Eyewitness testimony: the effect of misleading information (leading questions and post-event discussion)
Eyewitness testimony is the evidence a witness gives about a crime or accident they observed, which research shows can be distorted by misleading information encountered after the event, including leading questions and post-event discussion with other witnesses. Because eyewitness accounts carry strong weight in criminal trials, such distortion risks serious miscarriages of justice.
Before you start
Make sure you're comfortable with these topics first:
Method
- Learn the definitions of misleading information, leading question and post-event discussion, each with a simple example.
- Learn Loftus and Palmer's procedure and findings on how the verb used in a question about a car accident affects estimated speed and later false memories (e.g. of broken glass).
- Learn the two explanations for why leading questions distort memory: response-bias (the report changes, not the memory) and substitution (the memory itself is altered).
- Learn Gabbert, Memon and Allan's research on post-event discussion and the term memory conformity.
- When given a new scenario involving a witness being questioned or discussing an event with others, identify which mechanism (leading question or post-event discussion) applies and state the likely effect on their testimony.
- Learn at least one piece of evidence that challenges the lab-based findings (e.g. Yuille and Cutshall's real-world study) and one real-world application (e.g. avoiding leading questions in police interviews), so the topic can be evaluated as well as described.
Common mistakes
MistakeClaiming that Loftus and Palmer's differing speed estimates prove the wording of a question changed the witnesses' memories.
InsteadDifferent estimates fit an explanation in which only the reported answer changes as well as one in which the memory changes. Stronger evidence for an altered memory is a later question that avoids the wording, such as one about a detail that was never in the film.
MistakeDescribing memory conformity as witnesses deliberately lying to match each other.
InsteadMemory conformity is not lying. A witness may go along with the group to fit in, or may accept a co-witness as a reliable source and take their detail into their own memory. Say which route the scenario suggests.
MistakeCriticising eyewitness laboratory studies only as 'not realistic', with no reason given.
InsteadName the specific difference from a real crime: staged clips carry no danger, no personal stake and no consequence for a wrong answer, so accuracy in real events may differ in either direction. Then say what a real-event study found, if you know one.
Worked examples
Example 1
Two friends, Ben and Chloe, watch a bicycle theft from different sides of a car park. Before being interviewed by store security, they spend ten minutes discussing what they saw. Chloe later reports seeing the thief wearing gloves, a detail Ben mentioned but that Chloe herself could not have seen from her position. Using the concept of memory conformity, explain what has likely happened to Chloe's account.
- Identify the process at work: Ben and Chloe discussed the event before being interviewed, so this is a case of post-event discussion.
- Identify the specific effect: Chloe has reported a detail (the gloves) she could not have personally observed, matching the pattern found in research such as Gabbert, Memon and Allan's study.
- Name the effect: this is memory conformity, where one witness's account comes to include details only learned from a co-witness.
- Explain the mechanism: during discussion Ben mentioned the gloves, and Chloe appears to have incorporated this detail into her own memory, believing she recalls it herself.
- State the implication: Chloe's evidence about the gloves is unreliable, since it may have originated from Ben's account rather than her own observation, so the two witnesses' testimony is no longer fully independent.
Example 2
A researcher shows 60 volunteers a short film of a robbery in which the robber carries no bag. Half are then asked, 'How fast was the robber going when he threw down his bag?' and half are asked, 'How fast was the robber going when he ran off?' A week later a different researcher asks everyone, 'Did the robber have a bag?' Of the first half, 21 say yes; of the second half, 6 say yes. Calculate each percentage and the difference, identify the misleading information, and say what the results suggest about the response-bias and substitution explanations.
- Percentages: 21 out of 30 is 70%, and 6 out of 30 is 20%. The difference is 50 percentage points (not 50%).
- The misleading information is the presupposition in the first question. 'Threw down his bag' assumes a bag existed, so the question adds a false detail to what the witnesses know about the event.
- Response-bias predicts that wording only changes the answer given at the time. The final question was worded neutrally for everyone, a week later and by a different researcher, so response-bias has little to explain.
- Substitution predicts that the false detail was absorbed into the memory itself, so it can be reported later even when nothing in the new question suggests it. The 50 percentage point gap fits this better.
- Limits: some participants may remember the first question and answer consistently with it, so response-bias is not ruled out completely. The film was staged and watched with no danger or personal stake, so the size of the effect may not match real witnesses.
- Answer: 70% against 20%, a difference of 50 percentage points. The results fit substitution better than response-bias because the effect appeared a week later under neutral questioning, but they do not rule response-bias out.
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]What term describes a question phrased in a way that suggests a particular answer to a witness?Show answer
Answer: A leading question.
Q2[1 mark]In Loftus and Palmer's study, which verb produced the highest average speed estimates?Show answer
Answer: 'Smashed'.
Q3[1 mark]What is the name of the explanation which claims that a leading question only changes a witness's reported answer, not their actual memory?Show answer
Answer: The response-bias explanation.
Q4[1 mark]What is the name of the explanation which claims that misleading information becomes part of the witness's actual memory?Show answer
Answer: The substitution explanation.
Q5[1 mark]What term describes witnesses' accounts becoming similar or contaminated after they discuss an event together?Show answer
Answer: Memory conformity.
Q6[1 mark]Which real-world study of witnesses to an actual armed robbery found that misleading questions had little effect on recall accuracy?Show answer
Answer: Yuille and Cutshall (1986).
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a A Level Psychology exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- In a question about a police interview, quote the exact word or phrase that suggests an answer, and say what answer it suggests, before you describe the effect it might have on the account.
- Keep the source of the misleading information clear: something an interviewer asks and something a co-witness says are different routes to distortion. Name the source first, then the effect.
- If you suggest a change to police practice, link it to a finding and say what it removes. For example, keeping witnesses apart until each has given a separate account removes the chance for contamination.
Q1[4 marks]Explain the difference between the response-bias explanation and the substitution explanation for the effect of leading questions on eyewitness testimony.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 4 available
Q2[6 marks]A market trader witnesses a shoplifting incident and is interviewed by a store detective who asks: 'How quickly did the shoplifter run when they barged past the till?' Using research into leading questions, explain how this question could distort the trader's account, and suggest one way the detective could have worded the question to avoid this risk.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
See real A Level Psychology past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- WJEC A Level Psychology past papers: 7 questions across 7 papers, latest tagged Summer 2025
- Eduqas A Level Psychology past papers: 6 questions across 6 papers, latest tagged Summer 2024
- AQA A Level Psychology past papers: 1 question across 1 paper, latest tagged June 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Eyewitness testimony: the effect of misleading information (leading questions and post-event discussion) worksheet pack - 6 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 10 of A Level Psychology Essentials 1, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 10 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1, a free printable practice book.