Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu
History
Need a new topic?
Missing a topic, found a bug, or want something added?
GCSE History · Topic guide

Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1069-87: The Harrying of the North and Changes in Landownership

The Harrying of the North was William I's winter campaign of 1069-70 against Yorkshire and the lands beyond, launched after the northern rising of 1069 in which rebels, Edgar the Aethling and a Danish fleet sent by Sweyn Estrithson threatened Norman rule and Robert de Comines had been killed at Durham. Having bought off the Danes, William kept Christmas 1069 at York and sent his troops to destroy crops, livestock and villages so that the region could no longer feed rebel armies; he then marched to Chester in early 1070. Chroniclers such as Orderic Vitalis and Symeon of Durham describe famine and flight, and Domesday Book (1086) still records many Yorkshire manors as 'waste', though historians debate how much of that was caused by the Harrying. Alongside it, English landholding was transformed: land was forfeited from men who fought at Hastings or rebelled, and granted to Normans as tenants-in-chief, so that by 1086 very few English lords held land directly from the king.

Grades 4-7 (GCSE)Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, c1060-88AQAOCRWJECEduqasCCEAEdexcel

Before you start

Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:

Method

  1. Learn the sequence that led to the Harrying: the northern rising of 1069, the death of Robert de Comines at Durham, the arrival of the Danish fleet and Edgar the Aethling, then William's march north, the winter devastation and his arrival at Chester in early 1070.
  2. Learn the key terms with exact meanings: Harrying, waste (a Domesday entry for a manor with little or no recorded value), forfeiture (confiscating land from rebels), fief, tenant-in-chief and thegn.
  3. Treat the Harrying's scale as a matter of evidence. Chroniclers wrote decades later, often with a moral purpose, and Domesday 'waste' may have more than one cause, so write 'chroniclers claim' or 'Domesday suggests', never a confident death toll.
  4. For 'describe two features' questions, give two different features and add a name, place or date to each. For landownership, features include forfeiture, grants to Normans, and the small number of English tenants-in-chief by 1086.
  5. For 'explain why' questions, build each paragraph as point, evidence, link back to the question. Use the two stimulus points, then add a third factor of your own such as castles, the Danish threat or the need to reward followers.
  6. For 16-mark questions, set evidence for the statement against evidence for another cause or limit, then commit to a judgement and say what made it stronger than the alternative.

Common mistakes

  • MistakePresenting the Harrying as a single battle or a short raid, rather than a winter campaign of devastation across a wide area.

    InsteadDescribe it as a campaign of destruction in the winter of 1069-70, aimed at crops, livestock and villages, from Yorkshire towards Durham, followed by William's march to Chester.

  • MistakeStating an exact death toll as proven fact, because one chronicler claims a very large number.

    InsteadWrite 'a chronicler claimed' or 'sources describe famine'. Accounts of the Harrying were written long afterwards, often to condemn William, and historians disagree about how many died.

  • MistakeWriting that Domesday Book was compiled to record the damage done by the Harrying.

    InsteadDomesday was a survey of landholding and resources ordered in 1085-86, mainly for royal finance and control. It recorded 'waste' manors incidentally, which is why historians argue over what caused each one.

  • MistakeTreating the Harrying (1069-70) as part of the Revolt of the Earls of 1075, or as the same event as the earlier revolts of 1068-71.

    InsteadKeep the order straight: the Harrying was William's response to the rising of 1069, part of the unrest of 1068-71, while the Revolt of the Earls was a separate plot in 1075.

Worked examples

Example 1

Explain why Norman control of the North was stronger by 1087 than it had been in 1068. You may use the following in your answer: the castles at York and Durham, and grants of land to Norman lords. You must also use information of your own.

