A Level Psychology Essentials 1 includes Conformity: types, explanations, Asch's research and Zimbardo's Stanford Prison Experiment (Social Influence); Milgram's Baseline Study Into Obedience: Procedure and Findings (Social Influence); Explanations for Obedience: Agentic State and Legitimacy of Authority (Social Influence); Situational Variables in Obedience: Proximity, Location and Uniform (Social Influence); The Authoritarian Personality as a Dispositional Explanation for Obedience (Social Influence); Minority Influence: Consistency, Commitment and Flexibility (Social Influence); Social Influence Processes and Social Change (Social Influence); The multi-store model of memory: sensory register, STM and LTM, coding, capacity and duration (Memory); Types of Long-Term Memory: Episodic, Semantic and Procedural (Memory); Eyewitness testimony: the effect of misleading information (leading questions and post-event discussion) (Memory); The Working Memory Model: Central Executive to Episodic Buffer (Memory); Explanations for Forgetting: Proactive and Retroactive Interference (Memory); Explanations for Forgetting: Retrieval Failure and Cue-Dependency (Memory); Eyewitness Testimony: The Effect of Anxiety on Recall (Memory); Improving Eyewitness Testimony: The Cognitive Interview (Memory); Caregiver-Infant Interactions: Reciprocity and Interactional Synchrony (Attachment); Attachment types: Ainsworth's Strange Situation and cultural variations in attachment (Attachment); Stages of Attachment and the Role of the Father (Attachment); Animal Studies of Attachment: Lorenz and Harlow (Attachment); Learning Theory as an Explanation of Attachment (Attachment); Maternal Deprivation and the Effects of Institutionalisation (Attachment); The Influence of Early Attachment on Later Relationships (Attachment); The Four Definitions of Abnormality (Psychopathology); Characteristics of Phobias: Behavioural, Emotional and Cognitive (Psychopathology); Characteristics of Depression: Behavioural, Emotional and Cognitive (Psychopathology); Characteristics of OCD: Behavioural, Emotional and Cognitive (Psychopathology); The Two-Process Model: Explaining Phobias via Conditioning (Psychopathology); Treating Phobias: Systematic Desensitisation and Flooding (Psychopathology); The Cognitive Approach to Depression: Beck, Ellis and CBT (Psychopathology); The Biological Approach to OCD: Genes, Neural Explanations and Drug Therapy (Psychopathology); Wundt, Introspection and the Emergence of Psychology as a Science (Approaches in Psychology); The Behaviourist Approach: Classical Conditioning and Pavlov's Research (Approaches in Psychology); The Behaviourist Approach: Operant Conditioning and Skinner's Research (Approaches in Psychology); Social Learning Theory: Imitation, Modelling and Bandura's Research (Approaches in Psychology).
Method recap - Social Influence Processes and Social Change
- Learn the sequence often used to describe how minority influence produces social change: drawing attention to an issue, creating cognitive conflict in the majority, showing consistency (both synchronic and diachronic), demonstrating commitment through the augmentation principle (costly or risky action increases perceived sincerity), the snowball effect (as more individual converts appear, the minority view gradually gains momentum and becomes the majority view), and social cryptomnesia (once the view is mainstream, people forget or misremember that it originated with a minority).
- Learn how normative social influence contributes to social change through descriptive social norms: Nolan et al.'s (2008) field study found that telling households that most of their neighbours tried to conserve energy reduced the households' own energy consumption more than standard financial or environmental appeal messages.
- Learn how obedience research contributes to understanding social change: in Milgram's variation studies, the presence of a disobedient confederate who refused to continue giving shocks sharply reduced the genuine participant's obedience, showing that seeing another person resist authority can give others 'social support' to dissent, which can gradually shift what is seen as an acceptable response to an unjust order.
- Learn the related idea of gradual commitment: small initial steps, as in Milgram's escalating shock levels, can commit a person to a course of action they would have refused if asked outright; real-world campaigns for social change sometimes use this same foot-in-the-door principle deliberately.
Worked example - Social Influence Processes and Social Change
A small group of students starts a campaign for their school canteen to stop using single-use plastic packaging. They repeat the same request at every student council meeting for a year, and two of them personally give up buying any packaged snacks to show they mean it. Over time, more students start supporting the idea, and eventually the school changes its policy. A year later, most students simply think of the plastic-free canteen as 'how things have always been'. Using the minority influence route to social change, identify and explain the stages shown in this scenario.
- Identify the initial campaign itself as drawing attention to the issue, making other students aware of the plastic packaging problem.
- Identify repeating the same request at every meeting for a year as consistency (diachronic consistency, the same position held over time).
- Identify the two students giving up packaged snacks as demonstrating commitment through the augmentation principle, since this personal cost increases how sincere the group appears.
- Identify more students gradually supporting the idea, leading to a policy change, as the snowball effect.
- Identify students later seeing the plastic-free canteen as simply 'how things have always been' as social cryptomnesia, since the origin of the change, a small dissenting minority, has been forgotten.
