Revision Library
Choose a subject
Menu

11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbooks · Book 7 of 10

11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 7

Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1, Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 2, Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 3 and 4 more

Level
11+ · GL Assessment · CEM
Series
11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbooks, book 7 of 10
Suitable for
Year 5-6 entrance exams
FreePDF download · 2027 edition · 97 A4 pages
  • One file, prints straight to A4
  • No account, no password

Workbooks like this one, with 7 topics, 136 questions and mark schemes at the back, are usually printed and sold by publishers. This one is one of 558 free PDFs on the shelf.

Pages
97 A4 pages
Chapters
7 worksheet chapters
Questions
136 · 705 marks
Answers
From page 72
Working time
About 11h 45m

What is inside

7 chapters · answers from p72

Each chapter starts with a page showing its marks and a suggested time, followed by the questions. The mark schemes for all 7 chapters are at the back, so the book works for homework, a timed test or revision.

  1. 01Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 124 questions · 63 marks · about 65 min Topic guide: Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1p3
  2. 02Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 224 questions · 62 marks · about 60 min Topic guide: Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 2p12
  3. 03Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 326 questions · 60 marks · about 60 min Topic guide: Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 3p21
  4. 04Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 426 questions · 55 marks · about 55 min Topic guide: Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 4p30
  5. 05Creative Writing17 questions · 114 marks · about 115 min Topic guide: Creative Writingp39
  6. 06Creative and Persuasive Writing Prompts9 questions · 165 marks · about 165 min Topic guide: Creative and Persuasive Writing Promptsp49
  7. 07Creative and Persuasive Writing Prompts Set 210 questions · 186 marks · about 185 min Topic guide: Creative and Persuasive Writing Prompts Set 2p59
  8. AnswersMark schemes for every chapterp72

Each chapter is drawn from one of our worksheet packs. Follow a chapter title for the full pack on its own page, or browse every 11+ English pack. Every book on the shelf is a complete printable workbook of up to 120 A4 pages.

Explore this volume

11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 7 includes Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1 (from page 3); Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 2 (from page 12); Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 3 (from page 21); Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 4 (from page 30); Creative Writing (from page 39); Creative and Persuasive Writing Prompts (from page 49); Creative and Persuasive Writing Prompts Set 2 (from page 59).

Worked question 24 - Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 4

Open the included worksheet

Two Texts: Maps and the People Who Make Them

Original texts written for Revision Library. Text 1 is original short fiction; Text 2 is original non-fiction.

TEXT 1: THE MAP BEHIND THE SHELF (fiction)

Rehan had been sorting books into cardboard boxes for two straight hours when his uncle finally called out from the front counter that they could stop for the day. The bookshop, Whitlock's Rare and Secondhand Books, was closing at the end of the month, and every shelf had to be emptied, checked and boxed before the new owners took over and turned it, according to the sign already taped in the window, into a coffee shop.

It was while he was reaching for the last few books on the highest shelf that Rehan noticed something odd: the shelf itself seemed to wobble slightly, as though it were not properly fixed to the wall behind it. Curious, he pressed his palm flat against the dusty wood and pushed. To his surprise, the whole shelf unit swung outward on a hidden hinge, revealing a narrow gap behind it, no wider than a school ruler, in the brick wall.

Inside the gap, rolled tightly and tied with a length of faded string, was a single sheet of thick, yellowed paper. Rehan's fingers trembled slightly as he worked the knot loose and unrolled it flat across the counter. It was a map, hand-drawn in careful black ink, showing streets Rehan half recognised, though the names beneath them were older, unfamiliar spellings he had never seen on any modern sign.

In one corner, someone had drawn a small, neat cross beside a symbol that looked like a bell, and beside it, in handwriting even smaller than the rest, three words: still there, listen. Rehan turned the map over, searching for anything else, a date, a name, an explanation, but the back of the paper was completely blank.

His uncle appeared in the doorway, keys jangling, ready to lock up for the night. "Whatever you've found, it'll have to wait until tomorrow," he said, glancing at the darkening window. "Whitlock's has been here since 1891, Rehan. Believe me, anything hidden in these walls has waited a great deal longer than one more night." Rehan carefully rolled the map back up, already certain that tomorrow could not come quickly enough.

TEXT 2: READING THE GROUND - A SHORT HISTORY OF MAPMAKING (non-fiction)

Long before satellites circled the Earth taking photographs from space, people were already finding ways to record the shape of the world around them. Some of the oldest known maps are not drawn on paper at all but scratched onto clay tablets, dating back nearly four thousand years, showing rivers, mountains and settlements from a bird's eye view that no ancient mapmaker could possibly have seen with their own eyes.

One of the most influential early mapmakers was Ptolemy, a scholar working in Egypt around AD 150, who collected geographical information from traders and travellers and used it to draw a map of the known world, complete with a grid of lines representing latitude and longitude. Although parts of his map were badly inaccurate, since large areas of the world were still completely unknown to him, his method of using a coordinate grid shaped mapmaking for well over a thousand years afterwards.

"What people often forget," explains Dr Naomi Foss, a historian of cartography, "is that maps were never simply neutral records of geography. Every mapmaker had to decide what mattered enough to include and what could be left out, which meant every map also carried the beliefs, priorities and limitations of the person who drew it." Medieval maps, for example, frequently placed Jerusalem at the exact centre of the world, reflecting religious belief rather than geographical accuracy.

Mapmaking changed dramatically from the fifteenth century onwards, as sailors began crossing oceans further and further from home, gradually filling in the blank spaces on the map with real, measured coastlines. By the eighteenth century, more precise instruments allowed surveyors to measure distance and elevation with far greater accuracy, and by the twentieth century, aerial photography made it possible to map entire countries from above without ever setting foot on much of the land being recorded.

Today, most people no longer unfold paper maps at all, instead relying on satellite navigation systems that update their position roughly once every second. Yet Dr Foss argues that something has been lost along the way: "A drawn map tells you what a place meant to somebody. A satellite map just tells you where you are standing right now." Whichever kind of map is being read, one thing has remained constant since those first scratched clay tablets: the basic human instinct to make sense of the world by putting it down on paper, or in a grid of light on a screen, so it can be shared with somebody else.

Compare the purposes of the two texts. What is Text 1 trying to do, and what is Text 2 trying to do?

Answer and mark scheme

Question 24

CreditAnswer or working
B1Identifies that Text 1 aims to entertain and intrigue the reader through a fictional mystery
B1Identifies that Text 2 aims to inform the reader about the real history of mapmaking, using facts, dates and expert opinion
B1Compares the two purposes, e.g. Text 1 deliberately withholds information to build suspense, while Text 2 deliberately provides detailed information to build understanding
  • Answer: Text 1 aims to entertain and intrigue the reader through a fictional mystery, deliberately withholding information (such as the meaning of 'still there, listen') to build suspense. Text 2 aims to inform the reader about the real history of mapmaking, using facts, dates and Dr Foss's expert opinion to build understanding rather than mystery.

Question 25 - Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 4

Open the included worksheet

Two Texts: Maps and the People Who Make Them

Original texts written for Revision Library. Text 1 is original short fiction; Text 2 is original non-fiction.

TEXT 1: THE MAP BEHIND THE SHELF (fiction)

Rehan had been sorting books into cardboard boxes for two straight hours when his uncle finally called out from the front counter that they could stop for the day. The bookshop, Whitlock's Rare and Secondhand Books, was closing at the end of the month, and every shelf had to be emptied, checked and boxed before the new owners took over and turned it, according to the sign already taped in the window, into a coffee shop.

It was while he was reaching for the last few books on the highest shelf that Rehan noticed something odd: the shelf itself seemed to wobble slightly, as though it were not properly fixed to the wall behind it. Curious, he pressed his palm flat against the dusty wood and pushed. To his surprise, the whole shelf unit swung outward on a hidden hinge, revealing a narrow gap behind it, no wider than a school ruler, in the brick wall.

Inside the gap, rolled tightly and tied with a length of faded string, was a single sheet of thick, yellowed paper. Rehan's fingers trembled slightly as he worked the knot loose and unrolled it flat across the counter. It was a map, hand-drawn in careful black ink, showing streets Rehan half recognised, though the names beneath them were older, unfamiliar spellings he had never seen on any modern sign.

