Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1066-87: Establishing Control: the Earls, the Marcher Earldoms and Castles
After Hastings William still had to make himself master of a kingdom of which he held little. In late 1066 English leaders including Edgar the Aethling and Archbishop Ealdred submitted to him at Berkhamsted, and William was crowned in Westminster Abbey on Christmas Day. At first he kept some English earls, such as Edwin, Morcar and Waltheof, in place, and when he visited Normandy in 1067 he left regents, including his half-brother Odo and William FitzOsbern, to govern. He rewarded his Norman followers with land and offices, and on the Welsh border he created powerful earldoms at Hereford, Shrewsbury and Chester. These Marcher earls could raise their own armies, hold their own courts and win land from the Welsh. Throughout England the Normans built castles, at first mostly timber motte-and-bailey castles that could be raised quickly beside towns and on key routes, and later great stone buildings such as the White Tower in London. Castles gave garrisons a secure base, protected the Normans and showed the conquered English who now ruled.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn the first steps in order: the submission at Berkhamsted, the coronation on Christmas Day 1066, the retention of some English earls, and the regents and hostages of 1067.
- Learn the reward system: Norman followers were given land and offices, and on the Welsh border Hereford, Shrewsbury and Chester were given to trusted lords with wide powers. Be able to say why the border needed such earls.
- Learn how castles worked: motte and bailey, timber then stone, palisade and ditch, keep, garrison and castle-guard, and where castles were sited (towns, routes, the border).
- Learn the reasons for castle-building as separate points: control of the English, defence against rebels and invaders, a base for garrisons and government, and a display of power.
- For 'describe two features' questions, use two different features with one detail each, such as a purpose, a part of the structure or a place where castles were built.
- For 'explain why' and 'how far do you agree' questions, set William's methods (castles, rewards, earls, regents) side by side, and in 16 marks say which one mattered most and why the others depended on it.
Common mistakes
MistakeWriting that all Norman castles were great stone keeps from the start.
InsteadThe first castles were mostly timber and earth, built quickly. Stone castles, such as the White Tower in London, came later and were fewer, so say which kind you mean.
MistakeSaying William removed every English earl as soon as he was crowned.
InsteadEarly on he kept some English earls in place, because he had too few Normans to replace everyone and because dismissals could provoke revolt. Say that the policy changed after the first revolts.
MistakeGiving 'to frighten the English' as the only reason for building castles.
InsteadCastles also defended the Normans against rebels and invaders, housed garrisons and served as bases for government. Name at least one purpose beside intimidation.
Worked examples
Example 1
Explain why motte-and-bailey castles helped William to control the areas around them. You may use the following in your answer: the speed of building, and the height of the motte. You must also use information of your own.
- Plan three reasons: speed of building, the defensive advantage of the motte, and the bailey's role as a base. The first two use the stimulus, the third is your own.
- Explain the speed: a motte and bailey was made of earth and timber, so a garrison could raise one in days or weeks. William could therefore plant a castle in a new area almost as soon as he arrived, before local resistance could organise.
- Explain the height of the motte: the tower on top gave a view over the surrounding land and was hard for attackers to reach, so a small garrison could hold out and watch for rebels.
- Add your own point: the bailey, the enclosed courtyard, held the garrison, horses and stores, so soldiers could ride out from the castle to put down trouble across the area.
- Link the reasons: castles that were quick to build, strong on their mound and able to house a garrison let a small number of Normans dominate a large and hostile population.
Example 2
'The Marcher earldoms were the most successful part of William's system of control.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the powers of the border earls, and the failure to conquer all of Wales. You must also use information of your own.
- State your line: the earldoms worked well on the border, but 'most successful' is too strong because they gave great power to men who could not always be trusted.
- Build the case for the statement: border earls could raise armies and hold their own courts, so William could defend a distant frontier without keeping a royal army there. They also won Welsh land at their own expense.
- Add a further point for the statement: the border earls held the frontier without a royal army, which freed William to deal with revolts elsewhere, and their wealth and followers made them a cheap garrison for the frontier.
- Build the case against: Wales was not conquered in William's reign, and powerful earls could become a danger. The son of one of the first border earls joined the Revolt of the Earls in 1075.
- Weigh the two sides and judge: the earldoms did what William needed on the frontier, but the same powers that made them effective made them risky, so they were a success in one way and a gamble in another, and not the most successful part of his system.
Practice questions
Q1[3 marks]On what day, where and by whom was William crowned king of England?Show answer
Answer: On Christmas Day 1066, in Westminster Abbey, by Ealdred, archbishop of York.
Q2[2 marks]What were the motte and the bailey of a castle?Show answer
Answer: The motte was a large mound of earth with a tower on top; the bailey was the enclosed courtyard beside it.
Q3[2 marks]What was a castellan?Show answer
Answer: The man appointed to hold and command a castle on behalf of the king or a lord.
Q4[2 marks]Why did William appoint regents in 1067?Show answer
Answer: He returned to Normandy that year, so he left trusted men, including Odo and William FitzOsbern, to keep order and govern England in his absence.
Q5[2 marks]What were the Marches?Show answer
Answer: The border region between England and Wales.
Q6[2 marks]Which three earldoms did William create on the Welsh border?Show answer
Answer: Hereford, Shrewsbury and Chester.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE History exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Name the type and the place when you describe a castle: 'a timber motte and bailey beside a town' is more precise than 'a castle'.
- When asked why William used a method, give the problem it solved: too few Normans, a hostile population, or a distant border.
- In a 16-mark answer comparing William's methods, show how they linked, rather than listing them one after another. Linking is part of the judgement.
Q1[4 marks]Describe two features of William's handling of the English leaders in 1066-67.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q2[12 marks]Explain why William's castle-building caused resentment among the English. You may use the following in your answer: the destruction of houses to make room for castles, and the presence of Norman garrisons. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
Q3[16 marks]'William's control of England by 1071 rested more on castles than on any other measure.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the building of castles in towns, and the rewards given to Norman followers. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 16 available
See real GCSE History past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1066-87: Establishing Control: the Earls, the Marcher Earldoms and Castles worksheet pack - 16 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 1 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 8 and chapter 7 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 4, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: