A Level Business Essentials includes Price and Income Elasticity of Demand (Marketing and people); The Boston Matrix and Product Portfolio Analysis (Marketing and people); Leadership Styles and Theories of Leadership (Marketing and people); Market Research Methods: Primary, Secondary and Sampling Techniques (Marketing and people); Motivation Theories: Taylor, Maslow, Herzberg and Job Design (Marketing and people); Entrepreneurship: Risk, Reward and Assessing Business Viability (Marketing and people); Budgeting and Variance Analysis: Favourable and Adverse Variances (Managing business activities); Critical Path Analysis: Network Diagrams and the Critical Path (Managing business activities); Sources of Finance: Share Capital, Loan Capital and Venture Capital (Managing business activities); Ratio Analysis: Liquidity, Efficiency and Gearing Ratios (Managing business activities); Lean Production: Just-in-Time, Kaizen and Time-Based Management (Managing business activities); Quality Management: Total Quality Management and Cost of Quality (Managing business activities); Analysing Human Resource Performance: Productivity and Turnover (Managing business activities); Analysing Operational Performance: Unit Cost and Capacity (Managing business activities); Decision Trees and Quantitative Decision-Making (Decision making to improve performance); Porter's Five Forces and Competitive Strategy (Decision making to improve performance); Corporate Objectives, Mission and Ansoff's Matrix (Decision making to improve performance); Methods of Business Growth: Mergers, Joint Ventures and Franchising (Decision making to improve performance); Economic Influences on Business: Interest Rates and Exchange Rates (Decision making to improve performance); SWOT Analysis and Choosing a Strategic Option (Decision making to improve performance); Retrenchment, Redundancy and Business Contraction as a Strategy (Decision making to improve performance); Setting Functional Objectives: Marketing, Operations, Finance, HR (Decision making to improve performance); Multinationals and Global Market Entry Strategies (Global business).
Method recap - Entrepreneurship: Risk, Reward and Assessing Business Viability
- Separate the entrepreneur's possible rewards (trading profit, capital gain on sale, independence) from the risks they accept (capital lost, opportunity cost of a salary given up, unlimited liability if unincorporated).
- State the general risk-reward relationship: an entrepreneur normally has to accept a higher chance of loss to access a higher potential return, though relevant experience or a strong market position can reduce risk without reducing potential reward.
- Learn the quantitative tools used to test viability before trading starts: break-even analysis (fixed costs divided by contribution per unit) and a cash flow forecast (checking the business will not run out of cash even if it is eventually profitable on paper).
- Calculate margin of safety, actual or forecast sales minus the break-even quantity, as the buffer of extra output before the business starts making a loss.
Worked example - Entrepreneurship: Risk, Reward and Assessing Business Viability
Amara is deciding whether to launch a subscription meal-kit business. Fixed costs are forecast at 45,000 pounds per year. Each box sells for 25 pounds and costs 10 pounds in ingredients and packaging to make. Amara forecasts she can sell 4,000 boxes in year one. Calculate the break-even output and the margin of safety at the forecast sales level, and use these to comment on the viability of the business.
- Find the contribution per unit: selling price minus variable cost per unit, 25 - 10 = 15 pounds per box.
- Find the break-even output: fixed costs divided by contribution per unit, 45,000 / 15 = 3,000 boxes.
- Find the margin of safety: forecast sales minus break-even output, 4,000 - 3,000 = 1,000 boxes.
- Express the margin of safety as a percentage of forecast sales: 1,000 / 4,000 x 100 = 25%.
- Interpret the result: forecast sales are 25% above the break-even point, so a reasonable forecasting error would still leave the business profitable, which supports viability, though the judgement still depends on how reliable the 4,000-box sales forecast actually is.
