Worked question 4 - Explanations for Obedience: Agentic State and Legitimacy of Authority
Answer and mark scheme
Question 4
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | identifies a binding factor from the scenario, e.g. the awkwardness of arguing or being seen as disloyal (the cost of disobeying) oe |
| B1 | identifies a sign of moral strain from the scenario, e.g. her hands shaking, or her belief that the act is wrong oe |
| B1 | explains how the binding factor keeps her in the agentic state, e.g. it makes refusing seem more uncomfortable than obeying, so she continues oe |
- Answer: Binding factor: she wants to avoid an awkward argument and being seen as disloyal, so refusing feels costly. Sign of moral strain: her hands shake while she types (she believes the act is wrong). The binding factor keeps her obeying because disobeying feels more uncomfortable than carrying on.





