Worked question 10 - Eyewitness testimony: the effect of misleading information (leading questions and post-event discussion)
Scenario: the road junction collision
Original scenario written for Revision Library.
At approximately 4pm on a weekday afternoon, a silver car pulls out of a side road and collides with a cyclist at a busy junction. Four pedestrians on the opposite pavement witness the collision. Police later interview the four witnesses separately, but two of them, Marcus and Delia, had already discussed what they saw with each other while waiting for the police to arrive.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| M1 | (a) Yuille and Cutshall (1986) interviewed real witnesses to an actual armed robbery/shooting several months after the event oe |
| A1 | (a) the witnesses' recall remained largely accurate and detailed oe |
| A1 | (a) misleading questions included in the follow-up interview had little effect on the accuracy of their accounts oe |
| A1 | (a) this challenges Loftus and Palmer's conclusions, since it suggests real, significant and emotionally arousing events may not be as easily distorted by misleading information as a bland laboratory film of a car accident oe |
| A1 | (a) so Loftus and Palmer's lab-based findings may lack ecological validity for real, high-stakes eyewitness events oe |
| M1 | (b) research into misleading information has led to guidance that police officers should avoid using leading questions when interviewing eyewitnesses oe |
| A1 | (b) officers are instead trained to ask open, non-leading questions (e.g. as part of the Cognitive Interview technique) to reduce the risk of contaminating a witness's memory oe |
| A1 | (b) witnesses are also usually interviewed separately/kept apart where possible, to reduce the risk of post-event discussion contaminating their accounts oe |
| A1 | (b) this is important because eyewitness testimony can strongly influence jury decisions, so distorted testimony risks miscarriages of justice oe |
| A1 | (b) showing this research has real, valuable practical applications beyond the laboratory oe |
- (a) Answer: Real witnesses to a genuine, significant crime stayed largely accurate despite misleading questions, challenging the ecological validity of Loftus and Palmer's lab-based conclusions.
- (b) Answer: Research findings underpin practical guidance for police, such as avoiding leading questions and interviewing witnesses separately, to protect the accuracy of evidence used in court.








