Worked question 19 - Memory and Primary Storage
Discuss the likely effect of this upgrade on the laptop's performance, and explain the circumstances in which further increasing the RAM would provide little or no additional benefit.
In your answer you should refer to:
- the relationship between RAM size, secondary storage use and performance
- the role of the CPU and cache in overall performance
- the idea of diminishing returns
Answer and mark scheme
Question 19
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 1-2 | Level 1 Basic, isolated statement(s), e.g. 'more RAM makes it faster', with little or no justification. Limited or no use of appropriate technical terms. Answer is not clearly linked to the scenario. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 Shows some understanding of how RAM size affects performance (e.g. reduces reliance on slower virtual memory/secondary storage), with some justification. The discussion may be one-sided or not fully developed, and diminishing returns/the role of the CPU and cache may be only briefly mentioned. Some appropriate technical terms used. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 A coherent, well-developed discussion that explains how increasing RAM reduces reliance on (slower) virtual memory up to a point, and explains that once RAM is large enough to hold everything the CPU currently needs, further increases give diminishing returns because performance is then limited by other components such as the CPU and cache. The answer is logically structured and uses appropriate technical terminology throughout. |
- Indicative content:
- Before the upgrade, if 8 GB of RAM was often full, the operating system would have to use virtual memory (secondary storage) to store data that did not fit in RAM
- Secondary storage (HDD/SSD) is much slower to access than RAM, so relying on virtual memory slows the computer down
- Increasing RAM to 16 GB means more data/programs can be held in RAM at once, reducing how often virtual memory is needed
- This is likely to noticeably improve performance if the laptop was previously running out of RAM
- However, if the tasks the student runs never actually needed more than 8 GB, having 16 GB gives little or no extra benefit (diminishing returns)
- Overall performance also depends on the CPU (clock speed, number of cores) and cache size, not just the amount of RAM
- If the CPU itself is slow, or the cache is small, adding more RAM will not fix these bottlenecks
- Therefore performance gains from adding RAM depend on what was actually limiting performance beforehand
Answer: Level 3 response expected: increasing RAM reduces virtual memory use (improving performance) up to the point where RAM already meets demand, after which further RAM gives diminishing returns because the CPU/cache become the limiting factor.



