Attachment types: Ainsworth's Strange Situation and cultural variations in attachment
The Strange Situation is a controlled observational procedure, developed by Ainsworth, used to assess the quality of an infant's attachment to a caregiver by watching behaviour during separations, reunions and contact with a stranger, classifying infants as secure (Type B), insecure-avoidant (Type A) or insecure-resistant (Type C). The same procedure has been used across many countries to study cultural variations in these attachment types.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn the standardised structure of the Strange Situation: around eight short episodes involving the infant, caregiver and a stranger, with two separations and two reunions.
- Learn the categories of behaviour observers code: separation anxiety, stranger anxiety, secure-base/exploration behaviour and reunion behaviour.
- Learn the behavioural pattern that defines each of the three attachment types: secure (Type B), insecure-avoidant (Type A) and insecure-resistant (Type C).
- Practise applying the classification system to a described infant's behaviour, picking out specific evidence for each type.
- Learn Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg's meta-analytic method for studying cultural variations, and their finding that variation within a country can exceed variation between countries.
- Learn the evaluation points: inter-rater reliability, and validity concerns including the imposed etic critique of using the same tool across cultures.
Common mistakes
MistakeDescribing an insecure-avoidant infant as having no attachment.
InsteadAvoidant infants are attached; their attachment is insecure. They keep their distance, show little distress at separation and do not seek contact on reunion, but they are still classified as having an attachment relationship with that caregiver.
MistakeTreating a Strange Situation classification as a judgement of how good or bad a parent is.
InsteadThe procedure classifies the infant's behaviour towards one caregiver during a set of episodes, so it describes the quality of that relationship on that occasion. It cannot show why the pattern arose, and an infant can be classified differently with a different caregiver.
MistakeWriting that a cross-cultural meta-analysis of Strange Situation studies found no differences between countries.
InsteadIt found differences in the proportions of each type: secure attachment was the most common classification in every country studied, but the proportions of avoidant and resistant infants varied from country to country.
Worked examples
Example 1
In a Strange Situation observation, a 14-month-old infant called Priya stays close to her mother throughout and barely explores the toys, even when her mother is present. When her mother leaves the room, Priya becomes extremely distressed and cries loudly. When her mother returns, Priya rushes towards her but then arches away and resists being picked up, continuing to cry for several minutes afterwards. Classify Priya's attachment type, giving two pieces of supporting evidence from the description.
- Note that Priya shows very little exploration even with her mother present, unlike a securely attached infant who uses the caregiver as a secure base.
- Note that she shows intense distress when her mother leaves, greater than the moderate distress typical of secure attachment.
- Note that on reunion she seeks contact but simultaneously resists comfort, an ambivalent response rather than being easily soothed.
- Match this combination (little exploration, high separation distress, ambivalent reunion) to the insecure-resistant profile.
- State the final answer: Priya shows insecure-resistant (Type C) attachment, supported by her limited exploration and her ambivalent, resistant reunion behaviour.
Example 2
Two trained coders independently classify 15 infants from video recordings of Strange Situation sessions. Coder 1: B, B, C, A, B, C, B, B, A, B, B, B, C, A, B. Coder 2: B, B, B, A, B, C, B, B, A, B, C, B, C, A, B. Calculate the percentage agreement, comment on the reliability, and say what the pattern of disagreements suggests about how the classification is made.
- Compare infant by infant. The coders differ on infant 3 (C against B) and infant 11 (B against C). The other 13 infants are classified the same way.
- Agreement = 13 / 15 x 100 = 86.7% (1 d.p.).
- Interpret: this is above the 80% often used as a rule of thumb, so classification by trained observers is reasonably consistent. Inter-rater reliability counts as a strength of the procedure.
- Look at the pattern: in this set both disagreements are between secure and insecure-resistant, and none is between secure and avoidant. Secure and resistant infants both seek contact at reunion, so what separates them is how the infant responds to comfort, which takes judgement.
- Implication: the classification depends partly on judgement of reunion behaviour, so it is not purely mechanical. More precise coding rules for reunion, or a second coder to settle disagreements, would improve consistency.
- Add a limit: high agreement shows the coders are consistent, not that the categories are valid in every culture, so reliability and cross-cultural validity must be judged separately.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]What age range are infants usually observed at during the Strange Situation?Show answer
Answer: Around 12 to 18 months old.
Q2[3 marks]Name the three attachment types identified by Ainsworth.Show answer
Answer: Secure (Type B), insecure-avoidant (Type A) and insecure-resistant (Type C).
Q3[1 mark]Which attachment type shows the least separation anxiety?Show answer
Answer: Insecure-avoidant (Type A).
Q4[1 mark]Which attachment type shows the most separation anxiety along with clingy behaviour and little exploration?Show answer
Answer: Insecure-resistant (Type C).
Q5[1 mark]Who conducted a meta-analysis of Strange Situation studies from many countries to study cultural variation?Show answer
Answer: Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg (1988).
Q6[1 mark]In Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg's meta-analysis, was variation greater within countries or between countries?Show answer
Answer: Within countries.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Psychology exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Support a classification with named behaviours from the described episodes (exploration, separation, stranger, reunion), and say which behaviour rules out the nearest other type.
- In an evaluation of cultural use, name the assumption built into the coding, such as a particular reunion response counting as secure, and one child-rearing setting where it might not hold. 'Imposed etic' needs an example to persuade.
- When you cite reliability, say that trained observers classify independently and that the agreement between them is what is compared.
Q1[5 marks]The table below shows made-up percentages of attachment classifications from two separate Strange Situation studies carried out in the same country. Study 1: secure 62%, insecure-avoidant 25%, insecure-resistant 13%. Study 2: secure 68%, insecure-avoidant 12%, insecure-resistant 20%. (a) Calculate the difference, in percentage points, between Study 1 and Study 2 in the percentage of infants classified as insecure-avoidant. (b) Using Van Ijzendoorn and Kroonenberg's findings, explain what this pattern of results between two studies in the same country demonstrates about cultural variation in attachment.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 5 available
Q2[8 marks]Assess the extent to which the Strange Situation is more useful as a tool for research into cultural variations in attachment than as a way of assessing an individual infant's attachment relationship in clinical practice.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 8 available
See real A Level Psychology past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- AQA A Level Psychology past papers: 5 questions across 4 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- WJEC A Level Psychology past papers: 1 question across 1 paper, latest tagged Summer 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Attachment types: Ainsworth's Strange Situation and cultural variations in attachment worksheet pack - 5 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 17 of A Level Psychology Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 2 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 2 and chapter 16 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: