Worked question 8 - Measurements and their Errors
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) the wire's diameter is not perfectly uniform along its length, so a single reading is subject to random variation |
| B1 | (a) taking a mean of several readings reduces the effect of this random variation, giving a more precise/representative value of the diameter |
| M1 | (b) converts diameter to metres: d = 3.2 x 10-4 m |
| M1 | (b) correct substitution and evaluation: A = π x (3.2 x 10-4)2 / 4 = 8.04 x 10-8 m2 |
| A1 | (b) 8.0 x 10-8 m2 (awrt, to 2 s.f., matching the precision of d) |
| M1 | (c) absolute uncertainty in d = half the resolution = ± 0.005 mm |
| M1 | (c) percentage uncertainty in d = (0.005/0.32) x 100 = 1.6% |
| A1 | (c) since A depends on d2, percentage uncertainty in A = 2 x 1.6% = 3.1% (ft) |
| M1 | (d) percentage uncertainty in R = (0.05/2.40) x 100 = 2.1% |
| M1 | (d) percentage uncertainty in l = (0.001/0.800) x 100 = 0.13% |
| A1 | (d) for a product/quotient, percentage uncertainties add: %unc(ρ) = 2.1% + 3.1% + 0.13% = 5.3% (ft from c) |
| M1 | (e) correct substitution: ρ = (2.40 x 8.04 x 10-8) / 0.800 |
| M1 | (e) ρ = 2.41 x 10-7 ohm m (or awrt, ft from b) |
| M1 | (e) absolute uncertainty = 2.41 x 10-7 x 0.053 = 1.3 x 10-8 ohm m (ft from d) |
| A1 | (e) ρ = (2.4 ± 0.1) x 10-7 ohm m (awrt, appropriate s.f.) |
| 5-6 | (f) L3 A full, coherent evaluation that correctly identifies the diameter measurement as the dominant source of uncertainty (because it is doubled when calculating the area), proposes at least two valid, correctly justified improvements linked to specific measurements in the experiment, and reaches a clear, justified conclusion about which change would have the greatest effect. |
| 3-4 | (f) L2 The answer identifies at least one valid improvement and links it correctly to a reduction in percentage uncertainty, but the evaluation is incomplete, lacks full justification, or does not identify the dominant source of uncertainty. |
| 1-2 | (f) L1 A basic suggestion for improving the experiment (e.g. use better equipment) with little or no justification linking it to percentage uncertainty. |
| 0 | (f) L0 No relevant content, or the answer does not relate to the question. |
- (a) Answer: A wire is not perfectly uniform in thickness, so measuring at several points and averaging reduces the effect of random variation and gives a more precise mean diameter.
- (b) Answer: A = 8.0 x 10-8 m2
- (c) Answer: 3.1%
- (d) Answer: 5.3%
- (e) Answer: ρ = (2.4 ± 0.1) x 10-7 ohm m
- (f) Indicative content:
- The diameter measurement contributes the largest percentage uncertainty to the resistivity because it is squared in the area calculation (its percentage uncertainty is doubled), so it is the dominant source of overall uncertainty.
- Using a micrometer/digital micrometer with a smaller resolution (e.g. 0.001 mm) would reduce the absolute and hence percentage uncertainty in the diameter.
- Measuring the diameter at several points and in perpendicular directions at each point (to check for a non-circular cross-section) and averaging reduces random error further.
- Using a longer length of wire (while keeping the same absolute uncertainty in the length measurement) reduces the percentage uncertainty in l, since percentage uncertainty falls as the measured value increases for a fixed absolute uncertainty.
- Reading the length with a set square against the metre rule (avoiding parallax error) reduces the absolute uncertainty in l.
- Taking several sets of V and I readings and using the gradient of the V-I graph (rather than a single pair of readings) reduces the effect of random error in R.
- Conclusion: reducing the uncertainty in the diameter measurement gives the greatest improvement in the overall percentage uncertainty in resistivity, since it is the largest single contributor and is doubled in the calculation.
- (f) Answer: Improving the diameter measurement (e.g. finer-resolution micrometer, more readings at different points/orientations, averaging) gives the greatest reduction in overall percentage uncertainty, since the diameter's percentage uncertainty is doubled in the area calculation and is the dominant contributor (3.1% of the total 5.3%).