  1. Plan three paragraphs: the stimulus point on castles, the stimulus point on land grants, and an own-knowledge point on the Harrying. Each should explain a way Norman power became harder to challenge.
  2. Castles: William built castles at York in 1068 and 1069 and the garrisons held the city, and a castle at Durham from 1072 gave the Normans a base in the far north. Explain that a permanent garrison could respond to a rising quickly, unlike an army that had to be gathered.
  3. Land grants: northern estates were given to Norman lords, for example Alan Rufus at Richmond and Ilbert de Lacy at Pontefract, who built their own castles. Explain that these lords owed the king military service and had a personal reason to defend what they held.
  4. Own knowledge: the Harrying destroyed crops, livestock and villages in the winter of 1069-70, so the region lacked the food and manpower to support a large rebel army. Chroniclers describe famine, and Domesday Book still records waste manors in Yorkshire in 1086.
  5. Link and conclude: in 1068-69 the North faced few Normans and was open to Danish help, whereas by 1087 castles, loyal lords and a weakened region worked together, which explains why no rising of the 1069 scale followed.

Example 2

'The Norman Conquest ended the power of the English nobility.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the fate of the great English earls, and the thegns who kept land as tenants of Normans. You must also use information of your own.

  1. Set out the plan: evidence that English noble power ended, evidence that some survived, then a comparison of power at the top with power in the localities.
  2. Agree: Harold, Gyrth and Leofwine died at Hastings, Edwin was killed in 1071 after his revolt, Morcar was imprisoned after Ely, and Waltheof was executed in 1076. By 1086 very few English lords held land directly from the king, so the highest rank of English power had gone.
  3. Disagree: many thegns kept some land by submitting and holding it as tenants of Norman lords, and some bought land back. English people continued to run village and hundred life, so English influence did not disappear in the localities.
  4. Weigh the two: the power that mattered in national politics, the great earldoms and the tenants-in-chief, was overwhelmingly transferred to Normans. What survived was lower-level and depended on Norman lords.
  5. Judgement: the statement is largely right about the nobility at the top, but 'ended' overstates it. English landholders lost their independent power and became dependants, while a smaller number kept status in the localities.

Practice questions

Q1[1 mark]Which Norman earl of Northumbria was killed at Durham in January 1069, helping to spark the northern rising?Show answer

Answer: Robert de Comines (also spelt Cumin).

Got it right?
Q2[1 mark]Which earl of Mercia rose against William in 1068, with his brother Morcar, and was killed in 1071?Show answer

Answer: Edwin.

Got it right?
Q3[1 mark]Which Norman lord was granted the lands around Pontefract in Yorkshire?Show answer

Answer: Ilbert de Lacy.

Got it right?
Q4[1 mark]Which Danish king sent a fleet to support the northern rebels in 1069?Show answer

Answer: Sweyn (Swein) Estrithson.

Got it right?
Q5[1 mark]At which city did sources say William kept Christmas in 1069, during the campaign against the northern rebels?Show answer

Answer: York.

Got it right?
Q6[1 mark]Which chronicler, a monk at Saint-Evroul in Normandy writing decades later, condemned the Harrying and described famine in the North?Show answer

Answer: Orderic Vitalis.

Got it right?

Exam-style questions

Written in the style of a GCSE History exam paper, with a full mark scheme.

Exam tips

  • In an 'explain why' answer, begin each paragraph with the reason in your own words, then give the evidence, then say how it answers the question. Do not simply narrate the 1069-70 events.
  • Use a place or name in every paragraph, such as York, Durham, Chester or Richmond. A specific detail turns a general claim into evidence.
  • For a 16-mark question, plan a short counter-argument first. Write down what else could explain the outcome before you start, so your judgement compares causes.
Q1[4 marks]Describe two features of the Danish threat to Norman rule in the North in 1069-70.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 4 available

Got it right?
Q2[12 marks]Explain why Norman tenants-in-chief became the most powerful group in England by 1087. You may use the following in your answer: grants of forfeited land, and the duty of knight service. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 12 available

Got it right?
Q3[16 marks]'The Harrying of the North achieved what William intended.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the departure of the Danes in 1070, and the waste manors recorded in Domesday Book. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme

Tick each line you got.

Nothing ticked yet - 16 available

Got it right?

See real GCSE History past-paper questions, with official mark schemes 

Free printable worksheet

Want more practice on paper? Download the Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1069-87: The Harrying of the North and Changes in Landownership worksheet pack - 15 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.

This worksheet is chapter 3 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 8 and chapter 9 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 4, free printable practice books.

Keep going

Not quite what you needed?

Tell us what is missing on Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1069-87: The Harrying of the North and Changes in Landownership, or which topic to write up next.

Build a full practice pack.