Worked question 6 - Political Parties
Source A: Two approaches to party funding (a fictional case study)
Source written for Revision Library as a representative example for teaching purposes. 'The Renewal Party' and 'the Common Ground Party' are invented, fictional organisations, not based on any real UK political party, and no quotation is attributed to any real politician.
The Renewal Party was formed twelve years ago and now holds a small number of seats in the House of Commons. It has no large membership base and relies heavily on a handful of wealthy individual donors and business supporters, each contributing sums close to the legal maximum permitted without triggering the Electoral Commission's public reporting requirements for smaller donations. Its leadership argues this is simply prudent fundraising: 'We do not have deep historical roots, so we have to build support where we can find it.'
The Common Ground Party, founded over a century ago, has a large paying membership and, in some regions, retains a formal affiliation with local trade union branches, whose members' subscriptions include a small political fund contribution (from which individual members may opt out). It also receives short money, the public funding available to opposition parties in the Commons to support their parliamentary work. A party officer noted: 'Our funding is broader-based, but it still depends on institutions most ordinary voters have no say over joining.'
Both parties' income and larger donations are published by the Electoral Commission, the independent body that regulates UK election finance and conduct under the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 6
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) identifies a valid method, e.g. selection by a vote of local party members, or via a shortlist drawn up by a local party committee |
| B1 | (a) brief accurate development |
| B1 | (b) identifies a relevant criticism, e.g. that the party membership choosing a leader is small and unrepresentative of the electorate as a whole |
| B1 | (b) development, e.g. party members tend to be more ideologically committed than the average voter, so may not choose the candidate with the broadest general-election appeal |
| B1 | (b) further development, e.g. a party in government can change Prime Minister through an internal leadership contest without a general election being held |
| B1 | (b) notes a possible counter-consideration for balance, e.g. supporters of member-based leadership elections argue they give ordinary members, not just MPs, a genuine say |
- (a) Answer: Local party members typically select their parliamentary candidate, often from a shortlist drawn up by a local party selection committee, sometimes with an approved national list of candidates to choose from.
- (b) Answer: A common criticism is that party members, who elect the leader in most current UK party rules, are a small and often more ideologically committed group than the electorate as a whole, so may not select the candidate with the broadest general appeal; because the leader of the governing party becomes Prime Minister, this can mean a change of Prime Minister occurs through an internal party contest rather than a general election. Supporters of member-based elections respond that this nonetheless gives ordinary party members, rather than only MPs, a genuine and democratic say in choosing their leader.





