Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1075: The Revolt of the Earls
The Revolt of the Earls (1075) was the last major plot against William I by his own earls. At the wedding feast of Ralph de Gael, earl of East Anglia, and Emma, sister of Roger de Breteuil, earl of Hereford, the two men were joined by Waltheof, the English earl of Northumbria, in a plan to remove William from the throne; William had not given permission for the marriage. Orderic Vitalis, writing decades later, reports the complaints voiced against William, though his speeches are literary reconstruction. The plot failed quickly while William was in Normandy: Waltheof confessed to Archbishop Lanfranc, who led the government in England, Roger was blocked at the Severn by Bishop Wulfstan and Urse d'Abetot, and Ralph was defeated near Cambridge before Norwich castle surrendered on terms. A Danish fleet arrived too late and plundered York. Roger was imprisoned, Ralph went into exile, and Waltheof was executed at Winchester in 1076.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn the three rebel earls and what each held: Ralph de Gael (East Anglia), Roger de Breteuil (Hereford) and Waltheof (Northumbria), and the family link between Ralph and Roger through Emma.
- Learn the order of events: the wedding feast and plot, Waltheof's confession to Lanfranc, Roger blocked at the Severn, Ralph defeated and Norwich surrendering, the Danish fleet arriving late, then the punishments and Waltheof's execution in 1076.
- Learn the effects: rebels punished by imprisonment, exile and execution, forfeited lands passing to loyal men, and no new large regional earldoms given to English lords afterwards.
- Treat motives with care. Sources report grievances against William, but the earls' real reasons are inferred, so write 'sources suggest' or 'historians debate' rather than stating one cause as fact.
- For 'explain why' questions, give the reason, support it with a name, place or action, and say how it helps answer the question. For 'describe two features', give two separate points, each with a supporting detail.
- For 16-mark questions, compare the factor in the statement with at least one other, such as who the rebels were, how quickly it was defeated and what followed, and finish with a judgement that explains why one mattered more.
Common mistakes
MistakeDescribing the 1075 revolt as a continuation of the English resistance of 1068-71.
InsteadSeparate them. The 1068-71 revolts were English-led risings, often with popular support. In 1075 the plot was made by earls of Norman and Breton background with one English earl, and it won little support from ordinary people.
MistakeWriting that the Danish fleet fought alongside the rebels in 1075.
InsteadSay that the Danish fleet reached England after the rebels had already been beaten. It plundered York and left without helping the earls, which is why it matters as a missed opportunity.
MistakeDating the revolt to 1076 because that is the year of the execution that followed it.
InsteadDate the plot and the fighting to 1075 and treat the executions and punishments of 1075-76 as its aftermath. Keeping the sequence clear helps cause-and-consequence answers.
MistakeTreating Waltheof as the organiser of the plot because he is the earl who was executed.
InsteadRalph de Gael and Roger de Breteuil were the earls at the centre of the plot, linked by Ralph's marriage to Roger's sister. Waltheof joined them, then confessed, and his execution came a year later.
Worked examples
Example 1
Explain why the Revolt of the Earls left William's authority stronger rather than weaker. You may use the following in your answer: the crushing of the rebels while William was in Normandy, and the forfeiture of the rebels' lands. You must also use information of your own.
- Plan three paragraphs: the speed of the defeat, the forfeitures, and an own-knowledge point on the lasting effect on earldoms.
- Speed of defeat: the revolt was crushed in the king's absence by Lanfranc, bishops, sheriffs and local forces. Explain that this showed the rebels could not draw on wider loyalty, and that William's government functioned without him.
- Forfeiture: Roger de Breteuil and Ralph de Gael lost their lands, and the estates were available to reward men who had stayed loyal. Explain that this tied more lords to William through their own interests.
- Own knowledge: after 1075 the earldoms of East Anglia and Hereford were left unfilled, and Waltheof's execution in 1076 removed the last English earl of any weight. Explain that power in the shires passed to sheriffs and castles which depended on the king.
- Conclude by linking the points: the revolt came from inside his circle, but its quick failure, the punishments and the weakening of the earls left the crown with fewer rivals than before.
Example 2
'The Revolt of the Earls was a more dangerous threat to William than the revolts of 1068-71.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the backgrounds of the rebel leaders, and the speed of the defeat. You must also use information of your own.
- Plan the comparison: the scale and support of each threat, who the rebels were, and how long each lasted. Decide the judgement before writing.
- Case for 1075 being more dangerous: two of the three rebel earls came from Norman and Breton families and were men William had rewarded, so the plot came from inside his circle, and it involved powerful regional bases.
- Case against: the 1075 plot was over within months, had little popular backing and was crushed while William was away. The revolts of 1068-71 went on for years, spread across the country and called in Edgar the Aethling and a Danish fleet, and they led to the Harrying.
- Weigh the two: the 1068-71 revolts drew on wide English discontent and threatened Norman control of whole regions. The 1075 plot threatened through betrayal, but it lacked the support to turn betrayal into a rising.
- Judgement: the statement is not convincing. The 1075 revolt was more alarming in who joined it, but the 1068-71 revolts were the greater threat to William's rule because of their scale, duration and outside help.
Practice questions
Q1[2 marks]Which two people married at the feast where the plot was agreed in 1075?Show answer
Answer: Ralph de Gael, earl of East Anglia, and Emma, sister of Roger de Breteuil.
Q2[1 mark]Whose son was Roger de Breteuil, whom William had made earl of Hereford?Show answer
Answer: William fitzOsbern, the first Norman earl of Hereford.
Q3[1 mark]In which year was Waltheof executed?Show answer
Answer: 1076.
Q4[1 mark]What happened to Roger de Breteuil after the revolt?Show answer
Answer: He was imprisoned for life and lost his lands.
Q5[1 mark]Which English earl confessed the plot to Lanfranc and then went to William in Normandy?Show answer
Answer: Waltheof.
Q6[1 mark]In which part of William's lands was the king when the plot was uncovered in 1075?Show answer
Answer: Normandy.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE History exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Attach a named person and a place to every action you describe, such as which earl did what and where. A named person and place makes a point specific enough to work as evidence.
- In a 'how far do you agree' answer, state your judgement in the first paragraph, then use each later paragraph to test it against another factor.
- When a source is later or hostile, say so in a short clause and still use it. 'Orderic Vitalis reports...' gives you the content and shows you know its limits.
Q1[4 marks]Describe two features of the defeat of the Revolt of the Earls.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q2[12 marks]Explain why the Revolt of the Earls collapsed so quickly. You may use the following in your answer: the speed of the royal response, and the rebels' lack of co-ordination. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
Q3[16 marks]'The Revolt of the Earls was caused by personal grievances rather than opposition to Norman rule.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the marriage alliance between the earls' families, and Waltheof's position. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 16 available
See real GCSE History past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1075: The Revolt of the Earls worksheet pack - 15 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 4 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 8 and chapter 10 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 4, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: