of state and the Prime Minister is head of government. A US president holds both roles at once, so compare like with like: set the Prime Minister's powers against the president's powers as head of government.

Worked examples

Example 1

'The Prime Minister's power depends more on personal factors than on the powers of the office itself.' Evaluate this statement. Plan the essay: a thesis, three two-sided paragraphs and a conclusion.

  1. Underline the claim: are PERSONAL factors, character, popularity, authority, more important than the FORMAL powers of the office, patronage, prerogative, chairing Cabinet.
  2. Choose three comparisons: (1) patronage, (2) crisis leadership, (3) removal from office.
  3. Paragraph 1: the formal power of patronage lets a Prime Minister appoint and dismiss ministers, shaping Cabinet loyalty directly, weighed against the counterpoint that a Prime Minister with weak personal authority can still be defied by senior colleagues who calculate the PM is unlikely to survive a confrontation, then a judgement.
  4. Paragraph 2: international crises can showcase a Prime Minister's formal foreign policy and prerogative powers, such as deploying the armed forces, weighed against the counterpoint that how a Prime Minister is personally judged to have handled a crisis, rather than the powers used, usually determines whether their authority rises or falls afterwards, then a judgement.
  5. Paragraph 3: formally, only a Commons no-confidence vote removes a government, weighed against the counterpoint that in practice most recent Prime Ministers who left office mid-term did so through their own party's internal mechanisms, driven by a collapse in personal or political authority rather than a Commons defeat, then a judgement.
  6. Write a thesis and a conclusion that gives a clear, supported answer on whether personal or formal factors matter more.

Example 2

Serious operational failures occur in the delivery of a government policy, and the minister responsible does not resign. Using the distinction between policy and operational matters, explain why individual ministerial responsibility does not always end in resignation, and what decides whether a minister survives.

  1. State the convention: a minister answers to Parliament for their department and is expected to resign over a serious failing that can fairly be laid at their door.
  2. Introduce the distinction: policy is the minister's own, but the day-to-day running of a service, its operations, can be given to an agency head or senior official, so a minister can accept that Parliament is owed an explanation without accepting personal blame.
  3. Give an example of the distinction in use: after high-profile prison escapes in 1994 and 1995, Home Secretary Michael Howard separated policy, which he said was his, from operations, which he said belonged to the Prison Service's director general. Howard stayed in office and Derek Lewis, the director general, lost his post.
  4. Give a contrast: in 1982 Lord Carrington resigned as Foreign Secretary after the Argentine invasion of the Falkland Islands, accepting responsibility for a failure of his department's judgement, although no personal misconduct was alleged against him.
  5. Explain what decides survival in practice: whether the Prime Minister and the governing party stand behind the minister, and whether the press and Parliament keep up the pressure. The convention is enforced by political circumstances, not by a rule that compels resignation.
  6. Conclude: individual ministerial responsibility is a real expectation, but the policy/operations distinction gives ministers a route to stay in post, so resignation depends on politics as much as on the size of the failure.

Practice questions

Q1[2 marks]What is meant by the Prime Minister's power of 'patronage'?Show answer

Answer: The power to appoint, promote, reshuffle and dismiss ministers, and to make a range of other senior public appointments and honours.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q2[2 marks]What is 'collective responsibility'?Show answer

Answer: The convention that all Cabinet ministers must publicly support decisions made in Cabinet, or resign if they cannot.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q3[1 mark]Give a historical example of a minister resigning over collective responsibility.Show answer

Answer: Robin Cook resigned from the Cabinet in 2003 in protest at the decision to join the invasion of Iraq, rather than publicly support it.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q4[2 marks]What is 'individual ministerial responsibility'?Show answer

Answer: The convention that a minister is personally accountable to Parliament for the conduct and performance of their own department and their own actions, and may be expected to resign for a serious failing.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q5[2 marks]Which Act restored the Prime Minister's prerogative power to request the dissolution of Parliament, and in what year?Show answer

Answer: The Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022, which repealed the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q6[2 marks]What requirement does the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010 place on treaties negotiated by the government?Show answer

Answer: Most treaties must be laid before Parliament for 21 sitting days before they can be ratified, giving Parliament an opportunity to object.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q7[2 marks]Give one criticism made of 'sofa government'.Show answer

Answer: That it describes informal decision-making, often among a small circle of advisers, that bypasses full, formal Cabinet discussion and reduces collective ministerial input into major decisions, a practice criticised by the 2004 Butler Review.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • Give each power or convention an example with the office holder and the year, so the point rests on evidence a reader can check.
  • When you compare the Prime Minister with the US president, take one feature of the office at a time, such as how it is filled, and compare both offices on it before moving on.
Q1[8 marks]Explain TWO prerogative powers exercised by the Prime Minister.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 8 available

Got it right?
Q2[30 marks]'The office of Prime Minister has become presidential.' Evaluate this statement.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 30 available

Got it right?

See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

This topic in real past papers

We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the Prime Minister and Executive worksheet pack - 4 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This topic is chapter 15 of A Level Politics Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 15 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 14 of A Level Politics 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.

Other versions of this worksheet:

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on Prime Minister and Executive, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.