Question 10 - Social Influence Processes and Social Change
16 marks
Discuss how psychological research into social influence processes can help explain social change. (16 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 10 [16 marks]| Question 10[16 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Knowledge of the relevant theory/research is accurate and generally detailed. Discussion/evaluation is thorough, effective and clearly focused on the question. The answer is coherent, well organised and expressed with effective use of psychological terminology throughout. | Level 413-16 marks |
| Knowledge is evident but there may be occasional inaccuracies or a lack of detail. Discussion/evaluation is apparent and mostly effective, though it may lack a little depth or focus in places. The answer is mostly clear and organised, with appropriate use of terminology. | Level 39-12 marks |
| Knowledge is present but limited, and there may be inaccuracies. There is some attempt at discussion/evaluation, but it is not fully effective, may be brief or largely descriptive rather than evaluative. The answer lacks clarity and organisation in places, and terminology is not always used appropriately. | Level 25-8 marks |
| Knowledge is very limited. Discussion/evaluation, if present, is muddled, superficial and/or largely irrelevant to the question. The answer as a whole lacks organisation and coherence, and terminology is used inaccurately or not at all. | Level 11-4 marks |
| No relevant content, or the answer is not creditworthy in the context of the question. | 0 |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: description of the minority influence route to social change (drawing attention, cognitive conflict, consistency, commitment/augmentation principle, snowball effect, social cryptomnesia) | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: description of the role of descriptive social norms, with reference to Nolan et al.'s (2008) findings | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: description of the role of disobedient models in reducing obedience, with reference to Milgram's variation studies | |
| AO1 content that can gain credit: description of gradual commitment/foot-in-the-door as a mechanism for change | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a strength based on real-world, field-based application (Nolan et al.'s study was conducted in real households, giving it good ecological validity compared with laboratory-based minority influence research) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a limitation concerning the ecological validity of classic minority influence research (e.g. Moscovici's blue-green slide study used an artificial colour-judgement task with no real-world consequences for participants) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a limitation concerning the difficulty of separating minority and majority influence in real social change (a minority view that gains enough supporters effectively becomes a form of majority/normative influence itself, so the two processes may work together rather than as fully distinct explanations) | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a point on the slow, unpredictable pace of real social change compared with the immediate effects typically measured in lab studies, questioning how directly lab findings generalise to change occurring over years or decades | |
| AO3 content that can gain credit: a balanced conclusion noting that minority influence, normative social influence and disobedience research each capture part of the picture, so a combination of processes likely explains most real-world social change | |
Question 8 - Social Influence Processes and Social Change
4 marks
Outline how minority influence can lead to social change.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [4 marks]| Question 8[4 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| states the minority draws attention to the issue and creates cognitive conflict in the majority | 1 |
| states the minority must show consistency in its position | 1 |
| states that commitment, e.g. through the augmentation principle, increases how sincere the minority appears | 1 |
| describes the snowball effect and/or social cryptomnesia as the way the view spreads and eventually becomes mainstream | 1 |
Method recap - The multi-store model of memory: sensory register, STM and LTM, coding, capacity and duration
- Learn the three stores in order and what moves information between them: attention (sensory register to STM) and rehearsal (STM to LTM, and maintenance within STM).
- Learn the coding, capacity and duration of each store, and the key study behind each figure: Baddeley for coding, Miller for STM capacity, Peterson and Peterson for STM duration, Bahrick et al. for LTM duration.
- When asked to compare stores, organise the answer under the three headings (coding, capacity, duration) rather than store by store.
- When applying the model to a new scenario, identify which mechanism (attention or rehearsal) is doing the work described, and state what the model predicts should happen next.
Question 8 - The multi-store model of memory: sensory register, STM and LTM, coding, capacity and duration
6 marks
A student memorises a set of 12 unrelated playing cards by grouping them into four suits of three, then rehearses each group repeatedly before an exam. Using the concepts of capacity and rehearsal from the multi-store model, explain why this strategy is likely to help the student remember the cards accurately.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [6 marks]| Question 8[6 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| identifies that grouping the 12 cards into four chunks reduces the number of separate units held in STM | 1 |
| explains that STM capacity is limited by the number of chunks rather than individual items (Miller), so four chunks fits within the roughly seven, plus or minus two, limit | 1 |
| identifies that repeated rehearsal of each group keeps the information active in STM | 1 |
| explains that, according to the model, sufficient rehearsal transfers information from STM into LTM | 1 |
| links this to accurate recall: because the chunked information is both within STM's capacity and rehearsed enough to reach LTM, recall is more likely to be correct | 1 |
| notes a caveat, e.g. the strategy works best if the chunks are themselves meaningful or well-rehearsed, otherwise rehearsal alone may not guarantee transfer | 1 |
Question 7 - The multi-store model of memory: sensory register, STM and LTM, coding, capacity and duration
4 marks
Outline the difference in duration between short-term memory and long-term memory, according to the multi-store model, referring to one relevant study for each store.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [4 marks]| Question 7[4 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| STM has a short duration, lasting only a matter of seconds without rehearsal | 1 |
| supported by reference to Peterson and Peterson's (1959) finding that recall of trigrams fell sharply as the retention interval increased | 1 |
| LTM can last for a very long time, potentially decades or a lifetime | 1 |
| supported by reference to Bahrick et al.'s (1975) finding that recognition of former classmates' photographs remained accurate many years after graduation | 1 |