In one corner, someone had drawn a small, neat cross beside a symbol that looked like a bell, and beside it, in handwriting even smaller than the rest, three words: still there, listen. Rehan turned the map over, searching for anything else, a date, a name, an explanation, but the back of the paper was completely blank.

His uncle appeared in the doorway, keys jangling, ready to lock up for the night. "Whatever you've found, it'll have to wait until tomorrow," he said, glancing at the darkening window. "Whitlock's has been here since 1891, Rehan. Believe me, anything hidden in these walls has waited a great deal longer than one more night." Rehan carefully rolled the map back up, already certain that tomorrow could not come quickly enough.

TEXT 2: READING THE GROUND - A SHORT HISTORY OF MAPMAKING (non-fiction)

Long before satellites circled the Earth taking photographs from space, people were already finding ways to record the shape of the world around them. Some of the oldest known maps are not drawn on paper at all but scratched onto clay tablets, dating back nearly four thousand years, showing rivers, mountains and settlements from a bird's eye view that no ancient mapmaker could possibly have seen with their own eyes.

One of the most influential early mapmakers was Ptolemy, a scholar working in Egypt around AD 150, who collected geographical information from traders and travellers and used it to draw a map of the known world, complete with a grid of lines representing latitude and longitude. Although parts of his map were badly inaccurate, since large areas of the world were still completely unknown to him, his method of using a coordinate grid shaped mapmaking for well over a thousand years afterwards.

"What people often forget," explains Dr Naomi Foss, a historian of cartography, "is that maps were never simply neutral records of geography. Every mapmaker had to decide what mattered enough to include and what could be left out, which meant every map also carried the beliefs, priorities and limitations of the person who drew it." Medieval maps, for example, frequently placed Jerusalem at the exact centre of the world, reflecting religious belief rather than geographical accuracy.

Mapmaking changed dramatically from the fifteenth century onwards, as sailors began crossing oceans further and further from home, gradually filling in the blank spaces on the map with real, measured coastlines. By the eighteenth century, more precise instruments allowed surveyors to measure distance and elevation with far greater accuracy, and by the twentieth century, aerial photography made it possible to map entire countries from above without ever setting foot on much of the land being recorded.

Today, most people no longer unfold paper maps at all, instead relying on satellite navigation systems that update their position roughly once every second. Yet Dr Foss argues that something has been lost along the way: "A drawn map tells you what a place meant to somebody. A satellite map just tells you where you are standing right now." Whichever kind of map is being read, one thing has remained constant since those first scratched clay tablets: the basic human instinct to make sense of the world by putting it down on paper, or in a grid of light on a screen, so it can be shared with somebody else.

Using details from both texts, explain two ways in which maps are shown to be more than just tools for finding your way.

Answer and mark scheme

Question 25

CreditAnswer or working
B1Identifies one way from Text 1, e.g. the map hides a personal mystery and message ('still there, listen') that matters more to Rehan than any practical direction
B1Supports this with a specific quotation or detail from Text 1
B1Identifies one way from Text 2, e.g. maps have historically reflected belief and meaning as much as geography, such as medieval maps placing Jerusalem at the centre of the world
B1Supports this with a specific quotation or detail from Text 2
  • Answer: In Text 1, the map hides a personal mystery and message, 'still there, listen', that matters far more to Rehan than any practical direction it might give. In Text 2, maps are shown to have historically reflected belief and meaning as much as geography, such as medieval maps placing Jerusalem 'at the exact centre of the world, reflecting religious belief rather than geographical accuracy'.

Question 21 - Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 4

Open the included worksheet

Two Texts: Maps and the People Who Make Them

Original texts written for Revision Library. Text 1 is original short fiction; Text 2 is original non-fiction.

TEXT 1: THE MAP BEHIND THE SHELF (fiction)

Rehan had been sorting books into cardboard boxes for two straight hours when his uncle finally called out from the front counter that they could stop for the day. The bookshop, Whitlock's Rare and Secondhand Books, was closing at the end of the month, and every shelf had to be emptied, checked and boxed before the new owners took over and turned it, according to the sign already taped in the window, into a coffee shop.

