Worked question 13 - The Earth and its Atmosphere
Answer and mark scheme
Question 13
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 1-2 | Level 1 Simple statements are made about climate change or human activity, with little or no linking of evidence to conclusions. Limited or no use of scientific terminology. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 Some relevant evidence and human activities are described and linked to increasing greenhouse gas concentrations and/or rising temperature, with some reasoning. Discussion of ways to reduce CO2 concentration is mostly descriptive rather than evaluative. Scientific terminology is used with some accuracy. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 A well-reasoned and detailed evaluation is given, using evidence (e.g. ice core data, direct atmospheric measurements, the timing of industrialisation) to support the conclusion that human activity is a major cause of recent warming, while acknowledging natural factors and the limits of the evidence. A range of appropriate methods to reduce atmospheric CO2 are discussed with reference to their effectiveness or limitations. Scientific terminology is used accurately throughout. |
- Indicative content:
- Ice cores contain trapped air bubbles that allow scientists to measure past atmospheric CO2 concentrations and estimate past temperatures, going back hundreds of thousands of years.
- These records show that CO2 concentration and global temperature have historically risen and fallen together (a correlation).
- Since the industrial revolution (roughly 200-250 years ago), CO2 concentration has risen much faster than at any previous point shown by ice core data, closely matching the large-scale burning of fossil fuels.
- The enhanced greenhouse effect provides a credible scientific mechanism directly linking rising CO2 and methane concentrations to rising average temperature.
- Natural factors, such as volcanic activity and variation in the Sun's output, do affect temperature, but cannot fully account for the size or speed of the recent warming.
- The strength and consistency of evidence from several independent sources (ice cores, direct atmospheric measurements since the 1950s, global temperature records) supports the conclusion that human activity is a major cause of recent warming.
- Ways to reduce future CO2 concentration include: switching to renewable or low-carbon energy sources (wind, solar, nuclear) to reduce fossil fuel burning; improving energy efficiency and insulation to reduce energy demand; carbon capture and storage at power stations; reducing deforestation and increasing afforestation (planting trees) to increase CO2 removal; international agreements between governments to set emissions targets.
- Each method has limitations (e.g. cost, scalability, reliability, time needed to implement), which should be weighed against its potential to reduce emissions.
Answer: Indicative content only - assessed against the levels of response mark scheme above; no single fixed answer.







