Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
Politics
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?
A Level Politics · Topic guide

US Presidency

The presidency is the single executive of the federal government, established by Article II of the Constitution.

A LevelUS politics and comparative politicsEdexcelAQAWJECCCEA

Before you start

Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:

Method

  1. Split presidential power into formal, constitutional powers under Article II (commander-in-chief, appointments with Senate consent, treaty-making with Senate ratification, veto, pardon) and informal powers that have grown through practice (executive orders, executive agreements, signing statements, going public).
  2. Learn the difference between an executive order (a directive managing the executive branch, which can be challenged in court and reversed by a successor) and an executive agreement (an international agreement that does not require Senate ratification, unlike a treaty).
  3. Learn what the cabinet is and is not: it is nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, but it has no constitutional role, meets relatively rarely as a body, and its influence is frequently exceeded by the president's own White House staff.
  4. Learn the specific limits Congress places on the presidency (confirmation of nominees, the power of the purse, oversight hearings, veto override by two-thirds of both chambers, impeachment) separately from the limits the courts impose (judicial review of executive orders and actions, e.g. Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co v Sawyer, 1952, which limited a president's emergency powers).
  5. For an 'imperial presidency' style question, weigh evidence of unchecked presidential growth (expanding use of executive orders, executive agreements bypassing the Senate, war powers exercised without a formal declaration of war) against evidence of real constraint (courts striking down executive actions, Congress withholding funding or confirmation, divided government blocking the president's agenda).
  6. Always specify whether a power is being exercised unilaterally (needs no other branch's agreement, e.g. an executive order) or jointly (needs another branch, e.g. a treaty needing Senate ratification), since this distinction is central to most presidential power questions.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeTreating an executive order as a law the president can make on any subject.

    InsteadAn executive order needs a source of authority in the Constitution or in a statute. If it goes beyond that, or contradicts what Congress has legislated, a court can strike it down, and Congress can legislate against it, subject to the president's veto.

  • MistakeSaying the president can veto individual items in a bill while signing the rest.

    InsteadThe president must sign or veto a bill as a whole. In Clinton v City of New York (1998) the Supreme Court held the Line Item Veto Act 1996 unconstitutional, so a president cannot strike out single items.

  • MistakeDescribing the US cabinet like the UK cabinet, with ministers who sit in the legislature and share collective responsibility.

    InsteadUS cabinet secretaries are chosen by the president, confirmed by the Senate and serve at the president's pleasure. The Constitution bars anyone holding office under the United States from also sitting in Congress, and there is no collective responsibility.

  • MistakeBelieving the pardon power lets a president end any prosecution or stop an impeachment.

    InsteadArticle II gives the pardon power for offences against the United States, except in cases of impeachment. It does not reach state crimes, which are a matter for state authorities.

Worked examples

Example 1

Assess the extent to which informal powers, rather than the formal powers set out in Article II, are now the main source of presidential influence.

  1. Define both terms precisely: formal powers are those written into Article II (veto, commander-in-chief, treaty-making, appointments, pardon); informal powers are practices that have grown up around the office (executive orders, executive agreements, signing statements, going public/the bully pulpit).
  2. Build the case for informal powers being dominant: executive orders let a president act unilaterally without needing Congress at all, and their use has grown as legislative gridlock has made passing new laws harder; executive agreements let presidents make binding international commitments without the two-thirds Senate hurdle a treaty requires.
  3. Build the case for formal powers remaining central: the veto (and the mere threat of one) still shapes what Congress is willing to pass in the first place, and the Senate's power to reject nominations or refuse to ratify a treaty is a formal check that no informal power can bypass.
  4. Add a qualifying point: informal powers such as executive orders are themselves constrained by the formal structure, since courts can strike them down as unconstitutional and a successor president can simply revoke them, so they are a weaker and more reversible form of power than a formal, especially a ratified, action.
  5. Reach a conclusion: informal powers have grown as a practical response to the difficulty of achieving formal, cross-branch agreement, but they are more fragile and reversible than formal powers, so their prominence reflects legislative gridlock as much as it reflects presidential strength.

Example 2

Suppose a president orders a sustained air campaign against another state without a declaration of war and without any statute authorising force. Explain which constitutional and statutory limits apply, and assess how effectively they constrain the president.

  1. Locate the president's claim: Article II makes the president commander-in-chief of the armed forces, and presidents have argued that this covers directing military operations without prior approval.
  2. Locate Congress's claim: Article I, Section 8 gives Congress the power to declare war and to raise and fund the armed forces, so the constitutional text divides war powers between the branches.
  3. Add the statutory limit: the War Powers Resolution 1973, passed over President Nixon's veto, requires the president to report to Congress within 48 hours of committing forces and to end the action within 60 days (with a further 30 to withdraw) unless Congress authorises it.
  4. Test the statute: presidents have disputed its constitutionality, and a resolution by Congress to end the action can be vetoed, so overriding needs two-thirds of both chambers. A limit that needs a supermajority is a weak one.
  5. Test Congress's other lever: the power of the purse is real, but refusing money for forces already in the field is politically costly, so it is rarely used to stop an operation.
  6. Test the courts: judges have generally declined to decide disputes over war powers, so judicial review, which can limit a president on domestic matters, is a weak check here.
  7. Answer: the limits exist but depend on Congress acting by supermajority or by cutting funds, so a president has more room to use force abroad than to make domestic policy alone.