It was while he was reaching for the last few books on the highest shelf that Rehan noticed something odd: the shelf itself seemed to wobble slightly, as though it were not properly fixed to the wall behind it. Curious, he pressed his palm flat against the dusty wood and pushed. To his surprise, the whole shelf unit swung outward on a hidden hinge, revealing a narrow gap behind it, no wider than a school ruler, in the brick wall.

Inside the gap, rolled tightly and tied with a length of faded string, was a single sheet of thick, yellowed paper. Rehan's fingers trembled slightly as he worked the knot loose and unrolled it flat across the counter. It was a map, hand-drawn in careful black ink, showing streets Rehan half recognised, though the names beneath them were older, unfamiliar spellings he had never seen on any modern sign.

In one corner, someone had drawn a small, neat cross beside a symbol that looked like a bell, and beside it, in handwriting even smaller than the rest, three words: still there, listen. Rehan turned the map over, searching for anything else, a date, a name, an explanation, but the back of the paper was completely blank.

His uncle appeared in the doorway, keys jangling, ready to lock up for the night. "Whatever you've found, it'll have to wait until tomorrow," he said, glancing at the darkening window. "Whitlock's has been here since 1891, Rehan. Believe me, anything hidden in these walls has waited a great deal longer than one more night." Rehan carefully rolled the map back up, already certain that tomorrow could not come quickly enough.

TEXT 2: READING THE GROUND - A SHORT HISTORY OF MAPMAKING (non-fiction)

Long before satellites circled the Earth taking photographs from space, people were already finding ways to record the shape of the world around them. Some of the oldest known maps are not drawn on paper at all but scratched onto clay tablets, dating back nearly four thousand years, showing rivers, mountains and settlements from a bird's eye view that no ancient mapmaker could possibly have seen with their own eyes.

One of the most influential early mapmakers was Ptolemy, a scholar working in Egypt around AD 150, who collected geographical information from traders and travellers and used it to draw a map of the known world, complete with a grid of lines representing latitude and longitude. Although parts of his map were badly inaccurate, since large areas of the world were still completely unknown to him, his method of using a coordinate grid shaped mapmaking for well over a thousand years afterwards.

"What people often forget," explains Dr Naomi Foss, a historian of cartography, "is that maps were never simply neutral records of geography. Every mapmaker had to decide what mattered enough to include and what could be left out, which meant every map also carried the beliefs, priorities and limitations of the person who drew it." Medieval maps, for example, frequently placed Jerusalem at the exact centre of the world, reflecting religious belief rather than geographical accuracy.

Mapmaking changed dramatically from the fifteenth century onwards, as sailors began crossing oceans further and further from home, gradually filling in the blank spaces on the map with real, measured coastlines. By the eighteenth century, more precise instruments allowed surveyors to measure distance and elevation with far greater accuracy, and by the twentieth century, aerial photography made it possible to map entire countries from above without ever setting foot on much of the land being recorded.

Today, most people no longer unfold paper maps at all, instead relying on satellite navigation systems that update their position roughly once every second. Yet Dr Foss argues that something has been lost along the way: "A drawn map tells you what a place meant to somebody. A satellite map just tells you where you are standing right now." Whichever kind of map is being read, one thing has remained constant since those first scratched clay tablets: the basic human instinct to make sense of the world by putting it down on paper, or in a grid of light on a screen, so it can be shared with somebody else.

According to paragraph 3 of Text 1, what did Rehan find rolled and tied with string inside the gap?

Answer and mark scheme

Question 21

CreditAnswer or working
B1A single sheet of thick, yellowed paper (a hand-drawn map)
  • Answer: A single sheet of thick, yellowed paper, which turned out to be a hand-drawn map.

Question 23 - Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1

Open the included worksheet

Reading texts

Text 1: Under the Starling Sky

Original short fiction written for Revision Library.

Priya sat on the damp wooden bench inside the hide, her knees pulled up to her chest, and tried very hard not to fidget. Her uncle Devraj had promised her this would be worth the cold, but so far all she had seen through the narrow viewing slot was a flat grey sky sinking slowly towards a flatter grey marsh.

