Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1066-88: The Feudal System and the Church
Under William I, land was organised through a feudal hierarchy. In theory the king held all land. Tenants-in-chief, great lay lords and also bishops and abbots, held fiefs directly from him in return for service, above all providing a set quota of knights; they granted part of their land to knights and other sub-tenants, and at the base were peasants such as villeins, who owed their lord labour service and dues. A tenant did homage and swore fealty to his lord, and could lose his land by forfeiture if he rebelled. In 1086 William summoned landholders to Salisbury to swear loyalty to him above their own lords. The Church was brought under tighter royal control: Stigand, who held Canterbury and Winchester together, was removed in 1070 and replaced by Lanfranc, Normans replaced most English bishops and abbots, bishoprics were moved to towns, church courts were separated from shire courts, and reforming councils tackled simony and clerical marriage. Historians debate how far everyday English society and the economy changed, since village life and farming largely continued.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn the feudal hierarchy from the top: the king, tenants-in-chief (lay lords, bishops and abbots), knights and other sub-tenants, then peasants such as villeins. Be able to say what each level gave and received.
- Learn the key terms with exact meanings: fief, homage (the kneeling ceremony), fealty (the oath of loyalty), knight service, labour service, relief, forfeiture and the Salisbury oath of 1086.
- Learn the Church story: Stigand's removal and Lanfranc's appointment in 1070, the replacement of English churchmen, the move of bishoprics to towns, the separate church courts, and William's control of the link with the pope.
- For 'describe' questions, give two separate features and add one supporting detail to each, such as a name, a date or an example. A general sentence about 'feudalism' needs a specific example attached.
- For 'explain why' questions, give a reason, support it with evidence, and link it back to what William wanted: security, control of land, money or loyal churchmen. Use the stimulus points and add a third factor of your own.
- For 16-mark questions on change and continuity, set what changed against what stayed the same, in the same sentence where you can, then judge which was the more important.
Common mistakes
MistakeSaying that feudalism and lordship were wholly new in 1066, with nothing like them in Anglo-Saxon England.
InsteadSay that Anglo-Saxon England already had lordship and thegns who owed service to a lord or the king. What the Normans added was a formal pyramid of fiefs, tenants-in-chief and a fixed quota of knights.
MistakeUsing 'homage' and 'fealty' as if they meant the same thing.
InsteadKeep them apart: homage was the ceremony in which a tenant knelt and became his lord's man, while fealty was the oath to be faithful to him. Both were part of the bond between lord and tenant.
MistakeWriting that the Church stood outside the feudal system because bishops and abbots were churchmen rather than warriors.
InsteadState that bishops and abbots held land as tenants-in-chief, so their estates owed the king service like those of lay lords. Many provided knights, which tied the Church to the king's government.
MistakeAssuming that ordinary villagers' lives were completely transformed because a Norman lord replaced an English one.
InsteadDistinguish levels. At the top, landholders and churchmen changed. In the village, farming in open fields, the English language and many local customs continued, though peasants now owed dues to a new lord.
Worked examples
Example 1
Explain why Stigand was removed as archbishop of Canterbury in 1070. You may use the following in your answer: his holding of two offices at once, and the pope's doubts about his position. You must also use information of your own.
- Plan three paragraphs: the two stimulus points and one own-knowledge point about what William and the reformers wanted in the English Church.
- Two offices: Stigand held the archbishopric of Canterbury and the bishopric of Winchester together. Explain that holding two major posts was condemned by Church reformers, so his position was open to attack.
- Papal doubts: the papacy did not accept the way Stigand had come to office, and Norman sources claim that the pope had blessed William's invasion in 1066. Explain that removing him allowed William to claim he was acting for reform and to keep the pope's goodwill.
- Own knowledge: William wanted a trusted man at the head of the English Church. Lanfranc, an Italian-born monk who had been prior of Bec and abbot of Caen, replaced Stigand, and under him a council reorganised the Church and Normans replaced English bishops and abbots.
- Conclude by linking the points: Stigand's weaknesses gave William a religious reason to act, and the change served his political aim of controlling the Church through a loyal archbishop.
Example 2
'The English Church was more independent of the king in 1087 than in 1066.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the separation of church courts, and the king's control of appointments. You must also use information of your own.
- Set the plan: evidence for greater independence, evidence for stronger royal control, then a judgement on what kind of independence changed.
- For the statement: in the 1070s bishops were no longer expected to hear church cases in the shire court, and church courts judged them under church law. Reforming councils led by the archbishop set their own rules on matters such as simony and clerical marriage.
- Against the statement: William chose bishops and abbots, and they were mostly Normans loyal to him. According to Eadmer, writing later, no papal letter could be brought into England, and no tenant-in-chief could be excommunicated, without William's consent, and William refused Pope Gregory VII's demand that he swear fealty.
- Weigh the evidence: the Church gained independence in its own courts and discipline, but the king kept control of who ran it and how it dealt with Rome. Bishops and abbots also owed knight service as tenants-in-chief.
- Judgement: on balance the Church was not more independent. It was better organised and more distinct from the shire courts, but it was more closely tied to the king because he controlled the appointments and the link with Rome.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]What was a fief?Show answer
Answer: Land granted by a lord, or by the king, to a tenant in return for service, usually knight service.
Q2[2 marks]What was labour service?Show answer
Answer: Work on the lord's land, such as ploughing and harvesting, that a peasant owed to his lord as part of holding land.
Q3[1 mark]Who replaced Stigand as archbishop of Canterbury in 1070?Show answer
Answer: Lanfranc.
Q4[1 mark]Name one bishopric whose seat was moved to a larger town after the Conquest.Show answer
Answer: Any one of: Dorchester (moved to Lincoln), Selsey (moved to Chichester), Sherborne (moved to Old Sarum, later Salisbury), Lichfield (moved to Chester), or Elmham (moved to Thetford).
Q5[1 mark]Which pope sent legates to the councils of 1070 at which Stigand was deposed?Show answer
Answer: Alexander II.
Q6[1 mark]Of which Norman abbey at Caen was Lanfranc abbot before he became archbishop of Canterbury?Show answer
Answer: St Stephen's (the Abbaye-aux-Hommes).
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE History exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- When you describe a feudal relationship, name both sides and what each owed. 'The lord gave land and protection and the tenant gave service and loyalty' is more precise than 'they were connected'.
- In a question about Church change, name the person or event behind each change, such as Lanfranc or the papal legates who attended the council of 1070. A named agent shows you know who made the change happen.
- For change and continuity, use a sentence that holds both ('Lords changed but village farming continued') to show the balance, then explain which of the two mattered more.
Q1[4 marks]Describe two features of the church councils held in England in the 1070s.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q2[12 marks]Explain why the feudal system was important to the defence of England. You may use the following in your answer: knight service, and the castles held by Norman lords. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 12 available
Q3[16 marks]'The Normans changed the Church more than any other part of English life.' How far do you agree? Explain your answer. You may use the following in your answer: the new bishops and abbots, and the building of cathedrals. You must also use information of your own.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 16 available
See real GCSE History past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Anglo-Saxon and Norman England, 1066-88: The Feudal System and the Church worksheet pack - 15 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This worksheet is chapter 1 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 9 and chapter 11 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 4, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: