A Level Politics Essentials 1 includes Direct versus Representative Democracy and Debates on Reform (UK Politics); Political Parties (UK Politics); Rights and Civil Liberties in the UK: Protection and Tensions (UK Politics); Pressure Groups, Think Tanks and Lobbyists in UK Politics (UK Politics); First Past the Post: Operation and Impact on UK General Elections (UK Politics); Proportional Systems and Electoral Reform Debates in the UK (UK Politics); Long-Term Factors Influencing Voting Behaviour: Class, Age and Region (UK Politics); Short-Term Factors and the 2019 General Election Case Study (UK Politics); The Media, Opinion Polls and Their Influence on UK Elections (UK Politics); Party Funding, Internal Factions and Political Consensus in the UK (UK Politics); Liberal Democrats, Greens and Reform UK: Minor and Emerging Parties (UK Politics); The SNP, Plaid Cymru and Classifying the UK Party System (UK Politics); The Nature and Sources of the UK Constitution (UK Government); Constitutional Reform Since 1997 and Debates on Further Reform (UK Government); Prime Minister and Executive (UK Government); The Structure, Composition and Functions of Parliament (UK Government); Parliament's Legislative Process and Scrutiny of the Executive (UK Government); The Relationship Between the Executive and Parliament (UK Government); The Judiciary: Independence, Neutrality and the Supreme Court (UK Government); Judicial Review and the Judiciary's Power Over Government (UK Government); Parliamentary Sovereignty and the Impact of Devolution (UK Government); The Structures and Powers of the Devolved Governments of the UK (UK Government); The Comparative Powers of the Commons and Lords, and Lords Reform (UK Government); Referendums as an Instrument of Constitutional Change in the UK (UK Government); Conservatism (Core political ideas); Core Ideas and Principles of Liberalism (Core political ideas); Classical and Modern Liberalism: Tensions Within the Tradition (Core political ideas); Liberal Thinkers: John Locke and Mary Wollstonecraft (Core political ideas); Liberal Thinkers: John Stuart Mill and John Rawls (Core political ideas).
Method recap - Prime Minister and Executive
- Learn the Prime Minister's main prerogative powers, patronage, treaty negotiation, recommending dissolution, deploying the armed forces, honours, with one precise fact about each.
- Learn collective responsibility and individual ministerial responsibility as two distinct conventions, each with a real historical example.
- Learn the arguments for and against the 'presidentialisation' thesis as a specific list, not a vague impression, since this is one of the most common essay questions on the executive.
- For an evaluation question, plan three two-sided paragraphs, each weighing evidence the office has become more presidential against a genuine structural counterpoint.
Worked example - Prime Minister and Executive
'The Prime Minister's power depends more on personal factors than on the powers of the office itself.' Evaluate this statement. Plan the essay: a thesis, three two-sided paragraphs and a conclusion.
- Underline the claim: are PERSONAL factors, character, popularity, authority, more important than the FORMAL powers of the office, patronage, prerogative, chairing Cabinet.
- Choose three comparisons: (1) patronage, (2) crisis leadership, (3) removal from office.
- Paragraph 1: the formal power of patronage lets a Prime Minister appoint and dismiss ministers, shaping Cabinet loyalty directly, weighed against the counterpoint that a Prime Minister with weak personal authority can still be defied by senior colleagues who calculate the PM is unlikely to survive a confrontation, then a judgement.
- Paragraph 2: international crises can showcase a Prime Minister's formal foreign policy and prerogative powers, such as deploying the armed forces, weighed against the counterpoint that how a Prime Minister is personally judged to have handled a crisis, rather than the powers used, usually determines whether their authority rises or falls afterwards, then a judgement.
- Paragraph 3: formally, only a Commons no-confidence vote removes a government, weighed against the counterpoint that in practice most recent Prime Ministers who left office mid-term did so through their own party's internal mechanisms, driven by a collapse in personal or political authority rather than a Commons defeat, then a judgement.
- Write a thesis and a conclusion that gives a clear, supported answer on whether personal or formal factors matter more.
Question 9 - Prime Minister and Executive
30 marks
'The office of Prime Minister has become presidential.' Evaluate this statement.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [30 marks]| Question 9[30 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Excellent, detailed and accurate knowledge of the powers of the Prime Minister and the presidentialisation debate. Sustained, well-structured analysis and evaluation using specific, named evidence on both sides, reaching a fully substantiated overall judgement. | Level 525-30 marks |
| Accurate, mostly detailed knowledge. Good analysis and evaluation with named evidence on both sides, reaching a supported judgement, though development may be slightly uneven across the three paragraphs. | Level 419-24 marks |
| Generally accurate knowledge with some detail. Some analysis and an attempt at a two-sided argument, but at least one paragraph is one-sided or relies on generic rather than named evidence, capping the level. | Level 313-18 marks |
| Limited, mostly accurate knowledge. The answer is largely descriptive rather than analytical, with little genuine counter-argument or judgement in any paragraph. | Level 27-12 marks |
| Basic, undeveloped knowledge with little relevant, accurate detail; no clear argument structure or judgement. | Level 11-6 marks |
| No creditable content. | 0 |
| media coverage increasingly focuses on the Prime Minister personally rather than the government or Cabinet collectively, reinforced by the introduction of televised leaders' debates at the 2010 general election; the Prime Minister's Office and special advisers have grown in size and influence, sometimes described as 'sofa government' bypassing full Cabinet discussion, criticised by the 2004 Butler Review; the PM personally represents the UK at high-profile international summits, concentrating foreign policy visibility in one individual. | |
| unlike a US president, a UK Prime Minister has no fixed term or separate electoral mandate, sits in and depends on the confidence of the legislature, and can be removed mid-term by their own party without a general election, as has happened repeatedly in recent decades; the PM cannot govern without a functioning Cabinet and Commons majority, and collective responsibility means Cabinet colleagues can force a change of policy or resign in protest, as Robin Cook did in 2003 over the Iraq War; there is no separation of powers protecting the PM from the legislature in the way the US Constitution separates the presidency from Congress. | |
Question 8 - Prime Minister and Executive
8 marks
Explain TWO prerogative powers exercised by the Prime Minister.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [8 marks]| Question 8[8 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies patronage as a prerogative power. | 2 |
| develops, e.g. the power to appoint and dismiss ministers, shaping loyalty within Cabinet. | 2 |
| identifies a second prerogative power, e.g. recommending the dissolution of Parliament or making senior public appointments. | 2 |
| develops, e.g. explains that the power to recommend dissolution was restored by the Dissolution and Calling of Parliament Act 2022 after the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 was repealed. | 2 |
Method recap - The Structure, Composition and Functions of Parliament
- Learn the numbers and composition facts precisely (650 MPs, up to 92 hereditary peers, 26 bishops, life peers) since factual recall questions on Parliament's structure are common.
- Learn the difference between a frontbencher (minister or shadow minister) and a backbencher, and what the 'payroll vote' means for party discipline.
- Learn Parliament's core functions (legislation, scrutiny, representation, deliberation, recruitment of government, legitimation) with one example of each, so you are not left describing only law-making.
- For a question comparing the Commons and the Lords, or weighing one function against another, plan three genuinely two-sided paragraphs, each with a point and a linked counterpoint.
Question 9 - The Structure, Composition and Functions of Parliament
30 marks
'The unelected composition of the House of Lords means it cannot be considered a legitimate part of the UK Parliament.' Evaluate this statement.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [30 marks]| Question 9[30 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Excellent, detailed and accurate knowledge of the Lords' composition and legitimacy debate. Sustained, well-structured analysis and evaluation using specific, named evidence on both sides, reaching a fully substantiated overall judgement. | Level 525-30 marks |
| Accurate, mostly detailed knowledge. Good analysis and evaluation with named evidence on both sides, reaching a supported judgement, though development may be slightly uneven across the three paragraphs. | Level 419-24 marks |
| Generally accurate knowledge with some detail. Some analysis and an attempt at a two-sided argument, but at least one paragraph is one-sided or relies on generic rather than named evidence, capping the level. | Level 313-18 marks |
| Limited, mostly accurate knowledge. The answer is largely descriptive rather than analytical, with little genuine counter-argument or judgement in any paragraph. | Level 27-12 marks |
| Basic, undeveloped knowledge with little relevant, accurate detail; no clear argument structure or judgement. | Level 11-6 marks |
| No creditable content. | 0 |
| members are appointed, not elected, so lack a direct democratic mandate, unlike the 650 elected MPs in the Commons; life peerages last for life, so members face no re-election accountability; the continued presence of up to 92 hereditary peers, sitting by birth rather than merit or election, is hard to defend as legitimate in a modern democracy. | |
| legitimacy can rest on function and expertise rather than election alone, since many peers bring senior professional experience that a wholly elected chamber might lack; the Lords accepts the primacy of the elected Commons in practice, via the Salisbury Convention and the Parliament Acts 1911/1949, so it revises and delays rather than overruling elected decisions; the Appointments Commission and House of Lords Reform Act 2014 (allowing retirement and expulsion) have tried to improve standards without removing the expertise-based model. | |
Question 8 - The Structure, Composition and Functions of Parliament
8 marks
Explain TWO functions of the UK Parliament, other than making legislation.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [8 marks]| Question 8[8 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies scrutiny of the executive as a function. | 2 |
| develops with an example, e.g. Prime Minister's Questions or departmental select committees questioning ministers. | 2 |
| identifies representation as a function. | 2 |
| develops with an example, e.g. constituency casework, or debates raised by MPs reflecting a public concern. | 2 |