A Level Sociology Essentials 2 includes Victimology: Explaining Patterns of Victimisation (Crime and deviance); Religious Organisations: Churches, Denominations, Sects and Cults (Beliefs in society); New Religious Movements, New Age Movements and Religiosity (Beliefs in society); Functionalist Definitions of Religion and Civil Religion (Beliefs in society); Marxist and Neo-Marxist Perspectives on Religion as Ideology (Beliefs in society); Feminist Perspectives on Religion and Patriarchy (Beliefs in society); Religion, Science and Ideology as Competing Belief Systems (Beliefs in society); Religion as a Force for Political and Social Change (Beliefs in society); Class, Gender, Ethnicity and Age: Patterns of Religiosity (Beliefs in society); Measuring Religiosity: Defining and Operationalising Religious Belief (Beliefs in society); Global Development: Theories of Development, Underdevelopment and World Systems (Global development); The Media: Ownership, Control and the Pluralist versus Marxist Debate (The media); The Media: Representations of Age, Class, Gender, Ethnicity and Disability (The media); Health: Concepts of Health, Illness and the Medicalisation of Society (Health); Work, Poverty and Welfare: Explanations and Measurement of Poverty (Work, poverty and welfare); Work and Welfare: Changing Work, Worklessness and Welfare Policy (Work, poverty and welfare).
Method recap - Global Development: Theories of Development, Underdevelopment and World Systems
- Set out modernisation theory's key claim clearly: underdevelopment is caused mainly by internal barriers within poorer countries (traditional culture, low investment), and development is a staged process every country can, in principle, pass through.
- Learn Rostow's five stages in order with a brief description of each: traditional society, preconditions for take-off, take-off, drive to maturity, and age of mass consumption, since exam questions sometimes ask students to identify or apply a specific stage.
- Present dependency theory as a direct rejection of modernisation theory's internal explanation: Frank argues poverty in the periphery results from an external relationship of historical and ongoing exploitation by the core, not from internal cultural failings.
- Define Frank's 'development of underdevelopment' precisely: colonialism and unequal trade did not simply fail to develop poorer regions, they actively structured those regions' economies to extract wealth and resources for richer countries, producing underdevelopment as an active outcome, not a starting condition.
Worked example - Global Development: Theories of Development, Underdevelopment and World Systems
Item A: During the colonial period, a country's economy was reorganised around exporting a small number of raw materials to the colonising power, with little investment in local manufacturing industries. After independence, the country continued to rely heavily on exporting the same raw materials and struggled to develop its own manufacturing base. Applying material from Item A and your knowledge, analyse two ways dependency theory explains the pattern described. (10 marks)
- Identify the item's key pattern: colonial-era reorganisation around raw material exports with little manufacturing investment, continuing after independence.
- Way 1: use Frank's 'development of underdevelopment' directly, the colonial reorganisation around raw material exports was not neutral, it actively structured the economy to serve the coloniser's needs, producing underdevelopment rather than simply leaving development to happen later.
- Develop way 1: explain that this legacy did not disappear at independence, since the economic structure (reliance on raw material exports, weak manufacturing) was already built in, showing dependency is a lasting structural relationship, not just a historical event.
- Way 2: use Wallerstein's world systems theory as a complementary explanation, the country's position as a raw-material exporter locates it in the periphery of the global capitalist economy, a position that world systems theory argues chiefly determines its development level, regardless of internal effort.
- Add a brief contrast with modernisation theory: a modernisation theorist might instead point to the lack of local manufacturing investment as an internal barrier, but the item's colonial detail suggests this lack of investment was itself a product of the external relationship, supporting the dependency reading.
- Check both ways are tied explicitly to the item's colonial and post-independence detail, and named using Frank and Wallerstein rather than a generic account of underdevelopment.
