Worked question 12 - Respiration and Photosynthesis
Explain how increasing carbon dioxide concentration and increasing light intensity can each affect the rate of photosynthesis in the cucumber plants, and why increasing carbon dioxide concentration will not always increase the rate of photosynthesis.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 12
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 1-2 | Level 1 Basic, isolated statements about factors needed for photosynthesis (e.g. light or carbon dioxide is needed), with little or no reference to the idea of a limiting factor. Limited use of scientific vocabulary. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 A clear explanation of how increasing light intensity or carbon dioxide concentration increases the rate of photosynthesis while that factor is limiting, with some reference to another factor eventually becoming limiting. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 A full, logically linked explanation covering both light intensity and carbon dioxide concentration, correctly applying the concept of limiting factors, and clearly explaining why the rate levels off once a different factor becomes limiting, related to the glasshouse context. |
- Indicative content:
- Photosynthesis requires light energy, carbon dioxide, water and chlorophyll, and produces glucose and oxygen
- Increasing light intensity increases the rate of photosynthesis because more light energy is available to drive the reaction, as long as light intensity is the limiting factor
- Increasing carbon dioxide concentration increases the rate of photosynthesis because carbon dioxide is a raw material, as long as carbon dioxide is the limiting factor
- Whichever factor is in shortest supply relative to what is needed limits the overall rate (the limiting factor)
- Beyond a certain point, carbon dioxide (or light) is no longer limiting, so a different factor, such as temperature or the other resource, becomes limiting and the rate levels off
- A paraffin heater releases both carbon dioxide and heat, so it can raise temperature as well as carbon dioxide concentration, which may allow the rate to increase further if temperature was previously limiting
- Very high temperatures can denature the enzymes controlling photosynthesis reactions, reducing the rate, so there is an optimum temperature
- The market gardener aims to keep all factors (light, carbon dioxide, temperature) close to optimum together, rather than increasing only one, in order to maximise yield
Answer: Increasing light intensity increases the rate when light is limiting; increasing carbon dioxide concentration increases it when carbon dioxide is limiting. If light is low, extra carbon dioxide has little effect, and once carbon dioxide is sufficient, extra carbon dioxide will not raise the rate. The rate then levels off because another factor, such as light, temperature or water, becomes limiting. Increasing light likewise has little effect when carbon dioxide or another factor is limiting. The heater also adds heat, so the gardener should keep light, carbon dioxide and temperature near their optima together.