Example 3

In a fictional US presidency, a president proposes a grant scheme that is popular with the public. For this exercise, the scheme may begin only after Congress approves it; all other conditions for starting are satisfied, and no alternative authority to begin is supplied. Congress has not approved it, and enough legislators still withhold support to prevent approval. The president plans a public speech urging voters to contact their representatives and also offers legislators a compromise on the scheme's safeguards. An adviser claims that popularity already permits the president to start the scheme, and that approval following these efforts would prove the speech caused it. Assess both claims, distinguishing formal approval from informal persuasion.

  1. Identify the formal condition before judging presidential influence. The supplied rule makes congressional approval necessary for starting this scheme. All other starting conditions are satisfied, but approval is still absent, so this particular barrier remains decisive.
  2. Test the claim about popularity against that condition. Public support concerns what voters favour; formal approval concerns a decision by Congress. The premises explicitly combine popularity with insufficient legislative support, so public support cannot be treated as evidence that the required decision has been secured.
  3. Classify the speech by its mechanism. Urging voters to contact representatives uses the president's public profile to build pressure, the informal power of going public. It seeks to influence how legislators decide; delivering the speech does not itself constitute congressional approval.
  4. Explain how persuasion could matter without guaranteeing success. Legislators might respond to public pressure, or the offered safeguards might make the scheme acceptable to them. Either route could help secure the missing support, but neither response is supplied as a fact. If support remains insufficient, the formal condition continues to block the scheme, however popular it is.
  5. Test the causal claim separately from the approval rule. If approval later follows both the speech and the compromise, that sequence is compatible with legislators responding to the speech, to the safeguards, or to both. The outcome alone cannot identify which explanation caused their decision. Evidence distinguishing their reasons would be needed to attribute success to the speech.
  6. Answer: the president cannot begin the scheme on the supplied facts because congressional approval is missing. Informal persuasion may help obtain that approval, which makes formal and informal power potentially complementary, but popularity supplies no substitute for it. Even later approval would establish that the formal barrier had been cleared, not by itself that the speech caused the change.

Practice questions

Q1[1 mark]Which article of the Constitution establishes the presidency?Show answer

Answer: Article II.

Got it right?
Q2[1 mark]Name one formal power of the president that requires the Senate's agreement to complete.Show answer

Answer: Appointing federal officials or judges (needs Senate confirmation), or negotiating a treaty (needs two-thirds Senate ratification).

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q3[2 marks]What is an executive order?Show answer

Answer: A directive issued by the president that manages operations of the federal government, without needing congressional approval, though it can be challenged in court or reversed by a later president.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q4[2 marks]How does an executive agreement differ from a treaty?Show answer

Answer: An executive agreement is a deal with a foreign government that does not require Senate ratification, unlike a treaty, which needs approval by two-thirds of the Senate.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q5[1 mark]Is the cabinet set out in the Constitution?Show answer

Answer: No, the cabinet is a creation of political practice, not the Constitution, and has an advisory role only.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q6[1 mark]Name one Supreme Court case in which the Court limited a president's use of emergency power.Show answer

Answer: Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co v Sawyer (1952), which ruled that President Truman could not seize steel mills without congressional authorisation.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.
Q7[2 marks]What is the 'bully pulpit'?Show answer

Answer: The president's use of their high public profile to build public pressure and support for their policy agenda.

Got it right?
Your answerWork it out on paper, then show the answer and mark yourself.

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a A Level Politics exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • Back each power or limit with a named example, such as a court case, a bill or an order, rather than the general power alone.
  • When you weigh a limit, say whether Congress is controlled by the president's party, since the same check can be strong under divided government and weak under united government.
  • In a question about how things are 'now', use evidence from more than one presidency so that your judgement does not rest on one president's style.
Q1[12 marks]Explain and analyse three ways in which Congress or the courts can limit presidential power.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 12 available

Got it right?
Q2[25 marks]Assess the extent to which informal powers, rather than the formal powers set out in Article II, are now the main source of presidential influence.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 25 available

Got it right?

See real A Level Politics past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

This topic in real past papers

We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the US Presidency worksheet pack - 4 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This topic is chapter 16 of A Level Politics Essentials 2, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 13 of A Level Politics Topic Workbook 3 and chapter 15 of A Level Politics 10-Minute Tests 2, free printable practice books.

Other versions of this worksheet:

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on US Presidency, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.