"They won't come if you keep shuffling about," he whispered, not unkindly, passing her a flask of tea she was too nervous to drink. "Starlings don't like being watched by someone who can't sit still."

Priya tried. She counted the reeds swaying at the edge of the water, silver-tipped where the last of the light caught them. She counted her own breaths. She was halfway through counting the peeling patches of paint on the hide's window frame when Devraj touched her arm and pointed, without a word, towards the horizon.

At first it looked like smoke: a thin, dark smudge rising from somewhere beyond the willows. Then the smudge thickened, and thinned, and thickened again, twisting like a ribbon caught in wind that nobody else could feel. More birds joined from every direction, streaming in from the fields until the smudge became a cloud, and the cloud became something that had no name Priya knew.

It poured itself into shapes: a whale, a spinning top, a hand opening and closing against the darkening sky. Thousands of starlings, tens of thousands, wheeling together so closely that not one of them seemed to touch another, and not one of them seemed to be flying alone. The sound reached the hide a moment later, a vast rushing hush, like the sea folding over itself somewhere far off.

"How do they know where to go?" Priya breathed, forgetting to whisper.

"Nobody's really sure," said Devraj. "Each bird is only watching its closest neighbours, they reckon. No leader. No plan. Just thousands of small decisions, made so fast they look like one big one."

Priya watched the shape roll and fold above the reed beds until, all at once, as though someone had switched off a light, the whole flock dropped from the sky into the reeds and vanished, leaving only their calls, murmuring somewhere below the darkness. Priya realised she had been holding her breath the whole time and let it out slowly, her tea gone cold and forgotten in her hands. She understood, finally, what her uncle had meant: you could not rush a thing like this. You could only wait, and watch, and be ready when it came.

Text 2: The Mystery of the Murmuration

Original non-fiction text written for Revision Library.

Every autumn and winter, in a handful of wetland reserves across Britain, an extraordinary spectacle takes place at dusk. As the light fades, starlings that have spent the day feeding on farmland gather into vast, swirling flocks before dropping down to roost together in reed beds, safe from predators for the night. This behaviour, in which thousands or even hundreds of thousands of birds move as a single shifting shape, is known as a murmuration, a name thought to come from the low, murmuring sound made by so many wingbeats and calls together.

Murmurations can be seen at several well-known sites in the UK, including the Somerset Levels, Gretna Green in Scotland, and Brighton's West Pier, where flocks estimated at over a million birds have occasionally been recorded. The largest gatherings tend to happen in the coldest months, when starlings from as far away as Scandinavia and Eastern Europe fly to Britain to escape harsher winters further east, joining the resident UK population at shared roosting sites.

For a long time, nobody could fully explain how such enormous flocks move together with no apparent leader and no collisions. Early theories suggested some form of telepathy, or that a single bird at the front was somehow directing the others. It was not until scientists in Rome used stereo photography to track individual starlings within a flock, in a series of studies published from 2008 onwards, that a clearer picture began to emerge. Each starling, the researchers found, pays attention to roughly its seven closest neighbours, adjusting its speed and direction to match them almost instantly. When one bird moves, its neighbours respond, and their neighbours respond in turn, so that a single small movement can ripple through an entire flock of thousands within seconds, without any bird needing to see or respond to the whole group at once.

Scientists believe murmurations may help protect starlings from birds of prey such as peregrine falcons, since a shifting, densely packed flock is harder for a predator to target than a single bird flying alone. Despite these dramatic winter displays, however, the UK's breeding starling population has fallen by more than 80 per cent since the 1970s, and the species is now red-listed as a bird of the highest conservation concern. For all their apparent abundance at a winter roost, the starlings gathering above the reed beds each evening are, in fact, a species in trouble.

Using details from both texts, explain two ways in which watching or studying a murmuration is difficult or demanding.

