Worked question 17 - Comprehension: Poetry: Practice Set 2
Smoke and Gold
Source written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free). Original poem created for 11+ comprehension practice.
My grandmother kept six hives by the wall,
with frames all blistered gold from rim to rim,
and every August brought the ache of stings
to fingers far too young and far too slim.
She'd light the smoker, calm as evening air,
and lift each frame as gently as a book,
her veiled face steady above a thousand wings
that rose and settled, no matter how it shook.
"They only sting," she'd say, "when they're afraid,
so keep your breathing low and stay quite still;
the hive's one creature, not a swarm of parts,
and fear is caught much faster than a chill."
I did not trust her then. I told myself
however hard I tried, I could not stay still,
and thought her calm was something like a trick,
too strange to learn, a lesson far uphill.
Now every summer when the clover blooms,
I light the smoker slow the way she taught,
and stand as still as she once stood, and feel
the calm that as a child I never caught.
The hive does not reward the loud or fast;
it only asks for patience we can make;
it gives its gold to those who hold themselves
as steady as a branch that will not shake.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 17
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 1-2 | Level 1 A simple, general comment on the relationship, with little or no textual support. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 A clear response identifying aspects of the relationship, with some relevant reference to language or structure. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 A detailed, well-supported discussion exploring more than one aspect of the relationship (for example the grandmother's words, the speaker's changing attitude), with well-chosen quotation. |
| 7-8 | Level 4 A perceptive discussion considering how language, structure and form together shape the presentation of the relationship, with precise, well-integrated textual support. |
| 9-10 | Level 5 A sophisticated, convincing discussion that explores the relationship in a nuanced way across the whole poem, evaluating how the poet's choices of language, structure and form work together, with skilfully selected and embedded evidence throughout. |
- Indicative content:
- The grandmother is presented through calm, controlled action and direct, quoted speech (stanza 3), giving her an authoritative but reassuring voice within the poem
- The simile 'as gently as a book' (stanza 2) suggests her deep familiarity and quiet respect for the bees, presenting her as skilled and patient
- The relationship is presented as one of inherited skill and confidence passed down across time: the child does not initially trust or understand his grandmother's calm (stanza 4), but comes to repeat her exact actions as an adult (stanza 5)
- The repetition of 'still' across stanzas 3 to 5 structurally embodies the passing on of calmness from grandmother to grandchild
- The regular quatrain form and steady ABCB rhyme scheme give the whole poem a controlled, measured tone appropriate to a considered adult looking back with gratitude
- The grandmother is not directly present in stanzas 5 and 6 (referred to only through the speaker's memory of her actions), suggesting she may no longer be alive, deepening the sense of a skill or legacy carried forward after her
- Strong responses will consider the relationship as one of quiet, inherited confidence that deepens with time and distance rather than one that is straightforwardly close throughout
Answer: The poem presents a relationship built on quietly inherited calm: the grandmother, characterised through patient action and direct speech, is not fully trusted by the young speaker, but her example is eventually adopted and repeated in adulthood, with the recurring motif of stillness and the poem's controlled form suggesting a respectful, matured confidence that may now be tinged with loss.