Question 10 - Entrepreneurship: Risk, Reward and Assessing Business Viability
16 marks
Nadia is deciding whether to open a small artisan bakery. She has saved 15,000 pounds and would need to borrow a further 10,000 pounds. Fixed costs are forecast at 38,000 pounds a year. Each loaf sells for 4 pounds and costs 1.50 pounds in ingredients. Nadia forecasts selling 12,000 loaves in year one, based on footfall counts she took outside the proposed site over four weeks. A new supermarket bakery counter opened two streets away last month. Evaluate whether Nadia should go ahead with the bakery.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 10 [16 marks]| Question 10[16 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| a well-supported judgement is reached, built on accurate use of the break-even and margin of safety figures alongside qualitative evidence from the case (the new competitor, the basis of the sales forecast), with counter-argument and a conclusion that explicitly weighs the strength of the evidence on each side. | Level 413-16 marks |
| developed analysis on both sides of the argument using the figures and case detail, but the final judgement is not fully justified from the evidence given. | Level 39-12 marks |
| some relevant calculation or case detail used with limited development or one-sided argument. | Level 25-8 marks |
| isolated, undeveloped points with little or no use of the figures. | Level 11-4 marks |
| Indicative calculation: contribution per loaf = 4 - 1.50 = 2.50 pounds; break-even = 38,000 / 2.50 = 15,200 loaves. | |
| forecast sales of 12,000 loaves are below the 15,200 break-even output, meaning the business is forecast to make a loss at the current forecast, and the arrival of a new supermarket bakery counter makes the footfall-based forecast less reliable. | |
| the footfall count gives some evidence-based grounding to the forecast rather than a guess, and Nadia has 15,000 pounds of her own capital reducing (though not removing) reliance on debt, with scope to raise price or cut costs before opening. | |
| A credible conclusion should state that, on the figures given, the bakery is not currently viable, and either explain what would need to change (higher price, lower fixed costs, or a materially higher sales forecast) or justify proceeding despite the shortfall by challenging the reliability of the forecast. | |
Question 9 - Entrepreneurship: Risk, Reward and Assessing Business Viability
9 marks
Tariq is launching a personalised phone case business. Fixed costs are 12,000 pounds a year. Each case sells for 18 pounds and costs 6 pounds to produce. Tariq forecasts sales of 1,500 cases in year one. Analyse the viability of Tariq's business using break-even analysis.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [9 marks]| Question 9[9 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| a calculation of the break-even output and margin of safety is used to support a developed analytical point about viability, with a clear chain of reasoning linking the figures to a conclusion about risk. | Level 25-9 marks |
| relevant calculation(s) attempted with limited or no analysis of what the result means for viability. | Level 11-4 marks |
| Indicative calculation: contribution per unit = 18 - 6 = 12 pounds; break-even = 12,000 / 12 = 1,000 cases. | |
| Indicative calculation: margin of safety = 1,500 - 1,000 = 500 cases, or 500 / 1,500 x 100 = 33.3% of forecast sales. | |
| Indicative analysis: a one-third margin of safety suggests the business could withstand a significant shortfall in sales before making a loss, supporting viability, provided the 1,500-case forecast itself is realistic. | |
Method recap - Budgeting and Variance Analysis: Favourable and Adverse Variances
- Identify whether the figure in question is a revenue item or a cost item, since the same-sized numerical difference is interpreted in opposite ways for each.
- Calculate the variance as actual minus budget for both revenue and cost lines, keeping the sign.
- Label a revenue variance: positive (actual higher than budget) is favourable; negative (actual lower than budget) is adverse.
- Label a cost variance the opposite way round: positive (actual higher than budget, i.e. cost overrun) is adverse; negative (actual lower than budget) is favourable.
Question 8 - Budgeting and Variance Analysis: Favourable and Adverse Variances
16 marks
GreenBranch Nurseries budgeted for quarterly sales revenue of 120,000 pounds and quarterly costs of 90,000 pounds. Due to an unexpected summer heatwave increasing demand for garden plants, actual sales revenue was 138,000 pounds. However, a shortage of imported plant pots pushed actual costs up to 101,000 pounds. Using variance analysis, evaluate whether GreenBranch Nurseries' quarter should be considered a success.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [16 marks]| Question 8[16 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| limited or no calculation, unsupported assertion. | Level 11-4 marks |
| one variance correctly calculated (revenue or cost) with limited development. | Level 25-8 marks |
| both variances and profit variance correctly calculated (revenue variance = 138,000 - 120,000 = +18,000 pounds, favourable; cost variance = 101,000 - 90,000 = +11,000 pounds, adverse; budgeted profit = 120,000 - 90,000 = 30,000 pounds; actual profit = 138,000 - 101,000 = 37,000 pounds; profit variance = +7,000 pounds, favourable) with analysis of the causes given (heatwave demand, plant pot shortage). | Level 39-13 marks |
| balanced evaluation, e.g. concluding the quarter was a genuine success overall since the 7,000 pound favourable profit variance shows the demand increase outweighed the cost overrun, but noting the heatwave-driven revenue rise is likely uncontrollable and may not repeat next quarter, while the plant pot shortage causing the adverse cost variance is worth investigating for a cause GreenBranch could manage, such as sourcing a second supplier. | Level 414-16 marks |
Question 7 - Budgeting and Variance Analysis: Favourable and Adverse Variances
9 marks
Analyse the benefits to a business of carrying out regular variance analysis.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [9 marks]| Question 7[9 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| basic statement, e.g. it shows if the business is over or under budget, with little development. | Level 11-3 marks |
| one chain of reasoning, e.g. identifying a significant adverse cost variance quickly allows managers to investigate its cause and act before it accumulates over further budget periods, protecting overall profit. | Level 24-6 marks |
| two or more points analysed with application, e.g. linking variance analysis to accountability (holding specific department managers responsible for variances within their control) and to more accurate future budget-setting based on what variance analysis reveals about past estimating errors. | Level 37-9 marks |