Question 7 - Global Development: Theories of Development, Underdevelopment and World Systems
10 marks
Outline and explain two differences between modernisation theory and dependency theory.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [10 marks]| Question 7[10 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Award up to 5 marks per difference: 2 marks for identifying an accurate difference, up to 3 further marks for explanation and development. | |
| Difference 1: the cause of underdevelopment, modernisation theory locates it in internal cultural barriers, dependency theory locates it in external exploitation by richer countries (Frank). | |
| Difference 2: the recommended solution, modernisation theory recommends Western aid, investment and values to help countries progress through Rostow's stages, dependency theory is sceptical of such aid, seeing it as potentially reinforcing dependency rather than removing it. | |
| Credit other valid, developed differences, e.g. their view of colonialism's legacy. | |
Question 8 - Global Development: Theories of Development, Underdevelopment and World Systems
10 marks
Item B: A country that gained independence several decades ago continues to export mainly unprocessed raw materials to wealthier nations, and receives back manufactured goods at a much higher price, so the value of its exports has grown far more slowly than the value of its imports over time. Applying material from Item B and your knowledge, analyse two ways world systems theory explains the pattern described. (10 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 8 [10 marks]| Question 8[10 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Award up to 5 marks per way: 2 marks for an accurately applied point from the item, up to 3 further marks for developed analysis. | |
| Way 1 (from the item): exporting cheap raw materials and importing expensive manufactured goods matches Wallerstein's description of a peripheral country's position in the world system, structurally disadvantaged in terms of trade value. | |
| Way 2 (from the item): the slower growth in export value compared to import value over time illustrates how a country's position within the world system, rather than its own effort, can lock in a lasting economic disadvantage, since core countries capture more value from the trading relationship. | |
| Full marks require explicit use of the item's trade value detail, not a generic account of world systems theory. | |
Method recap - The Media: Ownership, Control and the Pluralist versus Marxist Debate
- Set the three-way debate out clearly at the start: traditional Marxism (direct owner control), neo-Marxism/hegemony (indirect, ideological influence through professional norms), and pluralism (competitive market gives audiences real power), since answers that blur these lose precision marks.
- Explain the traditional Marxist argument with a concrete mechanism: the Glasgow University Media Group's research found systematic patterns of bias, for example coverage of strikes and industrial disputes tending to favour management's perspective over workers', which Marxists attribute to concentrated ownership.
- Explain the neo-Marxist hegemonic model precisely, since it is often confused with traditional Marxism: it does not require owners to give direct instructions, instead, journalists' own professional training, sense of newsworthiness and reliance on 'authoritative' official sources tend to reproduce dominant ideas without any deliberate top-down control.
- Explain the pluralist position and its key mechanism: because audiences can choose between many competing outlets, and outlets need audiences (and advertisers) to survive, content has to respond to what audiences actually want, giving audiences real, if indirect, power over content.
Question 9 - The Media: Ownership, Control and the Pluralist versus Marxist Debate
20 marks
Item C: A media company owned by a small number of shareholders controls several major news outlets. Its coverage of economic policy consistently favours lower business taxes and criticises increased workers' rights. Supporters of a pluralist view argue this simply reflects what most of the company's audience wants to read, since competing outlets with different audiences take a different editorial line. Applying material from Item C and your knowledge, evaluate the view that media content mainly reflects the interests of media owners rather than audiences. (20 marks)
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 9 [20 marks]| Question 9[20 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| sustained, accurate application of traditional Marxist, neo-Marxist and pluralist theory to the item, developed analysis, and effective evaluation weighing the perspectives against each other, with a clear, supported conclusion. | Level 417-20 marks |
| accurate knowledge applied to the item; evaluation present but may be less consistently developed. | Level 313-16 marks |
| some accurate knowledge but limited application to the item or thin evaluation. | Level 28-12 marks |
| basic, undeveloped knowledge, little application to the item, no effective evaluation. | Level 11-7 marks |
| no creditable response. | 0 |
| the item's concentrated ownership and consistently pro-business editorial line matches the Glasgow University Media Group's argument about systematic, ownership-linked bias. | |
| the item's pluralist counter-argument, that competing outlets serve different audiences with different views, matches Whale's consumer sovereignty argument, and neo-Marxists would add that even where content favours dominant interests, this can result from journalistic routine rather than proving owners directly dictate coverage. | |
| a strong answer judges that concentrated ownership creates a real tendency towards owner-friendly content, as the item suggests, but that this tendency is moderated, not eliminated, by audience choice and competition between outlets, so the true picture sits between the pure Marxist and pure pluralist positions. | |
Question 7 - The Media: Ownership, Control and the Pluralist versus Marxist Debate
10 marks
Outline and explain two differences between the pluralist and traditional Marxist views of media ownership.
Answer and mark scheme
Mark scheme for Question 7 [10 marks]| Question 7[10 marks] |
|---|
| Answer or working | Marks |
|---|
| Award up to 5 marks per difference: 2 marks for identifying an accurate difference, up to 3 further marks for explanation and development. | |
| Difference 1: source of content control, pluralists locate power with audiences (consumer sovereignty), traditional Marxists locate it with owners. | |
| Difference 2: view of media competition, pluralists see a genuinely competitive market forcing outlets to respond to diverse audience demand, traditional Marxists see concentrated ownership limiting real competition and diversity of content. | |
| Credit other valid, developed differences. | |