Answer and mark scheme

Question 23

CreditAnswer or working
B1Identifies a valid difficulty with reference to Text 1, e.g. the cold, damp waiting with no guarantee of seeing anything ('so far all she had seen... was a flat grey sky')
B1Explains/develops this first difficulty (e.g. it requires sitting still and being patient for an uncertain length of time)
B1Identifies a valid difficulty with reference to Text 2, e.g. scientists could not explain the behaviour for a long time and needed specialised technology (stereo photography) and years of study (from 2008 onwards)
B1Explains/develops this second difficulty (e.g. understanding the science required careful, patient research rather than simple observation)
  • Answer: In Text 1, watching requires enduring cold, damp waiting with no guarantee of seeing anything, needing patience and stillness. In Text 2, studying murmurations was difficult because scientists could not explain the behaviour for a long time and needed specialised technology and years of research to understand it.

Question 24 - Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1

Open the included worksheet

Reading texts

Text 1: Under the Starling Sky

Original short fiction written for Revision Library.

Priya sat on the damp wooden bench inside the hide, her knees pulled up to her chest, and tried very hard not to fidget. Her uncle Devraj had promised her this would be worth the cold, but so far all she had seen through the narrow viewing slot was a flat grey sky sinking slowly towards a flatter grey marsh.

"They won't come if you keep shuffling about," he whispered, not unkindly, passing her a flask of tea she was too nervous to drink. "Starlings don't like being watched by someone who can't sit still."

Priya tried. She counted the reeds swaying at the edge of the water, silver-tipped where the last of the light caught them. She counted her own breaths. She was halfway through counting the peeling patches of paint on the hide's window frame when Devraj touched her arm and pointed, without a word, towards the horizon.

At first it looked like smoke: a thin, dark smudge rising from somewhere beyond the willows. Then the smudge thickened, and thinned, and thickened again, twisting like a ribbon caught in wind that nobody else could feel. More birds joined from every direction, streaming in from the fields until the smudge became a cloud, and the cloud became something that had no name Priya knew.

It poured itself into shapes: a whale, a spinning top, a hand opening and closing against the darkening sky. Thousands of starlings, tens of thousands, wheeling together so closely that not one of them seemed to touch another, and not one of them seemed to be flying alone. The sound reached the hide a moment later, a vast rushing hush, like the sea folding over itself somewhere far off.

"How do they know where to go?" Priya breathed, forgetting to whisper.

"Nobody's really sure," said Devraj. "Each bird is only watching its closest neighbours, they reckon. No leader. No plan. Just thousands of small decisions, made so fast they look like one big one."

Priya watched the shape roll and fold above the reed beds until, all at once, as though someone had switched off a light, the whole flock dropped from the sky into the reeds and vanished, leaving only their calls, murmuring somewhere below the darkness. Priya realised she had been holding her breath the whole time and let it out slowly, her tea gone cold and forgotten in her hands. She understood, finally, what her uncle had meant: you could not rush a thing like this. You could only wait, and watch, and be ready when it came.

Text 2: The Mystery of the Murmuration

Original non-fiction text written for Revision Library.

Every autumn and winter, in a handful of wetland reserves across Britain, an extraordinary spectacle takes place at dusk. As the light fades, starlings that have spent the day feeding on farmland gather into vast, swirling flocks before dropping down to roost together in reed beds, safe from predators for the night. This behaviour, in which thousands or even hundreds of thousands of birds move as a single shifting shape, is known as a murmuration, a name thought to come from the low, murmuring sound made by so many wingbeats and calls together.

Murmurations can be seen at several well-known sites in the UK, including the Somerset Levels, Gretna Green in Scotland, and Brighton's West Pier, where flocks estimated at over a million birds have occasionally been recorded. The largest gatherings tend to happen in the coldest months, when starlings from as far away as Scandinavia and Eastern Europe fly to Britain to escape harsher winters further east, joining the resident UK population at shared roosting sites.

For a long time, nobody could fully explain how such enormous flocks move together with no apparent leader and no collisions. Early theories suggested some form of telepathy, or that a single bird at the front was somehow directing the others. It was not until scientists in Rome used stereo photography to track individual starlings within a flock, in a series of studies published from 2008 onwards, that a clearer picture began to emerge. Each starling, the researchers found, pays attention to roughly its seven closest neighbours, adjusting its speed and direction to match them almost instantly. When one bird moves, its neighbours respond, and their neighbours respond in turn, so that a single small movement can ripple through an entire flock of thousands within seconds, without any bird needing to see or respond to the whole group at once.

