Worked question 14 - Motivation Theories: Taylor, Maslow, Herzberg and Job Design
Answer and mark scheme
Question 14
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | knowledge: computes staff turnover = (6/25) x 100 = 24% and states this figure |
| B1 | applied: links 24% turnover to immediate effects on staffing, e.g. temporary understaffing or need to use agency staff |
| B1 | applied: identifies increased recruitment/training costs for replacing 6 employees and links to GreenLeaf context |
| B1 | analysis: explains how recruitment and training reduce short-term productivity, even if average daily covers per FTE remain unchanged over the year |
| B1 | analysis: explains potential negative effect on customer service quality from inexperienced staff or frequent changes, with examples such as slower service or mistakes |
| B1 | analysis: discusses possible longer-term effects, e.g. lower morale among remaining staff, higher manager workload, and risk of further turnover |
| B1 | analysis: quantifies or weighs trade-offs using the 24% figure, e.g. replacing nearly a quarter of staff in a year is significant for a small cafe and likely to raise costs materially |
| B1 | conclusion or judgement: provides a supported judgement about overall impact, e.g. turnover is likely to harm short-term productivity and customer service and increase costs unless managed |
- Answer: Staff turnover = (6/25) x 100 = 24%. A 24% annual turnover is high for a small cafe and means GreenLeaf must recruit and train nearly a quarter of its workforce, raising recruitment fees, vacancy costs and training time. Even though average daily covers per FTE are reported unchanged over the year, short-term productivity is likely to fall during recruitment and training periods, and the cafe may need agency or overtime cover, which is more expensive. Customer service may suffer from inexperienced staff, slower service and more mistakes, reducing customer satisfaction and potentially sales. Remaining staff may face higher workloads and lower morale, which can further reduce productivity and increase the risk of further turnover. Overall, the 24% turnover is likely to increase costs and reduce service quality unless the cafe invests in retention and rapid induction.