Scientists believe murmurations may help protect starlings from birds of prey such as peregrine falcons, since a shifting, densely packed flock is harder for a predator to target than a single bird flying alone. Despite these dramatic winter displays, however, the UK's breeding starling population has fallen by more than 80 per cent since the 1970s, and the species is now red-listed as a bird of the highest conservation concern. For all their apparent abundance at a winter roost, the starlings gathering above the reed beds each evening are, in fact, a species in trouble.

Which text do you think gives a more powerful sense of the scale of a starling murmuration, Text 1 or Text 2? Support your answer with evidence and language analysis from at least one text.

Answer and mark scheme

Question 24

CreditAnswer or working
1-2Level 1 States a preference with little or no justification; minimal or no textual reference.
3-4Level 2 Gives a clear opinion supported by relevant reference or quotation from at least one text, with some comment on effect.
5-6Level 3 Gives a well-reasoned, developed opinion supported by precise, well-chosen references from at least one text (ideally both), with perceptive analysis of language or structure and its effect on the reader's sense of scale.
  • Indicative content:
    • Text 1: imaginative imagery and character response, e.g. 'the smudge became a cloud, and the cloud became something that had no name Priya knew', 'thousands of starlings, tens of thousands, wheeling together', and Priya holding her breath
    • Text 2: precise statistics and factual detail, e.g. 'flocks estimated at over a million birds', 'roughly its seven closest neighbours', 'fallen by more than 80 per cent', and named real locations
    • Either viewpoint is acceptable if well supported by precise textual evidence
    • Credit comparative analysis of how narrative technique (Text 1: imagery, character, emotion) versus factual exposition (Text 2: statistics, direct statement) creates a sense of scale differently
    • Reward a genuine personal response with clear textual justification and understanding of the writer's craft

Answer: Strong answers can argue for either text, provided the opinion is supported with precise, well-chosen evidence and analysis of how language or structure conveys scale (e.g. Text 1's imagery and character reflection versus Text 2's precise statistics).

11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbooks runs to 10 volumes

Book 7 of 10 · 846 pages in the set

Each book is a separate free PDF.

Volume 1

83 pp · 161 Qs

Comprehension: Fiction, Comprehension: Fiction: Practice Set 2, Comprehension: Fiction Set 3 and 4 more

Volume 2

87 pp · 178 Qs

Comprehension: Fiction Set 8, Comprehension: Fiction Set 9, Comprehension: Fiction Set 10 and 4 more

Volume 3

68 pp · 130 Qs

Comprehension: Non-Fiction, Comprehension: Non-Fiction: Practice Set 2, Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 3 and 3 more

Volume 4

75 pp · 174 Qs

Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 7, Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 8, Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 9 and 4 more

Volume 5

115 pp · 238 Qs

Comprehension: Poetry, Comprehension: Poetry: Practice Set 2, Comprehension: Poetry Set 2 and 7 more

Volume 6

79 pp · 144 Qs

Comprehension: Classic-Style Fiction, Comprehension: Classic Fiction Set 2, Comprehension: Classic Fiction Set 3 and 3 more

Volume 7 · this book

97 pp · 136 Qs

Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 1, Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 2, Comprehension: Mixed-Genre Set 3 and 4 more

Volume 8

78 pp · 126 Qs

Persuasive and Discursive Writing Focus, Persuasive and Discursive Writing Focus Set 2, Grammar Gap-Fill and 2 more

Volume 9

77 pp · 127 Qs

SPaG: Mixed Timed Test, SPaG Mixed Drill Set 2, Vocabulary in Context and 1 more

Volume 10

87 pp · 219 Qs

Cloze and Sentence Completion Set 2, Cloze and Sentence Completion Set 3, Cloze and Sentence Completion Set 4 and 3 more

More 11+ books

11+ English Exam Papers Set A

100 pp · 265 Qs

GL-Style English and Verbal Reasoning Mock, GL-Style English and Verbal Reasoning Mock 2, Warwickshire (GL)-Style Mixed Mock and 2 more

Want a different mix of topics?